Next-Gen DVD Copy Protection Well And Truly Busted

from the get-over-it dept

Thu, Feb 22nd 2007 4:47pm — Carlo Longino

Crackers had already managed to break the DRM on both the HD DVD and Blu-ray next-generation DVD technologies, but now the Advanced Access Content System (AACS) copy-protection technology has been further undermined. Another cracker reported last week that he'd discovered another one of the keys the system uses to decode encrypted content -- without doing any reverse engineering or using any special tools, just a hex editor. While the group behind AACS says that the latest crack is no big deal because it can issue new keys, but the crackers say the technique used here will make it easy to discover them, and releasing new keys would mean that current players that can't be updated wouldn't be able to play new movies, which certainly wouldn't annoy anybody that's dropped several hundred bucks on one of the new machines. So, it's time for Hollywood to own up to the fact that this latest DRM scheme is a bust, with The Guardian pointing out that the crackers were surprised at just how easy it was to defeat. Hollywood should use this episode to understand that it's pointless to keep throwing resources at DRM and copy-protection technology, because it simply doesn't work. It will be interesting to see how AACS and the movie studios respond: breaking current players' compatibility with new movies would certainly undermine the claim that DRM makes things better for consumers.

Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.

Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.

While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.

–The Techdirt Team

23 Comments

If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

david b, 22 Feb 2007 @ 5:25pm

you couldn't make this stuff up!
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Alex Hagen, 22 Feb 2007 @ 5:46pm

Can you add any more misinformation
A) This crack is not any more serious than the previous one. Revoking the player key will work just as well on this crack.

B) The key that would be replaced would be for a software player; either WinDVD 8 or Power DVD 6.5. The people that have "dropped several hundred bucks" will not be affected. No hardware HD-DVD player (or even DVD player) has ever been cracked.

C) It is not "well and truly busted". It is busted in exactly the way they anticipated it would be busted. It is a bit early to proclaim the battle over.

You guys have turned from reporting and commenting to just outright cheerleading. No one is suggesting that you ever claimed to be unbiased, but your bias is beginning to cloud your judgment.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Ryu, 22 Feb 2007 @ 5:57pm
  
  Re: Can you add any more misinformation
  referring to points A and B:
  
  They didn't extract the player key, well that's what was initially done. Arnezami, a doom9 member, was able to track down the Processing Key, which is like the "master key", and revoking this one is a much more complicated process. I would recommend reading this guide to understanding AACS by arenzami if you are interested how it all works. you can find it here: http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=122363
  
  you are correct on point C though, AACS hasn't been cracked, but an effective method to circumvent it has been achieved.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
felix five, 22 Feb 2007 @ 6:00pm

Alex your wrong
the crack does indeed work on media copied to be played on hardware players, and the vulnerability exists in hardware as welll- the DRM battle might not be over, but the pre DRM camp have been loosing since day one
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Axi0n, 22 Feb 2007 @ 6:41pm

Not such a big deal yet...
The man has been humbled and humiliated to be sure... I don't expect it to cause them any immediate grief.. Other than the embarassment of having to explain to the suits and investors of how their flawless system got pwned by someone with a hex editor snooping essentially plaintext key exchanges.

Until burners are out for either format, and are cheap enough combined with the wide availability of blank media...

Or

Everyone goes out and invests in a TB+ sized harddrive so they can hold a reasonable collection..

This whole thing will be largely semantics...

As fast as many peoples internet access is these days is it really a logical assumption that people are going to download all sorts of 20-30GB high def movies...

If everyone had 1Gig FTH and all the ISP's and backbones could sustain wirespeed to everyone then of course there'd be chaos...

Lets face it... 90% of what Hollywood produces is crap, now it just looks a little nicer...

Microsoft and certain software companies I can see crying over theft more because practically everyone with a PC has or had of copy of xyz software, thats their bread and butter and only revenue stream...

A lot of people still buy movies and music to get the jewel case, the inserts, the extras...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Thunderclap, 22 Feb 2007 @ 6:57pm

Heh, its a new phase.
Western digital now has consumer grade 1 TB hard drives.
So it isn't semantics, archiving HD is now possible. Is it probable? Not really, but the point has always been about fair use that we have a right back up the items we buy.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Alex Hagen, 22 Feb 2007 @ 7:09pm

Keys, keys, and more keys
Thank you for the link Ryu, it was very interesting. I thought I understood this, at least in a general way, but it is insanely complicated. After reading all of that I'm still not sure I really understand it.

I had thought the processing key was derived from the device key (what I was calling the player key), and it is...kind of. Apparently getting the processing key makes cracking current discs easier because you don't need to find the media key block on the disc.

But it is my understanding from reading that info that all the AACS people have to do is change the required processing keys for new discs to make discs unreadable with this crack, which is something they would have to do anyway when revoking a device key. Of course, this assumes they revoke the device keys and fix the player in question so the doom9 crowd don't get the new processing keys as well. All in all, this hardly seems like the final crack to end all cracks.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
erv, 22 Feb 2007 @ 7:54pm

goes to show crack and DRM don't mix
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Dirk, 22 Feb 2007 @ 8:04pm

My gf has a nice buttcrack
All this talk about cracks got me thinking, if that matters to anyone here.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- *Zing*, 22 Feb 2007 @ 8:10pm
  
  Re: My gf has a nice buttcrack
  @Dirk
  
  yea?...how long does it take to blow her up?
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Treslayr, 22 Feb 2007 @ 9:58pm

Re: My gf has a nice buttcrack
Oh ignore him Dirk,
Just post the pics of your girlfriend's crack somewhere and let us decide whether it is nice... This way if it is indeed nice you will have the awe and respect of your peers...
Otherwise we assume you do indeed have to blow her up...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Chris, 22 Feb 2007 @ 10:34pm

it's just what happens when it's all 0's and 1's
Ever since the first secuirty measure was implemented there has been someone out there dedicated to getting around it. This will always be the case, so whenever the next one comes out it will be cracked or bypassed just as easily. If people want to go wasting a bunch of money trying to protect their crap for a few short months, then fine by me. Im patient enough to take advantage of other peoples work that allows me to get what I want for free.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
ScytheNoire, 23 Feb 2007 @ 2:39am

DRM has always been a joke
Alex Hagen sounds like some industry rep.

DRM does not work, has never worked, and never will work. It's just some toy for bored geeks to play with. It's like some puzzle challange in the sunday paper that cost millions/billions to make. Good job wasting money. Shows how much they care about the artists they are supposed to represent.

For some real fun, they need to get those PS3 keys out there just to really piss Sony off and make them a bigger mockery. Of course, no one is really buying PS3's, and don't want to do too much to help Blu-Ray sales. But using a PS3 to rip Blu-Ray movies would be poetic justice. Get all those keys revoked and have them stop working. This will be done soon enough.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
fuse5k, 23 Feb 2007 @ 2:55am

RE: the downloading of HD debate
I know it now sounds improbable that people will be downloading the entire content of 20-30 GB disks over the internet. But now the case is that if you were to download a DVD quality movie you could get it on about 800 MB, instead of the 4-9 you would on a DVD Disk.

There will be new compression formats to take these behemoth files and compress them so that we will be able to share them.
it has been happenning for years, as the file formats get larger, bandwidth gets larger, and people come up with different ways of sharing them
in the days of napster would you have thought of downloading a whole album at the same time? doubtful. Would you think about it twice now, doubtful.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- John Locke, 23 Feb 2007 @ 7:54am
  
  Re: RE: the downloading of HD debate
  "There will be new compression formats to take these behemoth files and compress them so that we will be able to share them. it has been happenning for years, as the file formats get larger, bandwidth gets larger, and people come up with different ways of sharing them......."
  
  You've hit the nail on the head. That's exactly what's
  going to happen. The ISPs had better get ready for
  a huge surge in bandwidth usage.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Anonymous Jerk, 23 Feb 2007 @ 8:19am

Copy protection fix
Question: How many people would pay, say, $5 for a legal copy of a movie, that is the same quality as a pirated copy (camcorder shot of a movie screen)?
That's the fix! If someone is given an option of two movies, and the quality and cost are exactly the same, but one is illegal and can land you in serious trouble, and the other is legal, who's gonna pick the illegal version?

These film companies need to realize this, and, say, the day after a movie comes out in a theater, release a low-quality copy, and a discounted price. Yes, the theatres will be p***ed off, but screw them, they already make a KILLING off of $3 drinks and $4 popcorn. No, it won't solve all the piracy problems, but it would at least show everyone that the producers are willing to compete with piracy, instead of taking a hard-handed, brick-wall stance against it.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Pfahlstaff, 24 Feb 2007 @ 5:38pm

Cracking DRM
I wonder if they're working on quantum encryption.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Grundle, 25 Feb 2007 @ 3:47pm

Cracking DRM
Simultaneous release is the way to go. Out on DVD on wide release day. Movie theatres are competing with home rigs more and more for eyeballs. Gone are the days when you needed 10 grand+ just for the sound system, now a whole HD big screen rig with 5.1 is becoming affordable. I would much rather sit at home and watch a movie on a 60 inch tv than go to a packed movie theatre full of loudmouths and overpriced consessions to watch sub-standard swill. The movie theatre's role needs to be re-examined, especially the pricing. Hollywood puts out A LOT of garbage that's just no where near worth $50 for 2 people to go see. Don't get me wrong, I still do enjoy the theatre for those movies that NEED to be seen on an 80 foot screen but I can guarantee you that I've already watched it at home to see if it's even worth going to see. THAT right there terrifies the movie industry.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Deniz, 23 Dec 2007 @ 3:32pm

copy???
how do i copy a protected dvd??? help im not that smart please email me how on my email deni688@hotmail.com thank you ppl
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
jony, 19 Jan 2009 @ 12:30am

Korean Offer: CDR.DVDR illegal Strong Copy Protection System.
Dear Sir/Madam
Hope you are fine and good health.
We got your reference through internet search and Now we are pleased to contact you
To see if there is any possibility to establish business Cooperation with you.

Our technology licensing enable you to add comprehensive protection against illegal
Copying to your products. To give you a general idea of our products, You can apply CD/DVD
And DVD-video rom all format useable through by Computer work only,This is not SoftWare Package.
** This copy protection can help to protects your important data,
Specially : GameCD,CourseWare.Excel.ExeFile.Swf.Txt.Jpg.Pdf.MsWord.Ppt.Wmv.Mp3 file.Flash Etc.

For details please visit our Site for : www.safe-rom.com
After check please feel free pass your valuable business comment.
We will be glad and honored to work with your esteem organization
Thanks & Best Regards.
Jony.
MB: + 82-11-9997-9839
jony@safe-rom.com

P.S:OUR ANOTHER NEW TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT WORK WILL BE FINISH AT COMING MARCH.
(BLANK CDR & DVDR DISC WITH ILLEGAL STRONG COPY PROTECTION SYSTEM,

CAN NOT DUPLICATE FROM ALCOHOL120,NERO AND CLONE CD)
YOU CAN EASILY ABLE TO RECORD ALL DATA (DRAMA/MOVIE/SONG/MP3 WITH OTHERS)
AND ITS ALSO PLAYABLE TO GENERAL CD/DVD PLAYER AND COMPUTER TOO.

www.safe-rom.com
Narae Blue Media Co.,Ltd.
Korea.Seoul.YangChon Gu,Mok 4/Dong,806-16
Tel:+ 82-2-392-0972 & + 82-707124-6166
Fax:+ 82-2-2653-0185
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
merso, 14 Apr 2009 @ 1:24am

remove your dvd protection then copy it to another blank one.
http://www.applemacvideo.com/mac-dvd-copy.html#131
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
msdfs, 22 Jun 2009 @ 7:12pm

Copy dvd to player media and directly play on Apple DVD Player.
In the upgrade version of DVD Copy for Mac, we add Copy DVD to DVD player Media on Mac. If you choose to copy your DVD as DVD Player Media, you can directly play the output media file with Apple DVD player . Resource: How to Copy DVD on Mac to Playback on Apple DVD Player?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
copydvd, 25 Mar 2014 @ 11:04am

Copy Protected Dvd's
To begin with an exposition. What they call "duplicate control" is really "content encryption". The encryption does nothing, nor would it be able to, do stop duplicating.
The issue is that a large number of DVD's and players have been sold, individuals aren't going to strive for another group for quite a while, and the encryption that DVD's utilization has been broken. As such, its pointless.
So we have an industry that purchased and paid for the DMCA as a lawful intends to shore up their powerless specialized guards of their substance. Anyway the law is generally excessively moderate to find individuals replicating films.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]