E-books Still A Solution In Search Of A Problem
from the value-added? dept
On Monday, Amazon plans to unveil the latest stab at a successful e-book reader with Kindle, a $400, a WiFi and EVDO-equipped tablet PC that's rumored to have 256 MB of memory and an 800 X 600 electrophoretic display. It will be a direct competitor to Sony's PRS-505 Reader. The technology here looks kind of neat, but I don't understand why they expect anyone other than die-hard gadget enthusiasts would jump on board. Books are durable, flexible, cheap, light, boast an extremely high contrast ratio, and never malfunction or run out of power. It's going to be awfully difficult to design an e-book reader that can compete on all of those dimensions. Plus, people have developed life-long habits around paper books, and would have to learn a new set of habits to get comfortable reading e-books. So e-books will have to offer some pretty compelling advantages to overcome all of those considerations. Yet the only real advantage of an e-book is that it saves some space. If you buy Amazon's reader, you can pack a few dozen e-books in the space in your suitcase that used to be occupied by a single paper book. But nobody reads dozens of books on one trip, so it's not obvious why that's valuable. And when they get home, a lot of people actually like putting their books on bookshelves in their living room where they'll impress their friends. So saving space isn't necessarily a big advantage there either.Amazon seems to be trying to address that issue by tacking on some other features, most notably the ability to load up content from a variety of newspapers. But reading a newspaper is a much different experience than reading a book. People flip through newspapers a lot faster than they flip through books, and because of the way electrophoretic displays work, that's likely to run down their batteries pretty quickly. Most of Amazon's target customers likely already have a laptop and/or a smartphone, either of which offer color, a more responsive display, and more powerful browsing software. It seems more likely that people would just read the day's news on one of those devices and leave the e-book reader at home.
The fundamental issue here is that people don't adopt new technologies — especially ones that cost hundreds of dollars — unless they provide compelling advantages over the products already on the market. Merely achieving parity with paper books (and it's not clear they've even achieved that) isn't going to cut it, because people don't like to change their established routine. For e-books to catch on, then, they have to be better than paper in a really compelling way. So far, nobody has figured out how to make e-books do something really useful that they can't do with the paper books and laptops they already have.
![Hide This Hide this](https://ii.techdirt.com/s/t/i/topclose.png)
Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.
Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.
While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.
–The Techdirt Team
Reader Comments
Subscribe: RSS
View by: Time | Thread
what a dumb idea!
Actual printed media is easier and more comfortable to read and is easier on the eyes in my experience. I think most would agree. Not to mention an absurdly high % of our country hasn't even read a book in the last year.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: what a dumb idea!
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: what a dumb idea!
The place where I could've really used an ebook was at school; lugging those big books around. Amazon should take advantage of that niche market and get people to by the device and e-books for way less then you'd spend on one semester of real books. This way they could also invest in future users as the format would be more familiar.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Not a dumb idea!
My wife reads e-books. Initially she was a bit hesitant, but now she prefers it to print.
I would pay for an e-book... just not the absurd amounts that the content industry wants me to pay.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
One other benifit...
This benifit, for me, is not yet outweighed by having to constantly charge the ebook reader and the fact that many of the books I read are loaned to me by friends or ones I see when I'm killing some spare time in a bookstore. It's almost impossible to get me to want to buy a book online.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Better
What might be compelling advantages, and definitely only if DRM free?
Annotation: I can mark passages and leave myself notes.
Quotation: I can select and organize passages, across multiple books even, for use in term papers and reports and have the ebook software export the passages along with all required bibleographical information etc.
Colaboration and sharing: Reader or "Fan" markups. I can mark sentences or passages and share them with like minded individuals via the web. I can compile profiles and histories for characters and share them. I can create my own illustrations and images to go with certain passages and share them.
Explanation: Glossaries, also extendable and shareable, can explain names, terms, ideas, foreign words and the like.
All integrated seamlessly, fetched automatically if online, and not requiring the user to manage multiple pieces of software.
Would I buy an e-book reader for those things? No, but I know people who'd get into each of those features. So are they available?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
too much for too little
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
the e-book reader is supposed to be the new ipod
no one has ebooks and is looking to buy a player.
besides, it's not like you can rip a copy of book to your PC like you can with a CD. if they fix that problem i'm all about it.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Amazon's target customers will still carry books..
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Amazon's target customers will still carry boo
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I ain't into the gadgets...
** I have 4 volumes of this size that I have to search through on a monthly basis. With only a few keywords to go on, these searches would take 2 months to complete instead of a few minutes.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Where I think it really shines is for reading things that never came in hardcopy, like RSS Feeds and Word documents. Not so much PDFs, because A4 sheets don't scale well on the thing. And while I can read the web on my PDA, a) the battery dies much faster, and b) the screen is tiny.
The technology needs work, like being cheaper, and having a fast-refreshing color screen, but the idea isn't wholly without merit.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I forgot to add
Talk about social. You could tie your discussions to external sites too, fan sites, myspace, facebook, favorite book lists, Oprah's book club.
These are features that I'd think you could incorporate and encourage adoption. Since many would also take you to external sites, which currently are or could be advertising supported, there'd be an external avenue for revenue generation that might lower prices.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
niche
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Ebooks
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
e-Books
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Collaberative Textbooks
A $400 e-book reader would be 1/3 the cost of a single semester's worth of textbooks for me.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Only advantage?
Last time I moved, more than 50% of the weight of my household shipment was books.
Another advantage of a e-book is that the production cost is lower, and you only have to 'manufacture' the exact quantity that is sold. It can then be delivered nearly instantly. Keeping a backlist is no longer an issue (there are books that I own that can no longer be purchased ANYWHERE).
That said, the e-book readers I've seen aren't quite ready for prime time, but some of them are getting close. Also, the e-book business model currently sucks, but eventually somebody will get it right, and all the idiots will be forced to follow suit or go out of business (unless they can make non-DRM illegal).
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
oh and...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
My ebook reader
Actually, that is how I got started in ebooks. The entire Honor Harrington series is available for free (yes legally!) as ebooks. My friend urged me to give the series another chance so I started reading on an iPac. The books were ok but reading on the iPac sucked. I'm using a Nokia N800 today and I love it.
The other reason I use ebooks is programming documentation. My standard library of Perl books is a cubic foot of paper. 20+ pounds of paper. The html based version of the same books is 300Meg, fits on an SD card and weights nothing.
I wish the manufactures would give up on supporting just their own format and DRM. Totally useless.
I'm waiting on 4bit color e-ink displays. The Complete Iron Man Comic book DVD is calling out to be read on one.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Longevity
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Baen
Baen/Webscriptions "gets it", but you know, they're a sci-fi publisher. If anyone is going to figure out what the brave new world means for publishing, it's going to be a company like that.
I read them on my PDA (and now on my iPhone), and it was ok. I'm actually very close to a person that reads dozens of books on their trips, because I read so damn fast, but I'm smart enough to realize that I'm a niche market, and I'm not even going to buy one of those e-books readers.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
This guy has never been a soldier deployed over seas or a truck driver or any other job that has you away from home for long periods of time.
I would love to have had something like this when I was in the Army where weight and space mean everything when you carry everything you own in a ruck.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
hmm
1000 pdf files are awful light in comparison.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
If I could afford it
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
eReaders
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
ick
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Who you gonna call?
Egon Spengler
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Yet the only real advantage of an e-book is th
1) Convenience. I can browse, preview, and purchase and begin reading a book from my own bed. Or car, or....
2) Price. Yes you have to shell out for the device, but it looks like the individual books will be cheaper than print copies.
3) Flexibility. I will be able to read my book collection, newspapers, and techdirt all from one place, on the go.
Other cool things that I can think of off the top of my head that you can't do with real books: Indexed text search so I can find any passage quickly. The aforementioned 20 books in one package. Not having to hang around getting barbed looks form the staff at Barnes and Noble while I check things out.
And for people who say it is too expensive, consider this: An iPhone costs $400 or whatever up front and ~$2000 after two years. This thing costs $400 now and that's it. Can you name one other device that comes with wireless (ie more than just wifi) connectivity and no subscription fee?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Basically it depends on how you can integrate the device (or any device) into your life. If you can't it just won't work.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Ebook concept to lower price of text books?
"A $400 e-book reader would be 1/3 the cost of a single semester's worth of textbooks for me."
Think of this scenario: An English professor requires you to purchase 7-9 different novels to use during a class. About half-way through the semester she decides to abandon two of them. You can no longer sell them back to the bookstore and are stuck with them.
Here's another: Your Geology text BY ITSELF is $200. Granted it does include a study/homework-type lab book.
How much simpler would a CD of .pdfs be? How much easier and cheaper for the student would an ebook be? Remember what it's like to have to carry a 25lb book bag? There are lots of good reasons for ebooks. I just think text books are too big of a cash cow for *some* publishers. I know everybody has to go through it but there should be and IS a better way. When you think about it, text books are a perfect way to exploit the richer environment and address the concept of different learning styles.
BTW, if I could have the text books on my laptop I'd be just as happy. Concept is still the same.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Now I dont know about the price I think it should be less then $100 and also be able to see in very low light and very bright light. It should also have an option to create your own ebook and upload more and be able to expand the memory to use computer laptop hard drives. Also it should have the ability to be of any resolution and in 32 bit color.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
While I agree that the "ebook reader" aspect is not as compelling as vendors would have you believe, the possibilities of having a lightweight, low-power touchscreen computer (for notetaking, musical composition...) make the prospect worth considering.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
companies building ebooks have no idea what consum
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
ebooks
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
eBooks
But I can’t wait for ebooks. They may not replace paper books but they will become a viable alternative and they will become useful because they can be annotated in situ, so to speak. I think Annotation will itself become an art form in the future.
Imagine reading something like Roughing It by Mark Twain and being able to click a link to pictures of all the places he visited or to read more about silver mining or the colorful people he writes about or decipher some of the old slang. While I was reading the book I kept popping over to my pc to read more about tumble weeds or the Pony Express, whatever. There are plenty of books like this where
You could just go deeper and deeper and deeper.
I look forward to this eventuality. I think much of the annotation will be provided by ardent fans. You can see the beginnings of this already. But there will be professionals as well.
The device price will inevitably come down and epaper is already on the horizon. There might not be a need for a big clunky book reading machine but electronic books will happen and they will be wonderful.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
You would think...
Not that you'd see what you'd want to see from them, but giving students the ability to download the text book in e-book format would be a huge savings for them since it's almost all profit once the e-book has been produced, and (if I understand the DRM correctly), they cannot be sold/transferred to other students at the end of the term.
Personally, I'd love to use an e-book reader for the 3 to 6 books I have to carry around each term.
EtG
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: You would think...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I'm really disappointed...
2)None of you have any right to comment on ebooks until you've actually a) read an ebook and b) used both an e-ink device and a non e-ink device to read an ebook or other document.
E-Ink devices are great; they are much better to read on than an LCD, and they look just about as good as a real book (especially considering the infancy of the technology).
3)The ebook industry is still in its infancy, and will be growing really fast in the next few years. If you want to learn anything, go to mobileread.com and read their forums. Higher resolution/faster devices are coming out every year, and color devices should be out by around 2010. Animation should be viable soon after that. In addition, thanks to advances in both Nanotechnology and Microelectromechanical Systems, we are getting other new technologies such as Interferometric Modulation (IMOD) and OLED displays, which might offer alternative/complimentary options.
4)The main problem with the ebook market at this point in time (in addition to the obvious problems of its infancy) is that the content producers are not backing it, but we really must just give them time and tell them that we want them to start offering their books as ebooks (or better yet, ask them to do what apress is doing and offer ebooks in addition to hardcopies at a really low cost (I got a $50 book's e-copy for $10)). However, those ebooks that are available are often on the order of 30% cheaper than their print versions (at least of those I've looked at), which is about the cost of the printing/shipping/stocking/etc. of the hard books. Go to http://ebooks.connect.com/ and check the prices of books.
Example: Double Cross by James Patterson (0316015059)
Print: $27.99
eBook: $19.99 (I don't really know what this number is)
Connect: $15.99 (20% discount of eBook, 43% off print)
Amazon.com: $16.79 (Connect is still 5% cheaper)
4b)The other problem is that companies don't want to agree on a single standard format (pdfs are nice, but large in size and don't like to be reformatted to different sizes; BBEB/lrf (Sony's format) is much nicer, but not supported by anyone else; mobipocket is another proprietary format), but hopefully this will all be solved by the IDPF's .epub format (see: http://www.idpf.org/).
4c)The final problem is the cost of the devices, but that is dropping fast, and the features are growing just as fast. I bought my PRS-500 a little over a month ago for $249.99 with a $50 credit for books + 100 free classic books. Amazon's *possible* device (it is NOT confirmed yet, just speculation and rumors) is more expensive because it has more features (wifi, annotation, etc), and the iLiad is even more expensive for the same reason.
5)As for content, don't forget Project Gutenberg (http://www.gutenberg.org/wiki/Main_Page), WikiBooks (http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Main_Page), WikiSource (http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Main_Page), and Wikiversity(http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Main_Page), as well as EVERY SINGLE TEXT-BASED DOCUMENT (& pictures) FOUND ON THE INTERNET, including:
websites
blogs
news sites
web-based dictionary articels
web-based encyclopedia articles
datasheets
and hundreds of other things.
From now on, if you're going to comment on something, make sure you a)know what your're talking about and b)do some actual research. I'm really disappointed in you, Tim. Before you post these kind of things, you should really do some research. You're becoming more like the newspapers and news shows, just announcing something with a sensational headline to create a controversy that doesn't exist. There ARE many problems with the current system that ebooks address (price, waste (not just paper, but the whole publishing process, just as with music and movies), convenience (size, access, acquiring), and other things.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
ebook comments
Pros:
1. fits in a suit pocket, and holds 50 or more full-length books.
2. I can adjust the type size for my over-40 eyes
3. I can find plenty of legal content (and since I have a high-speed scanner and quality OCR software, I can do the equivalent of RIP for any book I am willing to cut apart -- e.g. cheap paperbacks
4. pages are flat -- I can hold the ebook and turn pages with one hand -- unlike paperback, pages stay flat when using hands to do something else.
5. has sufficient battery life -- lasts for several days of reading (since ePaper, supposedly only uses power when turning pages, but if I leave alone (on or off) for several days, I have to re-charge).
Some cons:
1. contrast is OK (great in outdoors) but of course NOT equal to paper
2. This version does NOT highlight, annotate, or search -- it is the equivalent of a single purpose tool (It does bookmark, but I do not use the feature)
3. airlines deem it an electronic device, so I am asked to turn it off during take-offs and landings.
Bottom line
For what it is -- great way to do recreational reading (I do read dozens of books on a trip while sitting on the beach -- and I can put the eBook in a plastic bag and still use it).
But what I really want is a tablet PC with (a) a screen as good as the ebook for outdoor, but backlit for indoor; (b) all the features of search, annotation, etc. (c) same size and weight factor -- especially that it fits in the outer suit pocket.
Rollie Cole
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
All I Want For Christmas
1. A deeply discounted price for the books. Most of the e-book retailers have failed because they expect consumers to pay full hardcover retail price for a bestseller ($26-30+). I can buy a brand new hardcover Grisham or Steel novel at Costco for around $14.
2. The ability to print out text onto my printer.
3. An open e-book format that allows me to choose the reading format most comfortable for me. As in PDF, Word, etc.
4. The ability to transfer the e-book back and forth between my desktop PC, my laptop, my Smart Phone and the proprietary e-book reading device.
5. For non-fiction books, the ability to mark up text inside the e-book, just as if I were holding a regular book in my hands, with a highlighter pen and a virtual Sharpie, making margin notes as I read.
6. The ability to resell the e-book used on Amazon to another buyer once I'm finished with it.
7. The assurances that I'm not spending $400+ on a boat anchor, once the e-book company goes out of business or the big corporate media giant decides to stop manufacturing and supporting the devices.
Until the e-book format and readers meet these standards, I'll stay with the good old-fashioned paper book.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: All I Want For Christmas
See Baen Books and Fictionwise.com and eReader.com
> 2. The ability to print out text onto my printer.
Not likely, it's a violation of copyright.
> 3. An open e-book format that allows me to choose the reading format most comfortable for me. As in PDF, Word, etc.
Available. See Baen, Fictionwise, etc.
> 4. The ability to transfer the e-book back and forth between my desktop PC, my laptop, my Smart Phone and the proprietary e-book reading device.
Available. See Baen, Fictionwise, eReader, MobiPocket, etc.
> 5. For non-fiction books, the ability to mark up text inside the e-book, just as if I were holding a regular book in my hands, with a highlighter pen and a virtual Sharpie, making margin notes as I read.
Available, See eReader, MobiPocket, most eReader software (although amazingly not most ereader HARDWARE that isn't a PDA)
> 6. The ability to resell the e-book used on Amazon to another buyer once I'm finished with it.
Not likely. Publishers don't like you being able to resell paper books. I would have no desire for this anyway; I never sell books. I occasionally give them away to charity or a friend, but that's it.
> 7. The assurances that I'm not spending $400+ on a boat anchor, once the e-book company goes out of business or the big corporate media giant decides to stop manufacturing and supporting the devices.
That's why I use a PDA or a laptop and work with vendors (Baen, Fictiowise that support multiple format and/or open formats and that don't (or don't always) have DRM.
> Until the e-book format and readers meet these standards, I'll stay with the good old-fashioned paper book.
99% of your objections do not exist ALREADY and haven't for years. Time to check out ebooks.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I like the portability of e-books and the fact (in principle) that you can order one and start reading straight away without having to wait for it to be delivered. I also like the fact that if I buy them over the internet I don't have to pay 25% sales tax that we have in Denmark. My wife likes the fact that they don't clutter up the basement.
I read a lot on-screen now - mainly because of rss feeds. Why doesn't some enterprising publisher start publishing serialised ebooks on rss.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Sony eBook Reader
As for me, I'm not sorry I bought (though I do wish got it for much less) it since it does the one thing that I need and goes literally weeks without a recharge. This combined with the fact that I can fit about 50 books in RTF form on the internal memory alone is about all I care about.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Another thought on Text Books
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
The Amazon Kindle
BTW...if you watch one of the videos you'll see a quick cameo for Tech dirt...the Kindle lets you read blogs, magazines and newspapers!
The major drawback? $400 for the machine and almost $10.00 for a title. This has to be some kind of mistake. I hope Amazon figures this out and soon.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Free ebooks
What about price?
What about availability?
What about a full Library in one CD instead of huge bookshelves?
What about fast and easy search?
What about animation in children's books?
What about costless ink and High definition pictures and movies?
What about culture at no price?
When they invented the printed book (in the place of the manual written one)culture was available and affordable to almost all.
With eBooks it WILL. And that is the only Future: affordable Education.
I have a website: http://www.easymediabroadcast.com with free eBooks and a LOT of Audio eBooks.
You can read and listened to the story. It is wonderful for people who want to learn a language.
What was lacking was an eBook reader, because the computer is not the best medium.(I mean, it is nicer to sit on an armchair than in front of a computer screen)
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
e books
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Useful OCR tool
[ link to this | view in chronology ]