Texas Judge Forces Topix To Unveil Info About Anonymous Commenters
from the so-much-for-protecting-anonymity dept
While plenty of other countries don't provide very much protection to anonymous commenters online, US courts have time and time and time and time again found that it's important to protect the rights of anonymous speech online. That doesn't mean that you can say anything you want -- but it does mean that a court should be quite clearly convinced that the speech violates the law before allowing any progress in an attempt to unmask an anonymous participant.Unfortunately, it looks like a judge in Texas has ignored all of that. Topix, the online news aggregation and local community site, has apparently been told by a judge to cough up identifying information on 178 formerly anonymous commenters on the site. The details are still a little unclear from the article linked here -- but it looks like the commenters were discussing a sexual harassment case that was happening in Texas. In that case, the defendants were found not guilty, but apparently the online comments on Topix got somewhat nasty. So the couple, fresh off being acquitted of sexual assault charges, sued 178 different anonymous commenters -- and the judge seemed to have no problem ordering Topix to turn over any identifying information it had on those commenters.
This is troubling for a variety of reasons, as it does not appear that the court spent much time in determining whether or not actual libelous statements were made -- it just ordered Topix to hand over the info. Previous courts have found that even if the commenters were being jerks and totally obnoxious, that doesn't take away their right to anonymity. So why is this judge so willing to wipe away anonymity? If there are truly libelous comments, then it could make sense to go through a careful process of trying to identify who they came from. But to give a blanket order to hand over the names seems to go against what so many other US courts have done in similar situations, and raises serious questions about the right to anonymity online.
Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.
Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.
While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.
–The Techdirt Team
Filed Under: anonymity, comments, libel, texas
Companies: topix
Reader Comments
Subscribe: RSS
View by: Time | Thread
Soooo....
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Money grubbing lawyer
P.S. Wouldn't it be funny if all of the anonymous posters were his mom?
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Texas Courts
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Soooo....
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Re: Soooo....
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Texas Courts
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Not all Texas....
[ link to this | view in thread ]
So what information are they in a position to hand over? If they're "very, very careful" (and even half-intelligent) they didn't collect any information beyond what can be seen on the site. But he doesn't say that, so they probably did. And they will hand it over eventually. This is another of those security lessons that people never seem to learn: don't hold on to confidential information unless you really, really have to.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re:
IP Address + Time = (for most cases) the ISP Account of who posted.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Texas Courts
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re:
[ link to this | view in thread ]
You give up your right to be anonymous
Want to stay anonymous? Don't post to the internet from your home or work computer.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Re:
That's idiotic. Identifying an account holder does NOT tell you who made a post.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Texas Courts
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Re:
"That doesn't mean that you can say anything you want -- but it does mean that a court should be quite clearly convinced that the speech violates the law before allowing any progress in an attempt to unmask an anonymous participant." --Defamation, even if it happens anonymously, is still actionable. The comments alleged in the complaint are defamation. Case proven; therefore the IPs should be released.
I'm not sure why people are so up in arms about it. The judge had to follow the existing law - you know the one that says you can't libel and slander? The one that exists in EVERY state?
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re:
Seems somewhat nasty to me.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Re: Re:
I don't know about every other state, but the law in Texas did not require the judge to order the revelation of all these identities. Check the law before you go shooting off your mouth.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Subpoena First, Ask Questions Later
We lawyers need to be arguing more for the strict application of Dendrite. There is in fact a Texas appellate state court ruling that requires an affirmative showing for discovery to identify anonymous defendants, In re Does 1-10, 242 S.W.3d 805 (Tex.App.-Texarkana 2007), just as there are cases like that in California. Krinsky v. Doe 6, 159 Cal.App.4th 1154, 72 Cal. Rptr.3d 231 (Cal.App. 6 Dist. 2008). But the problem is that the plaintiff comes in asking for discovery and it is just an ex parte proceeding with nobody to point out to the judge what the governing law is. It will be interesting to learn whether the lawyer who came into court ex parte called the judge's attention to the legal requirement.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Trolling Issue
Oh my! 0_0
What shall I do?
I've read the case..
Never posted anything to a sexual site or trolled any opinioners on a sex site, except for Connor.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Mo der a tors
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Soooo....
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re:
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
topix
[ link to this | view in thread ]
court order
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
terrorists at Topix
very quiet life. I stumbled upon Topix a couple of years ago. I started posting
on a thread about food stamps where genocide for the poor was gleefully being
discussed as a serious remedy to the country's deficit. I commented with a
different view, one that doesn't involve hate, and found myself under attack in
the most vile way. I was so outraged at what I was seeing and so inexperienced
on the computer, I kept a hand written log. I was also so inexperienced on the
ways of forums, I was shocked to see the lies, manipulation and lack of any
ethics or morals. There was somebody in that forum that had Topix
administrative function. He could remove posts at any time, change posts to say
vile things then re-post them, change the "judge it's",etc. I stopped posting
to that thread but no matter where I went, this person would find me and start
with the threats defamation and in general, terrorizing me. I figured out how
to save things on my computer and started keep some of the vile posts. I have
about 137 saved.
I started posting on the "Should the US have universal health care" thread. I
found myself under attack again. A few weeks ago a troll announced
he had found my personal information and posted my husband's full name and age.
I complained to Topix. I'm not even sure if they got
the complaint. None of these posts were removed.
On the night of June 17th,
2010, I received 6 phone calls to my unlisted number in Springfield starting at
12:25am, with the last one logging in at 1:20am. I got the person to talk to
me. I ask him where he got my number and he replied that I have an unusual sir
name or unusual name several times. This is the same terminology he used in the
forum to announce his victory in finding my identity. He said he got my
information from 411. He never explained where he got my name.
On June 24th I received two more calls at 12:46am. However this time the caller
forgot to mask their number the first time and it registered on my phone. The
second call was made with in the same minute and registered "Private Name,
Private number" . I didn't answer either of these calls and didn't even noticed
they had been received until early the next morning. I called the exposed
number and the voice that answered sounded very much like the same voice from
the 17th calls. On June 25th, at about 10:00pm, I found my kitty, my little
friend, with a broken neck laid out on my sidewalk. I reversed number checked
the phone number and found it is registered to someone less than 6 blocks away.
On the night of the 26th my car was vandalized. All of this started after my personal information was exposed on Topix.
Topix is truly the most dangerous place on the net! It goes beyond mere defamation and libel. My little friend, Chloe, paid with her life. I wonder if that murderer heard my screams of anguish and grief...I'm sure he did. He will be hearing that in his dreams forever!My life has become a living hell because of these "people". EXPOSE THESE TOPIX TERRORISTS ....NOW!
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Topix
Free speech isn't about this.
I say that you should have to be identified and then say
whatever you want.
Deal with the consequences too.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Topix Profits Fron Sladerish Gossip Posts
I am not against Topix. I like the idea of having a site to go to for local information by others in the same town. But we greatly need moderation AND I believe we need to toss out anonymous postings by anyone that types in a few letters for a make believe name, because we have a lot of people shooting off slanderous posts and hiding behind the technology that Topix has help foster, Many things could help, such as forcing all posters to register for a name/handle and demanding a working email, along with a system of removing all of the tons of posts/threads that many of us feel are in violation of many laws and need to me removed NOW.
If you are unaware of what I am speaking about, check out what is being posted in your own home town. From what I have observed, it seems the smaller the town/community, they more damage is done by posts/threads using real names and info about local residents. I do not see how many lawsuits can not be the result of the current system in place. If Topix would only make a serious effort and removing all of the offending and often not legal information about others it might change the perception of them, but they need to implement changes "yesterday" in order to stop the misery many people and their families have got by slanderous looking posts, and now we see what appears to be a leak of medical information on a political candidate for political gain, which would seem to be in direct violation of HIPAA Federal laws, and if the medical story is untrue it would seem to be SLANDER and could cost a person an election. Personally I feel things are way out of hand at this point. I would like to see Topix do the right thing and put a strong effort in at stopping so many bogus and hurtful, if not flat out not legal, postings on their site.
Topix, please do the right thing and put much more effort and cleaning up your site. I do not hate you, I feel you have done a lot of good. But ever since you started allowing just anyone to hide behind their computer and say whatever they want about the guy down the street from them in a public forum, true or false, and do not have a realistic method of allowing users to flag these posts/threads for removal, things have gone from bad to worse (imho). Please remove all of this trash which is wreck many people's lives by their own words.
Thank you, and peace.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Please Hire More Moderators
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Registration
Topix started off a good idea and they have managed to ruin it. There are so many anti-Topix groups out there on facebook and other places and has anyone seen http://toxictopix.webs.com , pretty informative stuff
[ link to this | view in thread ]
judicial decision
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Where to send complaints about content on Topix
It may also help to send complaints about the forum to the Attorney General in the State of Washington, where Topix is based. If the AG's office receives enough complaints, it's likely they will put pressure on the company to institute an AUP, and enforce it, and develop tighter mechanisms to respond to complaints.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Re:
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Everyone commenting here needs to be introduced to 4chan
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Because I'm suing high officials they block topix posts
Those items btw, were my brother's cell phones (which were found AT MY BROTHER'S HOME) which he had allegedly used to send his ex-girlfriend and her ex-husband" naked photos of herself in order to demonstrate that she had slept around with him while she was married.
This "victim" was friends of the police dept. and D.A..And she is a Hot Chic.
Even though my brother had been gone from my home for 2 years....and was living in his own home- (where the actual cell phones in question WERE found), the aforementioned defendants in my lawsuit nonetheless wanted in my home.....JUST IN CASE that maybe my brother could have hid something in my home or with me.
My misfortune of being related to a brother in a nearby town who ran afoul of a hot chic with friends in high places.
Anyway, the federal judge has ILLEGALLY ruled against me with very well plead (and PROVEN) counts, and the local newspapers and television stations will not breathe a word of my lawsuit, even though I handed them a copies.
This is a very big lawsuit with very serious (and proven) allegations against these authorities.
I cannot even scratch the surface of what they did to me (ie: seized a junk vcr recorder from my home and later claimed that it was used by my brother to secretly record this hot chic--------and get this-------they simultaneously searched my brother's "actual" home (where he actually lived) and purposely did NOT take HIS vcr recorder.
(The cops HAD to have something from my home, so that in retrospect, they could claim that they found supposed items used in alleged crimes.)
This forced me into having to file suit.
Now...........the federal judge has blatantly ruled against LAW......and the media won't breathe a word of this to the public. You can see why the judge is so eager to illegally rule against law (to protect people in high places). He knows that where there is no public knowledge, I can therefore be screwed BIG TIME!
You have no idea how angry I am.
Enter Topix forum.
Since this medium is the only way of my informing the public what is going on, I started posting details and allegations of my lawsuit on Topix Forum.
At first "someone" simply took down the posts within a few hours. But shortly afterward, they somehow have blocked ALL places local to me in town where I can use my netbook and post information about my lawsuit via public wi-fi connections.
They were not going to have even ONE person read my posts before they got around to deleting them.
Somehow, any comments I attempt to post anywhere around my town (maybe elsewhere? WILL NOT appear.......period. No matter which wi-fi location I find.
This is some corrupt shit going on here. What's most sickening about the conduct of the authorities ,is that this is all because of a hot chic that the D.A. and police must REALLY have wanted in her pants.
THAT'S reason enough to hide this lawsuit from the public, which gives a green light to the federal judge to screw me without the light of day exposing what's going on.
As to Topix, I used to thank God that I had an avenue to expose the corruption which occurred and still is occurring against me. That was very short lived.
Unfortunately for me, now the authorities have found a way to block my comments on Topix by pre-emptively blocking ANY posts I attempt to post (about ANYTHING)........through any wi fi spot around here, so that this pro se schmuck (myself) can bend over and eventually walk away with nothing....except having spent $20,000 expecting to obtain justice.....and not just for myself......for everyone......so that these clowns would never try something like this again.....against ANYONE.
This is what I've learned:
IF THE AUTHORITIES CAN BLOCK ALL MEDIA FROM REPORTING AGAINST THEMSELVES, YOU CAN REST ASSURED THAT THE FEDERAL JUDGES WILL CERTAINLY SCREW YOU...................since nobody is looking....or will be the wiser.
It was bad enough to realize that the media is complicit (for whatever favors they received in return from the aforementioned authorities). But at least in my case, even TOPIX forum cannot be relied upon.
Double Standard Anyone????????????
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re:
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Topix Victim
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Topix Profits Fron Sladerish Gossip Posts
[ link to this | view in thread ]
[ link to this | view in thread ]
illuminati
WELCOME TO THE GREAT ILLUMINATI BROTHERHOOD,we welcome those that are ready to become and no the meaning and powerful useage of the illuminati.we have created a group on whatsapp for those interested in become a great member to the temple add on our trusted agent on +2349059880557 add and be rich now .
[ link to this | view in thread ]
illuminati temple
[ link to this | view in thread ]
a cure for all diseases
tuberculosis, west nile virus, coronary artery
disease, diabetes millitus, mental health issues,
hiv/aids,hearing loss and impairment, a spell to
bring your ex back, meningococcal disease,
insects borne disease, bacteria infection,
traumatic brain injury,Qfever,, coxiella burnetil
and kidney diseases. the solutions has come call
the GREAT DOCTOR'S TELEPHONE NUMBERS
+2348131927027
[ link to this | view in thread ]
great brotherhood illuminate temple
efficiency Genuine help has been provided to mankind in the lights of the religious illuminati occult temples. Fortunately for all the benefits we provide are all geared towards uplifting the spiritual..physical social monetary and many others aspects of the life's of does who are willing.issues of individual lives are taken care of whether monetary or not. Person sseeking power for increment in business enterprise and lot of celebrities an prominent personalities all have their Sucre in life to the efficiency of our temples. Are u suffering from a life threatens sickness or u needs supernatural powers to increased the growth of ur church? Do you wish for a life partners of ur choice? Or u wish to secure a well paying jobs? These are more others problem in life will all be a thing of the past as fate has led u to ur green message illuminati temples. For membership contact ur delegate on whataspp +2347039093271 Mr Frank
[ link to this | view in thread ]
join the illuminatibrotherhood
[ link to this | view in thread ]
you. You provided the best
spell casting service I have
ever paid for! You helped calm
down my anxiety overnight and
cancer i have been a spell casting
service user for several years
now and none of the other
spell casters I have used can
compare to your amazing
service! Thank you very much
for being there when I needed
you!mary in po
for orther problems contact him on
SriAvinashhealingtransmission@yandex.com
[ link to this | view in thread ]
need a loan?, We give out loans to People despite their poor/bad Credit
scores. We give out both business and personal loans with long and short
term duration of your choice. Our loan programmer is fast and reliable,
apply today and get instant field back.
Our loans are ranging from a minimum $5,000.00 USD and maximum of
$100,000,000.00 USD,Our loans are well insured, 100% Guaranteed and
Clients are assured maximum security. For further inquiry contact us via
our email address::::Christopherfinanciallink@mail.com
Best Regards
Mr Deo Christopher MD/CEO
Email Christopherfinanciallink@mail.com
[ link to this | view in thread ]
WELCOME TO ILLUMINATI,; the Club of the Rich and Famous; is the world oldest and largest fraternity made up of 3 Millions Members.We are one Family under one father who is the Supreme Being. In Illuminati we believe that we were born in paradise and no member should struggle in this world. Hence all our new members are given Money Rewards once they join in order to upgrade their lifestyle.; interested viewers should contact us on what's app+234708 946 7825
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Re: Re: Texas Courts
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Hello I am FELICITY MARCURLY, from Arizona . I am publicizing this amazing testimonial of my life to you because i knew of so many people who will still be having this same issues, which you are finding so difficult to solve. I and my HUSBAND have been suffering from HIV for the past 2 years. we have visited doctors but they couldn't get the permanent solution to my sickness. I almost loosed it until one faithful day when i saw so many amazing testimonials about DOCTOR MARK how he has cured patients infected with HIV. So i told my HUSBAND and we both decide to give it a try and contact him, here we are now. All thanks to DOCTOR MARK for curing our HIV permanently. Now we are both perfectly fine, and we are both HIV negative. you too can get cured today by contacting his email address now on (markherbs1960@gmail.com) WhatsApp (+12256273803} this is the doctor whatsapp number you can reach him on it if you need his aaaistant he can also cure the treat cancer and any other sickness he can also cure cancer,diabites and pregnacy problem and he can also help you to get back your lover. just contact him for any problem he wiill surely assist you (+12256273803} this is his whatapp number
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Illuminate
Join the Illuminati brotherhood for protection, powers, fame, wealth, riches, cure to all illness, popularity etc. Achieve all that you ever wish and hope for just in 3 days. If you believe in your dreams and destiny contact our initiator MASTER through WhatsApp+2347018381260 Hail the light
[ link to this | view in thread ]
I'm Harry Bhagaloo from Ontario Canada. I want to share my testimony on how i received my $74,000.00 loan from ANNIE FINANCE COMPANY, It's not a rumor that some fake company post comment of their self online deceiving people and collecting money from them. Am a soldier who got disable during war since that time life haven't be easy for me, My wife divorce me thing became bad i was depress i almost commit suicide during this time my finance went down i was seriously in need of financial assistance until a friend whom also was a beneficiary from ANNIE FINANCE COMPANY encourage me to contact them via E-mail which i did to God be the glory i received the loan successfully, ANNIE FINANCIAL COMPANY gave me hope to live. Today my life have became a blessed and fulfilled. I got re-married to the best and beautiful woman in the entire world CIARA, she is pregnant with my baby. Today being Wednesday after close of my business i decide to go through the internet then i start seeing comments posted about loan i smiled and decide to write a short summary about how i received loan that change my entire world, This goes for people who seek financial assistance, The very company i will refer you to contact is ANNIE FINANCIAL COMPANY, I pray every of your problem come to an end. I have my E-mail below for more info about this company or kindly reach them via info.annie_finance@yahoo.com
E-mail bencarson501@yahoo.com
[ link to this | view in thread ]
HOW I GOT MY HUSBAND BACK HOME WITH THE HELP OF A REAL AND GENUINE SPELL CASTER DR CHIEF PRIEST TEXT EMAIL HIM ON chiefprinst12@gmail.com KAYLEE TAYLOR.
My name is KAYLEE TAYLOR am from united state, I almost took my life because of my husband who left me and stop picking my calls answering my mails and my messages. He said He do not trust me anymore, I tried to convince and beg him, but he will not believe or answer me until we had a fight and broke up for 6months, after then I realize I can not live without him because of the love I have for him. I tried everything possible to get him back, but non worked for me, some fake spell casters scammed me and went away with my money until I came across this man called DR CHIEF PRIEST he helped me cast a spell and behold my husband came back after 48 hours, begging me for forgiveness, I was so surprised that spell caster like DR CHIEF PRIEST still exist. If anyone here needs some help, with all sincerity, contact DR CHIEF PRIEST today On chiefprinst12@gmail.com indeed you are a priest thank you for making my home a happy home again i can never stop talking about you sir. DR CHIEF PRIEST is really a great man you can contact him for solution for any kind of problems like
(1) lottery spell
(2) ex back
(3) get pregnant
(4) cure for any kind of sickness,disease and infection
And many others contact this great man today and get your Problems solved.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
MUST READ
Don't stress out. Just because you have bad credit doesn't signify an individual can't get a loan. Annie Finance specializes in affordable loan and fast service. our priority is to assist you with loan. If you are in need of financial assistance don't worry about it anymore kindly send your request to info.annie_finance@yahoo.com, Our online program is actually private and also safe, When you have employment plus a checking or savings account, you may be eligible. Annie Finance is a licensed and reliable loan provider that you can rely on when you really need extra money. Our own state-of-the-art technologies safeguards your personal information. The mortgage specialists tend to be devoted to providing nurturing as well as exceptional customer support. you will be amazed with the service we provide. email us with the amount you need, duration period and purpose for loan now at info.annie_finance@yahoo.com
[ link to this | view in thread ]
cryptocurrency trade
Trading Cyptocurrency is a good thing. i lost a lot before I got to where I am today. if you need assistance on how to trade and recover the money you have lost from your Cyptocurrency broker email me to get the new amazing strategy? If you are having problems withdrawing your fund from your Cyptocurrency trade broker even when you were given a bonus, just contact me, i have worked with a Cyptocurrency broker for 3years, i have helped a lot of people and i wont stop until i have helped as many as possible,here is my email flanmustelafu@gmail.com
[ link to this | view in thread ]