TiVo Fast Forward Banner Ads Return
from the this-space-for-rent dept
TiVo has long been trying to derail Hollywood efforts to have DVR fast-forwarding banned by reaching some kind of middle ground. A few years back, "lucky" TiVo customers were automatically selected by the company (whether they liked it or not) to take part in a new trial of technology that bombarded them with additional ads if they tried to fast forward through commercials. Only viewable by test participants, the ads were usually random banner ads for TiVo partners. After a brief hiatus the fast forward banner ads have apparently returned, this time designed so you'll see an ad for the company whose commercial you were trying to avoid in the first place. Since many TiVo users pay monthly subscriptions on top of pricey hardware costs largely to avoid ads, it's akin to having to watch a Coke TV commercial in a movie theater after shelling out ten bucks for a feature film. If that annoys you, these ads probably will too. As previously mentioned, broadcasters complain over ample "lost" revenue from ad skipping -- revenue they'd regain if advertisers and DVR manufacturers were more innovative and less annoying. While TiVo has tinkered with some user interactive advertising -- having users press a "thumbs up" button for more product info barely qualifies as a creative solution. A better solution is offering interesting advertising users don't want to skip in the first place.
Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.
Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.
While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.
–The Techdirt Team
Reader Comments
Subscribe: RSS
View by: Time | Thread
[ link to this | view in thread ]
i want the big mac
i wonder if that counts as subliminal advertising since its going so fast.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
subliminal?
I doubt if it's (hang on, I'm just getting a Coke) really having any (that was good, think I'll have another) effect on ME! :-))
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Dont be too quick to dismiss the pecuniary motive. Ad-supported services have been tried before. What if tivo users got a break on their bill in exchange for having to view those extra ads.
Uhh... wait, isnt this _television_? And isnt your product partially built around circumventing that business model? Don't put a lot of faith in it..
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: i want the big mac
[ link to this | view in thread ]
The 30 Second Skip:
http://www.bigmarv.net/how/tivo30secondskip.html
Every TiVo can do a 30 second skip - you just have to enable it. Here's how you do it:
1 Start playing any recording.
2 During playback press:
Select - Play - Select - 3 - 0 - Select
3 You should hear three bongs (if you don't have the TiVo sounds disabled), and you're done.
Your "skip to beginning/end" button (the arrow pointing to a line) is now a 30 second skip button. During fast-forwarding or rewinding, the button will still "skip to tick."
To turn the feature off, repeat the three steps.
Important note: this feature is set to "off" at default on restarts. So if your TiVo restarts or loses power, the feature will be turned back off. Just enter the code again while watching a recording to re-enable it.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Ads
[ link to this | view in thread ]
That's besides the point.
Try this.
Show the commercial, place a small banner, 1/4 the screen below the moving picture, animated it like a simple ad for the internet, so it can be viewed effectively on DVR when run at high speeds. This could also be used to have website or phone numbers for the regular video commercial.
Benefit: Ads are nearly removed from DVR users but the companies still get the revenue they are looking for
Downside: You pay to skip the damn ads, you still see the damn ads
Suggestions: Use The Office as an example, product placement is what makes that show work. Remember the Staples Salad/Paper shredder...brilliant. I didn't even realize it was a product placement until the staples commercial during the break showed it(which I forwarded through btw)
[ link to this | view in thread ]
or you could..
It's not hard to do, it's actually easier than using tivo. Setup uTorrent or mIRC to read an rss-feed and automatically download the file you want. Living on the westcoast I get the episodes before they actually *air* over here from atlantic cappers.
At the end of it all you can even burn the episodes to dvd and create your own compilation discs well before the official show season dvds appear.
It's just easier. Not that I don't think you should buy the seasons of worthwhile shows (like House MD for example).
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: or you could..
Plus, if you get home from working 8 hours infront of the computer and just want to veg watching TV shows for the next 5 hours until you sleep; whatever your download speeds are, and your searching skills, you will never be able to watch the all the shows you want to watch from BT, as you would if they were just easily recorded on a DVR while you were at work
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Panasonic DVRs
So, when watching something that I recorded and a commercial 'session' comes on, pressing 'CM-Skip' 4 times in quick succession takes care of that problem.
If you are in the market for a standalone DVR, then try the ones from Panasonic.
No, I do not work for the company, or anyone that sells them. I just happen to own one.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Re: or you could..
also, and i'm not sure how many places implement this, but azureus (the best bt client) allows for RSS feeds of your shows, i know for a fact you can automatically start downloading the new episode of lost as soon as it's available. for the most part, i've gotten into the habit of watching my shows a day after they air on tv. it's convenient, i have them permanently backed up (which is nice for re-watching the office) and i don't have to pay for tv and internet, just internet.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
OR
[ link to this | view in thread ]
GB-PVR.. better than Tivo.
It seriously rocks and can do so much more than DVR duties IF you want it to.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
WTF
[ link to this | view in thread ]
The Easier way to skip commercials
It's quite liberating really. You don't actually need TV for anything. Get something like NetFlix instead, watch movies at your own convenience. Watch TV shows at your own convenience.
Do it all without a cable subscription. Why are you paying that much money for something that aggravates that much? Just do something else.
Just stop sending the message that the intrusiveness of advertising is "ok by you".
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Could be worse.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
What if...
What if TiVo users purchased the Tivo in order to avoid ads in the first place?
[ link to this | view in thread ]
That's why Tivo sucks
People think Tivo is great because they have only compared it to VCRs and to crappy cable DVRs like Scientific Atlantic -- what a flaming piece of poo that DVR is.
I briefly owned a Tivo back in 2000 and promptly returned it as unsatisfactory. I have no regrets.
I own an Ultimate TV and love it. If you have ever owned an Ultimate TV, you would never want to touch a Tivo. I refuse to upgrade to high def because they don't make Ultimate TVs anymore. The joy of using the UTV surpasses even the joy of high def. I had a high def cable DVR for one year when I lived in a condo where I couldn't get Directv. I left at the end of my lease because of that.
The bottom line is that there is at least one DVR that is light years past Tivo. Unfortunately, you can't buy Ultimate TVs anymore, and I doubt many owners of these wonderful machines will part with them. When you get a 30-second skip, you never want to go back to fast-forwarding. Tivo users don't know what they are missing. It's like having an orgasm.
Fortunately, there may be hope. I have heard that Replay makes good DVRs. I don't think they have the 30-second skip anymore. They also got rid of the ability to copy the program from the DVR to the PC. So I don't know how good Replays are anymore.
Another option is a Windows Media Center PC. Since Microsoft either developed or bought out the developers of Ultimate TV (don't know which), I suspect that the UI for Media Center is good. The Ultimate TV interface makes Tivo look like a farting orangutan. I suppose that if I were to ever replace my Ultimate TV I would go with Media Center as long as it worked with Directv (don't know if it does though).
The final option is open-source DVR software coupled with a tuner. MythTV and Freevo are the most popular. However, they are time consuming and a pain to set up and they rely on a third party tuner/capture card like Haugepage. These tuner/capture cards have to re-encode the video, which lowers quality, and I think they only work with a cable box that already decodes the signal. I don't know if anyone has gotten them to work with Directv, but I'd love to hear some stories.
The bottom line is that you don't want to use Tivo or cable-company DVRs. There are alternatives like Media Center, Directv and Dish DVRs, and (if you have lots of free time and patience) open source DVR software. So get out of Tivo. They will never care about their customers and things are just going to get worse with them.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: The Easier way to skip commercials
The one thing that has kept me from doing that is that I like to watch specials on the Discovery Channel, the Science Channel, Animal Planet, the History channel, etc. I am also concerned that I won't even know which series I want to watch if I don't have a TV service. For example, the Science Channel recently played an old series by Carol Sagan called "The Cosmos". I plan to purchase the DVDs for these series, but I wouldn't have even known about this series if I didn't watch the Science Channel.
Any thoughts about this matter?
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: or you could..
I recently tried to download an episode of the Simpsons, The Wife Aquatic, that was interrupted by a football game on my local channel. I tried using bittorent, Limewire, and Sharezella. Not a single one could download such a file even though there were dozens of files listed as match.
Whenever I tried to download one of these files, I always get "need more sources." If I click on "find more sources" it waits for 10 minutes and then replies "need more sources."
How exactly is bittorent easy to use or reliable? Heck, it's not like I'm even trying to download illegal content. I'm trying to download a low definition show broadcast on a public, unencrypted channel from free (as in beer) TV. If you can't even get that from bittorent, it's useless.
If there is anyone who has actually had success in using bittorent, please write in detail how you got it to work.
[ link to this | view in thread ]