Can Dropping Fees Revitalize eBay?
from the time-to-reinvent dept
Over the past few months, more and more people have been noticing that eBay seems to have stagnated. Sure, it's been making plenty of money and still gets a ton of traffic, but it's not growing as fast as people would like, and there are numerous signs that it's starting to plateau. With Meg Whitman stepping down and John Donahue stepping up to the CEO position, the company has now announced lower fees and "tightened" seller standards to try to cut down on the rampant fraud that has managed to scare off many potential eBay buyers. Amusingly, this lowered fee comes just a day after new research hyped up how much eBay was saving people. The researchers behind the report suggested that, if the economy does go into a real recession, eBay should benefit as people switch to eBay searching for bargains. If that were truly the case, though, then it would seem eBay wouldn't have to be cutting fees.The real problem may simply be that eBay is too constrained by its own success. It's attempts at branching out with things like Skype and StumbleUpon certainly haven't done much to help eBay, as the eagerly prayed-for synergies turned out to not exist. eBay's own attempts at revitalizing its core business have been equally pointless. So, it seems like something of a desperation play to lower fees, but it's difficult to see it having much of an impact. Certainly, it will make eBay sellers happier, but the transaction fees aren't the barrier eBay is facing in staying relevant. In fact, eBay itself should know this. When Yahoo tried to compete with eBay, it's key selling point was lower transaction costs for sellers, and that didn't do much to attract users.
eBay finds itself in a tough position. If it changes anything in its core business too drastically, it risks alienating those who helped bring the company to its current position. But, not changing will continue the stagnation process and certainly make the hole it needs to dig itself out of that much deeper. In figuring out a new path, it may want to take a few lessons from Amazon, which has been successfully reinventing itself from the inside with its web services offerings, while still striving to keep its core userbase satisfied. Amazon recognized that it could expand into a non-competing business that leveraged its strengths. While some might say that's what eBay tried to do with Skype, that was an acquisition, rather than a ground up offering, and it's still never been clearly explained what synergies there are between the two. In contrast, Amazon's web services offering clearly builds on its experience managing large scale backend operations, as well as its ability to handle a massive number of transactions. eBay probably should be trying to become the "Kinkos" of the web -- a small business's ideal partner -- but has yet to figure out how to do so.
Update: As noted in the comments and elsewhere, this isn't so much a cut in rates as a change in rates. For many sellers, the fees will actually be higher.
Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.
Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.
While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.
–The Techdirt Team
Reader Comments
Subscribe: RSS
View by: Time | Thread
For example, five years ago, camera phones didn't exist, nor did VisualStudio, or the iPod. eBay's lost it's "Grarage Sale" athmosphere, and is now it seems too commercial. For example, Circuit City sells on there. Heh...
Bring Meg Whitman Back!
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I won't have much to do with eBay until...
Fraud, fraud, and more fraud eBay. That's why you aren't growing.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: I won't have much to do with eBay until...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
If ebay was interested in helping itself, it would reverse that algorithm. You should charge more when the seller does NOT make the sale. Otherwise you are just trying to be a retail chain without having to pay the taxes.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I crossed them off my list.
Secondly, the auction model loses effectiveness as scale increases. The point of auctions is to find value by recognizing it better than your fellow shoppers. When your fellow shoppers are the whole world, that's not too easy. Now I just use eBay for really odd items or as a real-world street price research tool.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
eBay Stores?
I don't think that is true. eBay stores is an example of being a small business's ideal partner.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Ebay
The last one is a biggy. I'm tired of running a very strict search and getting a dozen pages of results to wade through when most are multiple listings of identical items by the same few sellers. I'm also tired of all the garbage misleading, overly broad, or non-descriptive titles. For the first group let me block sellers listings from my results.
I used to spend several thousand a year on Ebay. Now I visit if and only if I have no alternative source.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Dropping Fees (see: poorly masking increases)
By their own numbers, let's look at this 'lower' fee structure:
The insertion fee on a $25 auction will drop from $1.20 to $1.00 - a savings of 20 cents; With the final value fee jumping from 5.25% to 8.75% (yes, that's raising the final value fee for that auction by 66.7%), that would mean that the final value fee on that item would go from $1.31 to $2.19 - an extra 88 cents (or net increase of 66 cents) into eBay's back pocket. Since the majority of auctions are payed for through eBay's subsidiary company, PayPal, there is an extra (roughly) 5% going to the company; they charge 35 cents, plus 4.9% for each transaction they handle that's paid for by credit card, America's favorite way to pay.
So let's look at a typical eBay seller who is selling flash memory, coffee makers, or anything else that might roughly sell for 25 bucks. It will cost one dollar to list it, $2.19 when they sell it, then $1.58 ($1.23 + the 35 cents) when they sell it... WAIT, W A I T, wait a minute... that's right, PayPal collects its' fee on the ENTIRE amount received, including what the seller received for the shipping cost; so if it costs $8.75 to ship that coffee maker or whatever it is, then PayPal is collecting on $33.75 ($1.65 + 35 cents), for an actual total of $2.00. All together, eBay/PayPal is taking $5.19 from that $25.00, or 20.76% (remember that you have to deduct it from the $25, not the $33.75, because the seller has to use that $8.75 to actually ship the item). So, even if the seller is able to double the price he paid for the coffee maker - doubtful though, that a seller is going to be able to get new coffee makers that retail for 25 bucks for only $12.50 - but let's assume he can, then his profit on every $25.00 sale after he pays for his merchandise is ($12.50 - $5.19) $7.31, not including gas to take it to the Post Office, UPS Store, or wherever. Now if eBay/PayPal together were getting about 10%, that would leave our coffee maker guy with about 10 bucks profit, or an extra $17.00 for every hundred than he'll be getting starting in February.
I think if eBay started figuring out how they can make the site more enticing for both buyers and sellers, instead of how they can wring every nickel possible out of the sellers, there would be a lot more profit to go around for everybody, and they wouldn't have to worry so much about the looming threat of Amazon, Kijiji, Craigslist, and everyone else who actually makes it worthwhile for a seller to use their site.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Dropping Fees (see: poorly masking increases)
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
A different view from a veteran Ebay seller
Also, my selling experience has been that the buyers of more costly items are wonderful customers. The riff raff buyers who buy penny merchandise make lousy customers, complainers, whiners and negative feedback leavers. So I set my sights high from the first year, and have never had to deal with the PITA buyers that most sellers complain about.
In my eighth year as a seller, I have a four thousand plus positive feedback rating, and only three negs, left in my first year of Ebay selling, by miserable buyers of items costing less than $5. So I fired those losers early on in my selling career, simply by selling higher priced merchandise, and I have always been happy as an Ebay seller. I beg Ebay RAISE the fees. Please, don't make it cheaper to sell on Ebay. Make it more expensive.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: A different view from a veteran Ebay seller
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
No Changes for Casual Sellers
For regular sellers, not the stores or power sellers, the higher Final Value fee mean less profit but doesn't have any extra services provided.
I THINK the galleries are free for everyone but still doesn't cover higher overall fee charged by eBay...
and why doesn't still eBay allow Google Checkout system?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Best way to increase traffic
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Agreed!
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Agreed!
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Why Shipping Is So High
Figure it out. 20 cent listing fee + 30 cent paypal fee + 5 cent Final value fee + $1.41 postage + shipping materials and that's where your $3.50 comes from.
eBay has stuck it to the very people who created their wealth, the low level seller who sells the odd item that you can't find elsewhere.
I am a powerseller and once my inventory is sold, I'll be done with eBay. eBay has cheated me for the last time.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Why Shipping Is So High
If you want to charge for shipping and handling, that's fine. But the $0.20 listing fee, $0.30 cent PayPal fee, etc., should be covered by your gross profit on the item.
Specifically, it is forbidden by eBay rules to add charges that cover your eBay or PayPal fees. The only way they police this is if you directly ask for that in the auction, but the spirit is obviously "price your item to sell so that it covers your fees and gives you the profit you want".
Personally, I don't really care if you (or other sellers) want to scam the system to avoid final value fees by selling for $0.01 and charging $50.00 shipping. If the item is worth $50.01 to me, I'll buy it. If not, I won't. It's undeniably part of the problem that many buyers only think about the actual bid, and not the final cost (including shipping and insurance).
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Why Shipping Is So High
First without quality low volume and high volume sellers ebay would be nothing, after all this is where ebay makes its money, from the sellers not from the buyers!!! The sellers are ebays really true customers.
Second as a buyer there is really no protection from ebay that they proudly tout. They use feedback which I consider a joke. they won't even look at an issue. By not taking care of there good sellers and buyers they are getting what they deserve, the fees should be going to provide some form of service.
I used to be able to sell my baby shoes for 6-10 dollars, now I would be lucky to get a bid on them for .99 cents. For that I will just take them to the local goodwill store and save my time and money. Ebay has truly lost interest from buyers and sellers because the only thing they are interested in is there bottom line. As a seller just like ebay I have to be able to make money to stay in business.
There fees are such a rip off, I figure they take anywhere from 15 to 25 % right off the top.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
From the announcement page: sellers with a high percentage of buyer dissatisfaction will receive reduced visibility in Best Match search. Also, because excessive shipping and handling continues to be one of the biggest pain points for buyers, sellers with the worst DSRs for shipping and handling charges will see a decrease in their listings exposure, as well.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Ebay's shooting itself in the foot
Now with this news, she and others are questioning if it's worth it to stay. Reading the new changes, sellers are being screwed by ebay with their "bait and switch" fee system. Sure, they tell people they're lowering fees but tend to ignore the fact they're raising fees to 8.75% on sold items.
Add in transaction fees, Paypal fees, and wow. Buyers will ultimately be hosed because sellers WILL make this up by either raising the value of their goods, making it worthless to use ebay to find items for less, or can the fees into their "handling" charge, which ebay is also going to nix.
Ebay hit its peak 2 years ago and has been going downhill ever since. While their business continues to "thrive" (remember, they've raised fees several times since inception), buyers like myself have returned to Amazon for very good reason: We KNOW we're not going to get screwed at Amazon.
Like anything else in America, once greed hits the picture, it all goes to hell in a handbasket. Ebay is just another victim because people just don't understand what it takes to maintain supply and demand but instead look for the "quick buck".
Ebay needs to do much more than restructure its (screw you over) fee system and, as the article states, they're way to big to do it now without offending someone.
I can only sit back and laugh while giving Amazon my money.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Amazon can eat eBay's lunch any time it decides to
You can list things for sale on Amazon and **they don't charge a new listing fee every week**. And if you pay them $40 a month for a storefront, they let you create thousands of pages for a wide variety of items without making you renew the listing. And Amazon has millions of customers.
eBay has a storefront program, but they charge you a listing fee every month and a rather high percentage for the transaction, and extra fees for credit card clearing if you use PayPal as everyone does.
What's keeping Amazon from taking over the eBay ecological niche? They are not organized in terms of categories the way eBay is. Their search mechanism is not quite as good. Feedback is still primitive. And... people don't yet go there looking for the collectible kinds of things they find on eBay. Not enough customers, not enough offerings; chicken::egg.
However, that hasn't stopped various people from trying to offer collectible items for sale. An unfortunate side effect of the dealers' attempts to use the Amazon Marketplace for small, collectible, and niche items is the number of dead listing pages that come up on a search, the result of offerings of unique items that sold, or were taken off sale. This is a consequence of Amazon's original model of retail sales of high-volume, commercially widely available standard items.
In the Marketplace for used books, there are only so many titles/editions ever published; once those all have a listing page, no more listing pages need be created. This is not the case with souvenirs of Paris. Amazon needs to hire a few more people, or some smart AI software, to clear out the deadwood. (While they're at it, they could merge the multiple listings for identical items, created by dealers who failed to find the existing listing pages that cover their title/edition.)
eBay, with a stroke of the pen, could compete with Amazon in this market. It simply has to decide that its current pricing model, even as modified by the latest changes, is out of date. But it's huge, and rich, and stuffed to gills with time-servers who are afraid to endanger the income stream. So we get deck-chair rearranging like this latest bit.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
eBay's Increased Fees and Those Outrageous Shippin
And speaking of fraud... I have had, and will always have a problem with sellers who grossly inflate their shipping fees in order to cover expenses and/or to avoid eBay's now increased final value fees. All I ask is that a seller list the CORRECT USPS or UPS fees to ship an item and to come straight with their actual costs. Some years ago there was talk of the need for Federal regulation to control eBay's ongoing tolerance of shipping fraud. eBay responded by instituting their almost useless "Gosh... did they over-charge you on shipping again?" feedback system.
The message is simple: YO EBAY BRASS... WAKE UP!!! CONTROL THE FRAUD IN YOUR BACKYARD before the Feds do it for you. If you refuse to get your house in order... and continue with 'business as usual'... count on your loyal customer base to flee the sinking ship for the greener pastures at Amazon and the like. What does it take to get through to you guys???
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Can someone please explain to me the requirement that a huge company grow? If a company continues to make money hand over fist, why is it necessary that they make *more* money than last year?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I used to be a regular eBay shopper
Besides, nearly everything on eBay ends up going for close to market price anyway, so the savings really are insignificant. Things that do go for less than Market do so because they are either used or refurbs.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Alternative to eBay
I found out more info at ukebid.com
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
eBay Rates
EBay also stopped charging extra for photos. This is good because it lowers the cost to list even more. Sure the cost to sell has gone up, but the cost to _try_ to sell has gone down. It has to do with marginal revenue.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Market will correct itself
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Ebay Security
The lax security that Ebay has used on their site is finally coming around on them and they are losing users big time. It serves them right. Couple the lax security with the insane shipping price increases and Ebay has run it's course. I closed my account last year and I say good riddance. You reap what you sow.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Ebay Security
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Alternative to ebay is the best solution
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Alternative to ebay is the best solution
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
EBay will continue on ......
They are doing what's best for them and I'm gonna do what's best for me. Right now seems like they are trying t screw over CRAIGSLIST too.
We pay the high fees to list, sell, final value fees, and then PAYPAL fees. I started taking MONEY orders seemed like I made more money but it takes longer
I can't make a profit on paypal/ebay. I think a lot of people are simply advertising on there and selling it off site. I did that a few times I had people contact me and they came to my area and I met them next door got cash. I had to make up some of my losses. PHUCK EBay/Paypal
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Did eBay ever realize that their CUSTOMERS are their SELLERS?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
ebay shipping
[ link to this | view in chronology ]