Guess That Bull In Texas Was A Good Investment: EchoStar Agrees To Pay TiVo To Settle Patent Case

from the money-wasted dept

Mon, May 2nd 2011 1:56pm — Mike Masnick

TiVo and EchoStar have been in a ridiculously long patent dispute over DVR patents that began years ago. TiVo won nearly all of the early rounds, but the tide turned a bit last year, though it looked like TiVo was going to get something out of this. Of course, all of this was happening while the Patent Office itself was expressing doubt about the patents in question.

The case is now over, with EchoStar agreeing to pay TiVo $500 million (significantly more than the initial jury award). Of course, some will use this to suggest EchoStar should have just paid up early on, and from a financial perspective, they're probably correct. But, really, this once again shows the ridiculousness of the patent system. Many millions of dollars were wasted on this lawsuit, and then a final massive transfer payment is made. All of that money could have gone towards actually innovating and building better products. What a waste.

Of course, this also brings to a close one of the more bizarre side notes to this story. Back when the district court case was being tried in East Texas, TiVo paid $10,000 to buy an award-winning bull in Marshall, Texas... which it renamed TiVo. Pretty much everyone suggests this was a really cynical ploy to influence the jury. I'm curious what ever happened to the bull?

Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.

Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.

While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.

–The Techdirt Team

Filed Under: dvrs, patents
Companies: echostar, tivo

17 Comments

If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

Nom du Clavier (profile), 2 May 2011 @ 1:38pm

Looking at the result
The bull shat; the resulting outcome is bullshit.

Now if only the manure ends up being used to fertilise ... oh never mind, this bullshit analogy clearly won't work as well as a car one.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Anonymous Coward, 2 May 2011 @ 2:06pm

Like any award winning bull, it had two options, become steak, or become a gene factory.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- ChurchHatesTucker (profile), 2 May 2011 @ 2:19pm
  
  Re:
  If it's an award winning bull, it's certainly going to be put out to stud.
  
  So, TiVo will continue screwing everything it can in East Texas.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
  - Nom du Clavier (profile), 2 May 2011 @ 2:36pm
    
    Re: Re:
    So that's how you become a steakholder?
    [ link to this | view in chronology ]
  - Anonymous Coward, 2 May 2011 @ 3:24pm
    
    Re: Re:
    They're going to pair it up with a cow named Dish.
    [ link to this | view in chronology ]
    - The eejit (profile), 2 May 2011 @ 11:38pm
      
      Re: Re: Re:
      PLease tell me the other null in this triangle is called Spoon.
      [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Mr. Smarta**, 2 May 2011 @ 2:10pm

Something to consider...
So if aliens came down to Earth from some planet somewhere using technology they created but companies here on Earth patented, who sues whom??? Does that mean an advanced civilization from another planet can sue earthlings for all the patent infringment? If companies expect that in their case, then the aliens get to, also.

Patents, copyrights, trademarks... It's all meaningless bulls*** anyway. Just another illusion to make people believe there's a weapon constantly hanging over their heads ready to swing down and destroy them.

Share everything. And piss on those who try to stop us. We get stronger, while they get weaker.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
DogBreath, 2 May 2011 @ 2:25pm

As to what happened to "TiVo"...
I'm curious what ever happened to the bull?

It was eaten by the TiVo lawyer:

http://amlawdaily.typepad.com/amlawdaily/2009/06/new-ip-trial-strategy-10000-for-that-b ull.html

Eastern Texas has plenty of livestock. And Marshall hosts an annual Farm City Week, which in March 2006 came just on the eve of the Tivo v. EchoStar trial. TiVo's local counsel, Samuel Baxter of McKool Smith (no relation to this writer), told Elinson that TiVo executives wondered whether they could buy a cow at auction "because the people have been so nice to us here."

As Elinson writes, Baxter did that and more. At Farm City's main event, a livestock auction, the legendary Eastern District lawyer bid on a Grand Champion Steer and bought it for a record-breaking sum of $10,000. The steer was quickly christened TiVo. (According to the Recorder, the seller was a high school student from nearby Hallsville who kept the money for herself to use for college.)

Perhaps finding the pastures in Silicon Valley to be lacking, Elinson reports that TiVo execs offered to return their namesake steer to its original owner. She declined given the tight quarters of her college dorm room.

So where is TiVo the cow now? "We turn 'em into steaks and burgers," Baxter told Elinson. So it seems that TiVo, the bovine version, ended up in Baxter's belly.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Blatant Coward (profile), 2 May 2011 @ 2:36pm
  
  Re: As to what happened to "TiVo"...
  Apparently he was no Cow Tse Toungue. Or didn't have enough revolutionary veal.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
  - DogBreath, 2 May 2011 @ 3:00pm
    
    Re: Re: As to what happened to "TiVo"...
    Probably not cowmmunist enough either. I hope they cooked him well, or someone might have come down with the trotskys.
    [ link to this | view in chronology ]
  - Anonymous Coward, 2 May 2011 @ 3:04pm
    
    Re: Re: As to what happened to "TiVo"...
    loved that song.
    
    Cows With Guns...
    [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Anonymous Coward, 2 May 2011 @ 2:35pm

I figured steak, I didn't care to check and see if it was a county fair or what. When you see business's buy livestock at crazy prices (like $400 a chicken) at auctions it is usually for the prize winning animals a kid raised because it's how alot of those kids get money for college. It is common practice for the livestock to get purchased and returned to the owner.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Anonymous Coward, 2 May 2011 @ 2:40pm

It is definitely a good PR move, think of it more like giving a 10,000 scholarship. Which is definitely a good reason to raise an eyebrow for trying to influence the community for the trial.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Peter Dow (profile), 2 May 2011 @ 3:19pm

Wasted $ ?
While saying that the $500M is wasted money and does not get applied to innovation, it's probably not entirely accurate. Sure, a lot of the $ goes to the lawyers, and that's not contributing to innovation, but whatever amount gets to TiVo might actually be spent on R&D.

However, I definitely agree with the overall idea -- patents these days are a hindrance to innovation.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- abc gum, 2 May 2011 @ 5:53pm
  
  Re: Wasted $ ?
  "but whatever amount gets to TiVo might actually be spent on R&D."
  
  Yeah, they will "invent" another obvious idea.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
staff, 5 May 2011 @ 7:08am

who is Masnick working for?
"Patent Office itself was expressing doubt "

The PTO grants reexams for 95% of requests. Even Masnick could cobble together a request to reexam the telephone patent. Who is the PTO working for? And while at it, who is Masnick working for?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
patent litigation, 9 May 2011 @ 1:00pm

bosom buddies?
One weird thing about the settlement proceedings in this patent litigation is the extent to which the parties -- recent adversaries -- gushed about each other in glowing terms afterwards. I'd guess some kind of partnership between the parties is in the offing.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]