PayPal Helping The IRS Track Down Tax Cheats
from the so,-please-launder-elsewhere dept
A few years ago, in a widely publicized article, eBay's liaison to law enforcement proudly talked about how the company would hand over all sorts of info to law enforcement if asked (even without a subpoena). So, it shouldn't come as much of a surprise eBay-owned PayPal is helping the IRS track down tax cheats by handing over the identity of customers using PayPal from a variety of well known tax havens. Of course, anyone who thought it was a smart idea to launder money through PayPal probably shouldn't be all that surprised when federal investigators show up on their doorstep.
Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.
Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.
While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.
–The Techdirt Team
Reader Comments
Subscribe: RSS
View by: Time | Thread
No Subject Given
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: No Subject Given
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: No Subject Given
not everyone loves giving up their identity when trying to even the playing field against a large, crooked corporate entity such as Paypal. The claims being made on paypalsucks.com are quite valid - right from Paypal's own terms of service. That info needs to be diseminated. I'd never heard of that site until this thread but I have avoided paypal for years because of the reasons listed on that site.
As far as anonimity goes: could be that it's not so much that people want to hide their identity as maybe they don't have a blog they sink 4 hrs a day into that they feel compelled to keep linking to on other sites.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
No Subject Given
AboutPayPal.org
consumeraffairs.com, PayPal - Complaints from Buyers
consumeraffairs.com, PayPal - Complaints from Sellers
CNN.com
blossom.com, Consumer complaints about PayPal
AbiWord Fund Robbed
PaypalWarning.com
Jayde.com
American Express, RE:PayPal Complaints in excess of $3.2 million
If there wasnt such a problem with paypal.com, there would not be this many websites.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: No Subject Given
1. re: PayPalSucks.com... "Next-to-nothing about themselves." I had a page detailing my origins with PayPal and eBay, but took it down for reasons you'll read below in just a moment. The origins of the site are well documented in press articles about the site. I was just a regular user of PayPal from it's earliest years (one of the first 10,000 to sign up). When I had a question about PayPal. I called and when the person could not answer the question, they hung up on me. At the time I made the first call, I was 100% Pro-PayPal. I was nice, cordial and pleasant on the phone. When the person I spoke with could not answer the question, I asked to speak to someone who could. I was disconnected. So I called back. I thought I was disconnected because they were transferring me to another person. I called back, got a different person, went through the same questions only to be told "that information is not disclosed." I was confused and asked again and this time I was told "Look, I've told you all that I'm going to tell you!" and then they hung up on me. Have you ever called a company and been hung up on? Ever been spoken to that way? Now I was a little pissed but more shocked. So I waited a day and called back and this time insisted on talking to a supervisor. After some time I talked to a person who would only identify themselves as "John" and after a few minutes with him, he hung up on me. 3 times in 2 days? That is outrageous. So I registered the domain PayPalSucks.com and put up a blank page. A month later I checked and found 90 people had typed in "paypalsucks.com" in their browser to get to my blank page. So I put up a guest book to see what/why they were coming there. W/in a week the guestbook had 100 posts from people complaining about PayPal. In addition we had at least one post from a PayPal employee (verified by IP) dropping so-not-so-flattering information about PayPal. That information is saved here: http://www.paypalsucks.com/PayPalWhistleBlower1.shtml
Very quickly it became obvious the guestbook was not the best way to handle the complaints so the forum was put up. Again, within weeks we had hundreds of posts...
The rest, as they say, is history.
I used to have my phone number on the site and whois information. But the threatening and hate filled phone calls (including one death threat.) ended that. We also had very vile and hate filled posts from PayPal employees (verified by IP) and so that's when I decided it's better to keep my personal information personal (and at the time I still had my PayPal account and feared someone at PayPal might do some retribution.)
2. You can contact me by mail (do a whois lookup) or email. I don't take phone calls because I work for a living and I have no desire to have my personal life disrupted by phone calls all during the night. (Which I did have when I had the phone numbers on the site.) I didn't see your home number in your post Mousky. No, I don't work for a competitor (in case you were wondering.) When I started the site there was no such thing as a competitor to PayPal.
3. "We..." I almost always answer from the "We" perspective because I have always considered the site more than myself. I have always considered it a community of people trying to affect change.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: No Subject Given
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: No Subject Given
http://www.settlement4onlinepayments.com/
Where PayPal agreed to not only release $5million it was holding of people's money, but pay another $9.25million in claims.
About the $5million... that was money that paypal had frozen from it's customers account and had gone by the 180 day waiting period. PayPal had NOT sent the money to the account holders, despite it clearing all concerns, because, according to PayPal: they didn't ask for it back. Part of the class action lawsuit was that Paypal would voluntarily refund funds held for 180 days without the account holder having to put in a specific request for it.
Holding people's money for 180 days is bad enough, but what do you call it when they do not release it after the 180 days? The courts call it conversion and it's a crime.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: No Subject Given
I called up paypal within a few minutes of me signing on and noticing that my account balance had been set at -$410. I provided the FedEx information that was requested by paypal to verify that the guitar was shipped. 9 days later, I get a notice from paypal stating that the case was now closed and that I was out of my $450 PLUS the guitar I had shipped and was proven to be received.
I called back up to Paypal because there had got to have been some mistake as to why the case was closed, even though I provided all of the information requested and FedEx had shown the item being received and signed for by the same name on the "buyer" account. When i finally got on the phone with a real life person, I asked for help in resolving this. The paypal representative told me, "go to church". After a bit of silence from my part, I asked "excuse me?". The paypal rep had said once again, "my advice to you is, go to church". I ignored this second time in which she said this, and continued to seek out help in resolving this obviously flawed transaction of paypal's part. The representative continued to mention that becoming more religious would be a better solution to solve this $$$ error on behalf of paypal. As you can see, that phone call didn't get any further. I never received my money back. And after being a member for about 2 years without any errors, this incident of $450 and the inappropriate religious suggestions by paypal's representative, lost them another member. I now only check/money-orders to receive payments. and when buying, i look for items being sold by persons within 100 radius of where i live - so I can meet the seller, face-to-face.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Paypal destroyed my business
I found a good honest supplier, after about 20 sales Paypal restricted my account. After 2 days, about 15 calls and an unbelievable amount of faxes I have sent to paypal. They wanted my driver license, a utility bill, my suppliers name, phone number and website. Then they wanted tracking numbers on my last 4 sales which I was using a dropshipper and was not able to send the funds to my supplier to get tracking numbers. And finally I went on a website for the product I was selling to get a letter from them stating these items was not fake. I received this and faxed it to Paypal and my account was no longer restricted.
Well guess what, 2 weeks later I got up and as always checked my email and found out that Paypal closed my account because my credit score was not high enough for them, and along with that they are keeping the $6,182.00 I had in my account for 180 days.
This money was not mine, it was my customers which are waiting for their item they bought from me. There is no way I can send that money to my supplier out of my pocket.
Within 24 hours I had my first complaint from a buyer. I know I will lose this money. Also I received some items I already sold. I have to pay over $300 out of my pocket for shipping because I cannot print shipping labels as I always done from paypal.
What I want to know is why paypal is running credit checks on me and what my credit score has to do with anything?
My advice is stay as far away from paypal as you can. I had a good business going and they shut it down with no warning and for no reason. Now my ebay account looks like I was a fraud!!! I use to have a 99.8% feedback, not anymore. THANK YOU PAYPAL
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Drop shipping is a scam and you deserved what you got
[ link to this | view in thread ]
knew all along
[ link to this | view in thread ]