Censoring The 'Net Is Hard

from the even-for-authoritarian-governments dept

Wed, Mar 5th 2008 3:21pm — Timothy Lee

Over the last few months, I've been doing research on a forthcoming paper for the Cato Institute on the network neutrality debate. In the next few weeks, I'll be doing a series of posts on the major themes of my paper. My goal will be to highlight some interesting stories from the tech world, and then highlight their broader policy implications.

This week, the blogosphere is abuzz with the story that Iran may shut down the Internet on the date of its elections next week. I should note at the outset that I'm a little bit skeptical of this story, which seems to be rather thinly sourced. It's been picked up by a bunch of news outlets, but they all point back to the same International Herald Tribune article. That story cites two unnamed Iranian media outlets, which apparently don't even agree with each other about the reasons for the supposed Internet blackout. And the idea of blocking Internet access on election day just doesn't make a lot of sense. I can imagine why an authoritarian regime would shut down the Internet for a week or two before the election to suppress access to information about the election. But a block on the day of the election -- especially one that's announced a week ahead of time -- doesn't seem like it would do the government any good.

In any event, this certainly wouldn't be the first time Iran has instituted broad restrictions on Internet access in an effort to suppress the free flow of information. In 2006, Iran reportedly required that home Internet connections be reduced to 128 kbps. That doesn't make a lot of sense either; 128k is still plenty of bandwidth to download compressed audio, for example. But the Iranian government turned to a broad restriction on bandwidth after other efforts at content filtering failed. It seems that "as fast as they put up information roadblocks, Iranians have found detours around them." The only way the Iranian government has found to cut off the flow of information it doesn't approve of is to restrict the flow of information, period.

Some advocates of network neutrality seem to think that network neutrality is an issue of free speech. The fear is that AT&T or Verizon will use sophisticated filtering technologies to block content and websites they don't approve of. A conservative telco might block liberal blogs or YouTube videos, say, or maybe Ford would pay telcos to block access to Chevy's website. But if the government of Iran -- an institution with an almost unlimited budget and the ability to throw people in jail -- can't keep information it doesn't like away from its citizens, it's awfully hard to imagine that AT&T or Verizon would be able to do so. Iran has found that the only way to limit access to content it doesn't like is to limit access to the Internet altogether. Obviously that's not going to work for telcos, which are in business to make money. There are certainly some plausible arguments for network neutrality regulations, but fears of telco censorship are pretty low on the list.

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

Le Blue Dude, 5 Mar 2008 @ 3:33pm

True...
It is less then possible to block parts of the internet. It is quite possible to make using them harder though.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Thinker, 5 Mar 2008 @ 4:16pm

Tor
So long as there is an internet connection, Tor allows outside access. Relakks, Xerobank, Ironkey, Tor are all valid solutions to break ISP snooping and non-Net neutrality.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Derek Kerton (profile), 5 Mar 2008 @ 4:25pm

Easier To Sabotage The Net, Leveraging Tech Ignora
Not sure I agree that "Iran has found that the only way to limit access to content it doesn't like is to limit access to the Internet altogether."

The easiest way to limit access to content would be to take advantage of the average user's ignorance (as Comcast has). Instead of blocking the whole Internet, or entirely blocking a particular content type, site, etc. - both of which are very easily noticed - governments could slow access to certain content, or introduce errors and glitches.

I'm not saying that this would be entirely successful, but when you just corrupt the flow, most people don't know why the service quality is so bad, and just give up. They'll blame their browser, their modem, their PC, or the host site. This is why the "uproar" over Comcast's BitTorrent filtering has been limited to a fairly small cadre of geeks.

It's like election rigging: nobody dares say, "Group x is not allowed to vote". That would be obvious to outside eyes, and could cause a revolt. Instead, jerks just intimidate group x, jerrymander, screw with voter lists, and make the travel distance large to the point where it's not worth the costs to go to the polling place. Yet in the case of election-rigging, non-technical people can understand what really happened. In the tech world, few people do.

Current world politics has shown that it's hard for people to fight back when they can't correctly identify the enemy.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Jake, 5 Mar 2008 @ 4:31pm

Re: Tor
On the other hand, Tor takes a massive bite out of one's available bandwidth. Much below about 1MB on a good computer and it's essentially unusable, at least in my experience. The Iranians might just have something here.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Hyrulio, 5 Mar 2008 @ 4:40pm

I hope they don't read this
The best way would be to employ people with a decent knowlege of computers who could simply administer some governmental DDoS attacks and take the site down, mind you, then other countries would complain about their porno being unavailable and it would start a war......

Parhaps DDoS at the next UN perogotive?
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Tim Lee, 5 Mar 2008 @ 5:03pm

Re: Easier To Sabotage The Net, Leveraging Tech Ig
Well, hasn't the "fairly small cadre of geeks" been BitTorrent users? I think the reason there hasn't been an uproar among the general public is that most users don't know what BitTorrent is.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Anonymous Coward, 5 Mar 2008 @ 5:08pm

Doesn't have to be impossible, just hard
IP blocking all of Ford's sites would be enough to stop at least 99% of all people. Most people don't have enough time to look into proxies, Tor, or whatever to get through. It's just not worth the trouble. The only people that will proxy are people trying to get to TPB and stuff lke taht.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Tim Lee, 5 Mar 2008 @ 6:34pm

Re: Doesn't have to be impossible, just hard
And you don't think Chevy would get a ton of negative publicity if it was revealed that they'd paid AT&T to block Ford's site?
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Jeff Linton, 5 Mar 2008 @ 7:26pm

Iran's possible reasoning
Since this site is oriented toward technology and not politics I think you have missed a potential reason behind Iran wanting to shut down the internet. It is one thing to announce the results to an election days after and alter the votes in your favor; however, with the immediateness of Internet communication there could be more questions as to the validity of the election results.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Ran Guu, 6 Mar 2008 @ 12:04am

AT&T, MICROSOFT, GM PLACING ADS OVER INTERNET PORN
In the headlong rush to "monetize" their portals, many video sites such as Youtube, Blip.Tv , Metacafe, and Veoh have developed some interesting technology that randomly places advertisements surrounding the videos. Some even place ads on top of the videos. But at the same time, some devilish pranksters have taken to uploading some really hardcore porn on these sites, knowing it could take days before a real human being at these portals is made aware of what has been uploaded. The situation has been producing some very interesting relationships between the porn and some of America's biggest corporations.

Check out http://www.planetpop.tv/culturetrends for a good laugh
[ link to this | view in thread ]
known coward, 6 Mar 2008 @ 9:04am

blocking is easy
Pakastan took down Youtube for half of south asia without really trying.

Blocking nets is easy. Try this on your outbound router port and see what comes back from 192.9.121.X

route add 192.9.121.0 /dev/null0

While i like the idea of a free unfettered net, the reality is that goverments can block whatever they want too, as long as they know about it. The net does not supercede geopolitical realities, as some would have it. The net does not see censorship as damage and route around it, The net see's censorship as a black hole.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Charlie, 6 Mar 2008 @ 11:24am

Stanford's Clean Slate Project
Censoring the net might be difficult in its present form, but some folks are working very hard to re-design it from the ground up. They want to increase 'control and management' in order to ensure 'quality of service' and provide 'value-added services.' I like my Internet just fine the way it is, thanks.

A Clean Slate researcher from Stanford recently gave a talk at my university, and the whole thing was basically a thinly veiled attack against Network Neutrality.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Macky, 25 Oct 2009 @ 7:54am

Censoring
electronic cigarette | visitor spy | get my girlfriend back
[ link to this | view in thread ]
traffic mavericks, 5 Nov 2009 @ 6:08am

hard
traffic mavericks | traffic mavericks review
[ link to this | view in thread ]
hypotheekrente, 25 Nov 2009 @ 5:39am

Quite a technical post but interesting anyway.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
geld lenen, 26 Nov 2009 @ 2:12pm

It's not easy but it shouldnt be, should it.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Online lenen, 13 Aug 2010 @ 2:18pm

I think censoring or trying to control the Internet (in any way, also datacenter takeover like Google) will in the end NEVER do any good
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Electronic Cigarette, 16 Sep 2010 @ 4:27am

I want to say that after reading your post I have found so many interesting thing in your blog and I really love that. Keep up the good work!
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Electronic Cigarette, 16 Sep 2010 @ 4:28am

I want to say that after reading your post I have found so many interesting thing in your blog and I really love that. Keep up the good work!
[ link to this | view in thread ]
jack balboa, 4 Oct 2010 @ 9:59pm

The net does not supercede
as long as they know about it. The net does not supercede geopolitical realities, as some would have it. The net does not see censorship as damage and route around it, The net see's censorship as a black hole. Dissertation Writing Essay Writing
[ link to this | view in thread ]
E cigarette reviews, 5 Oct 2010 @ 12:55pm

Censoring
Well written
[ link to this | view in thread ]
scott griest, 17 Oct 2010 @ 11:39pm

i like your article as long as they know about it. The net does not super cede geopolitical realities, as some would have it. The net does not see censorship as damage and route around it, The net see's censorship as a black hole thanks for sharing.... logo design
[ link to this | view in thread ]
stretch mark removal, 20 Oct 2010 @ 5:39pm

Insightful
You can't Censor the net. It is way too complex for people moderate it thoroughly. I do want to know if there is a certain system that would do it as a whole. But for the present Net is very hard to crack and so is its censorship.

Happy Blogging!
Maria
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Bootstrap, 12 Nov 2010 @ 12:48pm

Since this site is oriented toward technology and not politics I think you have missed a potential reason behind Iran wanting to shut down the internet. It is one thing to announce the results to an election days after and alter the votes in your favor; however, with the immediateness of Internet communication there could be more questions as to the validity of the election results.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Calculus Tutor Help, 20 Nov 2010 @ 7:34pm

http://www.calculusproblems.org
The internet is the modern day tower of Babel.
It can be brought down.

Algebra Problem Help
Used Harley Parts
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Calculus Tutor Help, 20 Nov 2010 @ 7:35pm

The internet is the modern day tower of Babel.
It can be brought down.

Algebra Problem Help
Used Harley Parts
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Electronic Cigarette Review, 28 Nov 2010 @ 4:17pm

Government Control
With all the new things happening with ICE being able to just shut down websites, I don't know what to think of it. I know the new bill says that it's to close down copyright infringement sites, but I bet you somewhere in that bill is fine print that says they can shut down any site they want to for any reason. What ever happened to freedom of speech?!
[ link to this | view in thread ]
custom logo designs, 8 Dec 2010 @ 2:26pm

custom logo designs
This is truely a great post. I will be coming back for sure custom logo designs | custom website designs
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Jim Lauri, Sr., 28 Dec 2010 @ 2:51pm

it really most amazing gadget.its good i am thank full to you Canvas Prints its amazing for this century.Hi, It is really nice, but could you tell me how should I use this code,thanks for this information.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Snel Geld Lenen Binnen 10 Minuten, 13 Feb 2011 @ 9:14am

Many countries (India, China, undoubtedly others) legally require mapping companies display only officially approved maps - i.e. ones that agree with what they claim their borders are, the rest of the world be damned.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Davie Jacob, 1 Mar 2011 @ 6:56am

After read this post i want to keep coming here again and again.Thanks a lot. business do not call register
[ link to this | view in thread ]
wart removal, 7 Mar 2011 @ 3:37am

s
I'm quite impressed of your good work. You've let us know what you've done after having a long research. I'd like to know more details regarding your research. If you have time, would you mind updating your blog? It's quite interesting.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Justin, 5 Apr 2011 @ 10:05pm

Thanks for the great post! I've been thinking about this exact same thing over the last few days, so it's weird that you posted on it. You definitely did a much nicer job writing about it than I could have though.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
first aid kits, 22 Oct 2011 @ 1:40pm

Your site gives me much interesting stuff here, I really enjoyed. I will be back for more new updates here.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Dr. Oizio, 13 Nov 2011 @ 10:13am

Censoring is impossible. If you look to the history of downloaden music. First with FTP, then p2p and so on. This also will happen with content. People always find ways to exposure stuff.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
John Mikael, 12 Dec 2011 @ 11:01am

censorship
It's really not a good evolution that they will try to censor the web. It can't be done anyways. People will always find a loophole. I'l like a big bucket of water. They try to close the gaps and we just shoot a new hole in it.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
testimonial voiceovers, 21 Dec 2011 @ 11:22pm

testimonial voiceovers
I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform
you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great
post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Customize Joomla Template, 10 May 2012 @ 5:27am

Customize Joomla Template
Its a brilliant writing. I hope Everyone like this writing. Thanks a lot for sharing this article.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Customize Joomla Template, 10 May 2012 @ 5:35am

Customize Joomla Template
Its a brilliant writing. I hope Everyone like this writing. Thanks a lot for sharing this article.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
obd2 tool, 16 Oct 2012 @ 12:01am

BMW ICOM BMW ISIS ISID A+B+C Plus BMW ICOM Software ISTA/D
Desktop computer requirement: interl i3i5cpu 8GRAM 250G 72000RPM HARDDDISK.feng
[ link to this | view in thread ]