Do Newspapers Need Comments?

from the probably-not dept

Fri, Jul 25th 2008 1:58pm — Mike Masnick

A few weeks back, we wrote about the question of whether or not newspapers should be getting into the community business by noting that you don't build communities, you enable them. But, the question still remains how you enable those communities. Gawker had an interesting post recently along those lines arguing that newspapers shouldn't allow comments on articles. The argument is, basically, that a lot of the comments are really dumb, and don't add very much. That may be true, but in many cases, that's because the newspaper doesn't give anyone incentive to add smart comments. There's no indication that anyone at most newspapers read the comments. The authors of the articles rarely, if ever, respond to people in the comments. There's little to no engagement or discussion. So, instead, the comments just become a way for readers to vent. Just tossing up comments and thinking you've created a community is a mistake -- but that doesn't mean newspapers shouldn't enable comments. It just means they should do so in a more intelligent manner.

Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.

Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.

While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.

–The Techdirt Team

Filed Under: comments, community, newspapers

47 Comments

If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

Matt Bennett, 25 Jul 2008 @ 2:26pm

I dunno,does Techdirt make a incentive to leave intelligent comments? I see some very ham-handed comments around here, particularly of the "Government sux, Bush sux, Corps suck" variety. Some are wholly off-topic.

Not that I'm against comments, of course.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Paul, 25 Jul 2008 @ 7:49pm
  
  Re:
  Mike is known to respond to comments. In fact, I half expected him to respond to this one =P
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
GeneralEmergency (profile), 25 Jul 2008 @ 2:28pm

The Authors won't comment because...
...Journalism is Dead. The only thing left today are partisan/agendamaniacal elitist hacks.

If they had to respond, their bias' would quickly be exposed.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Matt Rowe, 25 Jul 2008 @ 2:29pm

Same
Then why does GAWKER allow comments...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
NP Editor, 25 Jul 2008 @ 2:37pm

Comments suck
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- SV, 27 Jul 2008 @ 11:55pm
  
  Re: Excelent exampel
  Yes a very good example of crap commenting. Not adding any thing in the way of information or well thought out opinion.
  
  I don't normally read comets because of this. I don't usual leave comments saying "Your comment is crap" but this time it seemed on topic.
  
  I think any unmoderated forum tends to drown in peoples vapid self indulgence.
  
  Vewww thank god that's off my chest.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Bill W, 25 Jul 2008 @ 2:47pm

Comments, dumb?
I read a lot of blogs and blog-like things and there are a LOT of dumb comments. Who knows? Some may consider THIS a dumb comment! While it may dilute the experience it doesn't destroy it if you can find a dialog somewhere in there.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Anonymous Coward, 25 Jul 2008 @ 2:53pm

I personally refuse to read articles without a comment section at the end. I must skim comments for at least one alternate viewpoint. The notion of a single article with a single viewpoint and no comments is seriously out of date. Why should I willingly make myself a slave to your soapboxing or biased reporting?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Anonymous Coward, 25 Jul 2008 @ 2:54pm

I moved and have kept reading the online editions of the news papers of my country of birth. A while back some began allowing commenting from readers.
Now, I have a facebook account, I'm on LinkedIn so it isn't like I am opposed to the community idea. But the quality of reader submitted comments on news paper content is so poor, offensive and biased that it reduced the value I used to have from reading homeland news while drinking my morning coffee.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Greg Drogan, 25 Jul 2008 @ 2:54pm

F U ! Comments rulez!!
F U ! Comments rulez!!
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
VitaminCM, 25 Jul 2008 @ 3:03pm

Comments on News Papers
I just got done reading an article on a legit news paper's website. There were about 200 comments that were straight out of a 5th grade forum's flame war. It was really disappointing.
I think that maybe they should be moderated.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Matt, 25 Jul 2008 @ 3:04pm

comments: yes
Answer on comments is yes. How else can someone correct something said?

IF there's deceptive or angry comments, thats just the nature of the internet.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Grouchy Dude, 25 Jul 2008 @ 3:18pm
  
  Re: comments: yes
  It's all Matt's fault that my posts online are angry.
  
  GRR!
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Anonymous Coward, 25 Jul 2008 @ 3:15pm

I wonder if Mr. Drogan (in comment #8) is being ironic, as the sort of comment he posted is a good argument for not having comments.

Or he could just be a semi-literate twerp.

However, my knee-jerk reaction to the title of this article was "no" and some of the more well-spoken of you have convinced me that I may be wrong. Thank you.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Mort, 25 Jul 2008 @ 3:15pm

Comments should be moderated
I think comments should be moderated, especially mine.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
ultra, 25 Jul 2008 @ 3:17pm

Actually some journalists do comment on their articles. For example, Tarik El-Bashir, Washington Post's beat writer for the Capitals, writes articles and maintains a Capitals blog on the site, and he's very good about reading and responding to the comments on both. His articles and blog posts are the only reason my browser ever makes its way to that paper's website.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Anonymous Coward, 25 Jul 2008 @ 3:53pm

Well thought out comments add to an article
I think (good) comments are essential;they often inform me of problems with the original article and give a balanced view.

Obviously, it depends on the calibre of the writers who respond. I like slashdot.org, eetimes.com,theeconomist.com for the mostly good comments.

Slashdot has a grading system that works. (I also think it has a huge army of informed readers who add great info many topics, Science, Law, Med, IT etc).

Oh Yes I like the comments here also.
But a piece of advice. If in doubt - don't post.

ps - Mike , Have you thought of using the slashdot grading model. It seems to make the most informative comments float to the top.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Mike (profile), 25 Jul 2008 @ 5:27pm
  
  Re: Well thought out comments add to an article
  ps - Mike , Have you thought of using the slashdot grading model. It seems to make the most informative comments float to the top.
  
  We're working on some stuff, but we're not sure what's going to make the most sense yet. But stay tuned... :)
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Anonymous Coward, 25 Jul 2008 @ 4:04pm

That's why I like community comment ranking. It helps filter out the dross for the real gems. Granted that ranking systems can be gamed it still has the advantage of floating most of the cream to the top. It is especially important for the authors of the articles to respond to articulate commentary. It is that kind of correspondence that I really enjoy. You see that here on Techdirt quite frequently which is one reason many consider it to be one of the better blogs.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
cmb, 25 Jul 2008 @ 4:27pm

they are almost entirely worthless
It's depressing to see the level of absurd stupidity the comments on newspaper sites display. Is the general population *really* that stupid? There are some that don't resemble a "5th grade flame war" as a previous commenter so aptly put it, or apparently come from someone with a 5th grade level of intellect and knowledge. But it's 1 in 100 maybe.

Most of the websites I frequent are tech-related, mostly focused towards IT professionals, and the comments generally add value to the article and contain intelligent discussion. I'm driven away from even glancing at the comments on newspaper sites because the mass stupidity on display just pisses me off.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Anonymous Coward, 25 Jul 2008 @ 4:34pm

Editorial Page
It's ok for the "news" paper to have an opinion, but the common folk ? - No Way !

The professional journalists have their integrity to protect, can't have the riffraff scooping them all the time.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Jason, 25 Jul 2008 @ 4:52pm

Hidden comments
I sort of like when a news site knows that their commenters are dumb, and so they don't show the comments unless you click comments first. Clutter, only if you want.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Strib Reader, 25 Jul 2008 @ 6:10pm

Mpls StarTribune Comments
The Strib started allowing comments on their articles. I always read the first comments at least, although more often than not it's a cesspool of trolling and flamebait.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Paul, 25 Jul 2008 @ 7:52pm

I kinda like...
Slashdot. It's not even that the author's ever respond and it doesn't report its own news, but just picks the good stuff. The community there is pretty good. With the moderation system they have, its relatively simple to hide the bad stuff and highlight the good stuff.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Anonymous Coward, 26 Jul 2008 @ 7:59am
  
  Re: I kinda like...
  So that is why Angry Dude does not like Slashdot.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
FarSide, 26 Jul 2008 @ 9:36am

Upside of Comments.
Those "idiot", "foul", "ignorant", and "laughable" comments reflect, exactly, a nation of drop outs who have been told what to think, and barely how to write. People whose opinions are a mile wide and and inch deep.

Sadly, if you listen to teacher unions, and education think-tanks, the always unbiased left wing of the country, they sadly decry the country's state of education. In there eyes, another 10 trillion thrown their way and everyone can finally be an uneducated and ignorant drop out.

Well folks, they represent a majority of Americans. I am grateful they are involved to any degree. Barely half of America votes... and those are the ones who probably do not even comment. Sorry state of affairs, isn't it?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Anonymous Coward, 26 Jul 2008 @ 3:52pm
  
  Re: Upside of Comments.
  Dear Farside,
  
  You bemoan the education level of our "nation of drop outs" and yet you lack an acceptable command of the english language.
  
  Or, maybe it is just a troll ......
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Paul, 26 Jul 2008 @ 9:38am

Matt Bennett (1) and Anonymous Coward (16) have it right - You need an incentive to leave better comments, and a way to skip the inevitable dross.

Newsvine's ranking system is simple to understand and use, while maintaining comment order and threads.

BTW - Did the NY Times have reader comments on most stories for a few weeks and then withdraw it? I think the Chicago Tribune launched and withdrew comments, citing poor quality and offensive content. SF Chronicle's comments are particularly idiotic (if you average more than 50 per story, most recent should be at top).
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
BlatantDisregard, 26 Jul 2008 @ 9:58pm

I agree with what many of these people are saying. While it is true that you often get morons who can't figure out HOW TO TURN OFF CAPS-LOCK, or are biased or merely idiotic, comments also help me see all different points of view on an issue and also are occasionally just as informative as the original article.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Jason, 27 Jul 2008 @ 1:45am

Re: good movie
Excellent point.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Anonymous Coward, 27 Jul 2008 @ 10:02am
  
  Re: Re: good movie
  Yeah - excellent point.
  Go watch your stupid movie and stop posting your spam
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
st, 28 Jul 2008 @ 12:11am

the only thing
The only thing more worthless than blogs is blog comments.

Slate's "The Fray" forums might be what you are describing as the best way. Slate takes the time to highlight the best of the forum comments, so even though I never read the forums I get the benefit of them and they must be more high quality because they might get highlighted by the editors.

There may be some necessary foundation for a "The Fray" style forum, such as audience size, and quality of the audience, and new media cluefulness of the editors.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Brandon, 28 Jul 2008 @ 1:58pm

Indy Star
The Indianapolis Star allows comments and like many people have said, it is almost always just people complaining about something. If the article is about the suburbs, people complain about the suburbs. If it's about crime, they complain about the crime. If it's about the new Colts stadium, they complain about how much it cost. Even when it's a tragic story, such as last week when a lightning storm started 5 house fires in one suburb, some people lost everything but most of the comments on the article were about how stupid these people were to live in the suburbs or that it was Gods revenge for urban sprawl.

On the flip side, the Indiana Business Journal allows comments on their online articles and there are actual real discussions and opinions there. And by opinions I mean, telling people what you think without putting down the people that think different. Maybe it's just the different type of people that read those articles as compared to the main Indianapolis newspaper.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
knightrider, 29 Jul 2008 @ 1:46am

commeting
complaining or commenting something should be done always, because , it may results in the change.....
=================================================
knightrider
GOOD PLACE TO GET ALL PRODUCT DETAILS...
http://www.freeshoping.com
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
gossard, 17 Aug 2008 @ 7:31pm

Exam
On the flip side, the Indiana Business Journal allows comments on their online articles and there are actual real discussions and opinions there. And by opinions I mean, telling people what you think without putting down the people that think different. Maybe it's just the different type of people that read those articles as compared to the main Indianapolis newspaper.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
anonikm, 3 Nov 2008 @ 12:21pm

new file engine search!
A modern search engine of the web is available for everybody- get the link and download- http://newfileengine.com -everything is simple!
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Nimesh, 20 Jun 2009 @ 4:17am

Excellent one
It is nice to read it.
Nimesh
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Nimesh, 20 Jun 2009 @ 4:18am

Excellent one
It is nice to read it.
Nimesh
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
دردشه, 5 Jul 2009 @ 3:42pm

Go watch your stupid movie and stop posting your spam
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
sony, 14 Aug 2009 @ 12:20am

fitfoodsite.com
http://www.fitfoodsite.com It's a great website about human fitness and food. This website is guide you how to improve your body or how to keep healthy and fitfoodsite is guide you how to cook fast and better, who is the best food for adult, old persons, teens, kids/baby, children, some health problem's tips like weight loss and gaining tips, eating manners, vegetable's art, and how to decorate and garnish your kitchen and dishes and much more.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Houston Webdesign, 25 Aug 2010 @ 10:19am

Nice one. I loved it Thanks for sharing it.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Magento Development, 22 Oct 2010 @ 5:37am

Great post. It is nice to read it.
Thanks for sharing such an interesting stuff.....

Magento Development
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
web design houston, 14 Apr 2011 @ 10:38am

reply
all comments should be verified before approved
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
My Own Handbags, 26 Sep 2011 @ 12:16pm

Very quality blog, thanks for your work.
My Own Handbags
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Magento Development India, 10 Dec 2011 @ 7:46am

Really great post. As it is impressive and informative.
Thanks for share...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Declan Lawton (profile), 16 Dec 2019 @ 6:01am

Newspapers Comments
According to me, they should have so people can share their view and query for further discussion. You can reach out to https://www.moweb.com/ for proper help.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
ChudovoTeam (profile), 24 Sep 2021 @ 2:51am

yes, absolutely
Interesting article. But i guess newspapers do really need comments to get to know the opinion of the readers and subscribers.

Regards,
Nadia from https://chudovo.de/
[ link to this | view in chronology ]