Dear Rotolight: The Internet Never Forgets Your Censorious Past, Even If You Deny It
from the look-at-that... dept
So, you may have heard the story this week about Rotolight forcing down a video review they didn't like of one of their lights -- and then admitting publicly that they did it because they thought the review wasn't fair (and also claiming that they thought it violated their trademark, even though the DMCA doesn't cover trademark). That story got quite a lot of attention, and quite a bit late, Rotolight posted its official statement in response, in which the company sought to both apologize... but also defend the initial actions. There is also the odd statement that the video wasn't taken down for copyright reasons, even though the creator of the video, Den Lennie, clearly received a copyright takedown notice.In this specific case, the video was not removed for copyright infringement reasons as has been widely reported. Rotolight received external advice with respect to this particular video that it was potentially misleading and unrepresentative. This advice resulted in the only request the company has made to have a video removed from any video sharing website in the last 3 years.As Popehat notes, either Rotolight or Vimeo is lying here, and it's hard to believe that it's Vimeo. If they didn't send a copyright takedown, then why don't they say what they actually sent? Clearly, Vimeo received some sort of notification.
However, two more tidbits have popped up since then, thanks to the lovely internet. First, we have Jeepers Media pointing out to us that Rotolight's claim above that this is the "only request the company has made to have a video removed from any video sharing website in the last 3 years" does not appear to be true. CheesyCam has the story of how it had posted a YouTube video... and Rotolight had (you guessed it) taken it down:
While CheesyCam doesn't link to the original post, it appears to be here. Oops. So, clearly not the first. Also, a commenter on Popehat points out that it's highly unlikely that Rotolight did not understand copyright or the nature of DMCA notices (or the difference between copyright and trademark), in part because the founder/president of Rotolight also runs one of the largest music publishing/producing businesses in the UK -- and his wife is an entertainment lawyer who wrote a book about copyright that was published not too long ago.That’s total bull, because this has actually been a practice of RotoLight for at least the last two years. Two years ago, I posted up a video about one user and a UFO camping light who may have mentioned he was making his own DIY RotoLight. Obviously it was a UFO camping LED light, and because of the camparisons, RotoLight commented on this blog and admitted to taking down the users YouTube video:
“FYI, the YouTube Video on which your article relates has been removed due its to defamtory nature, breach of our Registered Trademark and misleading information”.Whoa wait a minute! The DMCA cannot be used for Trademark claims. That was two years ago, and who knows how many other YouTube or Vimeo videos were taken down in that time frame, but I can tell you the recent Den Lennie attempt was not the first. The fact that they are now playing dumb and backtracking as if this was the only DMCA they filed is a load of crap.
So, um, that's nice that you're a small business and you want to rehabilitate your reputation and all... but it might help to start out by not lying about the claim that this was the first such video you've taken down -- or about the nature of the takedown. As they say, it's often not the original bad deed that gets you in the end... but the attempted coverup.
Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.
Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.
While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.
–The Techdirt Team
Filed Under: censorship, copyright, history, reviews, takedowns, trademark, videos
Companies: rotolight
Reader Comments
Subscribe: RSS
View by: Time | Thread
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
No.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Miranda and the Streisand Effect
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Miranda and the Streisand Effect
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Does that apply to you ??
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
SO? What's your fix?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: SO? What's your fix?
Now while most cases this is as far as it goes, as the law requires the affected to prove the impossible, that the DMCA was in bad faith, in this case you've got the company pretty blatantly admitting that the DMCA claims have nothing to do with copyright, and everything to do with getting rid of criticism, so I agree, these would make perfect test cases, and hopefully set a precedent and add a real penalty to fraudulent DMCA claims.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: SO? What's your fix?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: SO? What's your fix?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Rotolight Lectures about IP Enforcement HOT HOT
Her Twitter is all about Rotolight, lobbying for tougher IP Laws AND Her music Seminars
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons
• She Claims Stronger Copyight Laws are NOT about Silencing Speech LAST YEAR on Twitter
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/160896372667719681
"Scare mongering by social media sites is wrong, the bills are not to restrict anyones voice, just to stop digital theft. Issues can be resolved."
• https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/160897311004835842
"Why is theft in the digital domain different to stealing from a record shop?"
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/160895549732687872
"Re: SOPA & PIPA digital piracy is not an acceptable social habit its theft. It stops working composers,producers & artists earning a living.
• She Launched and Runs a Music Distribution Rights Company, Her Tweet
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/31830267576455168
"Did I mention I'm launching "sync in the city" a music placement company for film and tv. Should be 'live' in a few weeks."
• The Music Publishers Will Gain Control, Her Tweet
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/31829978861535232
"Music Publishers have the upper hand if they control both the music and the master and it will bring great success (BMG Rights Management)."
• A Tweet about her "Music Copyright Seminar"
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/255386446633005059
• Anti Music Piracy Tweet
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/247622808300052480
• HUNDREDS of Rotolight Tweets Here's a Few to prove correct Account
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/361201052323815424
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gamm ons/status/324240614403211264
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/314062180804882432
https:// twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/303596159174332418
• One of her "Music Seminars" http://www.henley.ac.uk/mba/henley-mba-music-creative-dynamics.aspx
Helen Gammons actually LECTURES on IP Enforcement Learned from years as a Music Industry Leader and Co-owner in Several Music Publishing houses!
Tuesday 14 May 2013, 10:21 | By CMU @ TGE
Artist brands and the challenges of communicating copyright tackled at Great Escape IP-themed sessions
CMU Business Editor Chris Cooke will lead a debate on the challenges of ‘communicating copyright’, with Sentric Music’s Chris Meehan, Henley Business School’s Helen Gammons, First Column Management’s Phil Nelson and the Music Managers’ Forum’s John Webster.
http://www.thecmuwebsite.com/article/artist-brands-and-the-challenges-of-communicating-c opyright-tackled-at-tge-ip-themed-sessions/
• A Technorati Article on her Music Lectures http://technorati.com/entertainment/article/henley-business-schools-new-mba-for/
Helen Gammons Linked In
Helen Gammons's Overview
Current
Programme Director at Henley Business School www.henley.com/mbamusic
CEO at Sync In The City
Owner / Director at Rotolight.com
Owner at Planet Video Systems Ltd
see less
Past
Creative Director. at Avex Inc
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Well, Here is there Address found at this link
http://www.rotolight.com/contact-us/
Pinewood Studios,
Pinewood Road,
Iver Heath,
SL0 0NH
Heres a Google Earth Pictures Below of the Tiny Quaint Address
https://twitter.com/JeepersMedia/status/363509783950680064
https://twitter.com/JeepersMedi a/status/363509783950680064/photo/1
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Genesis?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Genesis?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
RotoLight Tweeted Last Year that Copyright Laws Not about Censorship
Claims Copyright Laws NOT TO SILENCE Bloggers LAST YEAR!
All Proof Here! I have Tons More Now! Most here from Owner's Personal Twitter.
The "Claimed" owner of Rotolight is actually "Helen Gammons" on her linked In. ( Details at Botton of this comment )
Her Twitter is all about Rotolight, lobbying for tougher IP Laws AND Her music Seminars
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons
• She Claims Stronger Copyight Laws are NOT about Silencing Speech LAST YEAR on Twitter
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/160896372667719681
QUOTE: "Scare mongering by social media sites is wrong, the bills are not to restrict anyones voice, just to stop digital theft. Issues can be resolved."
She believes downloading music same as Physical Theft!
• https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/160897311004835842
QUOTE: "Why is theft in the digital domain different to stealing from a record shop?"
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/160895549732687872
QUOTE: "Re: SOPA & PIPA digital piracy is not an acceptable social habit its theft. It stops working composers,producers & artists earning a living.
• She Launched and Runs a Music Distribution Rights Company, Her Tweet
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/31830267576455168
QUOTE: "Did I mention I'm launching "sync in the city" a music placement company for film and tv. Should be 'live' in a few weeks."
• The Music Publishers Will Gain Control, Her Tweet
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/31829978861535232
QUOTE: "Music Publishers have the upper hand if they control both the music and the master and it will bring great success (BMG Rights Management)."
• A Tweet about her "Music Copyright Seminar"
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/255386446633005059
• Anti Music Piracy Tweet
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/247622808300052480
• HUNDREDS of Rotolight Tweets Here's a Few to prove correct Account
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/361201052323815424
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gamm ons/status/324240614403211264
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/314062180804882432
https:// twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/303596159174332418
• One of her "Music Seminars" http://www.henley.ac.uk/mba/henley-mba-music-creative-dynamics.aspx
Helen Gammons actually LECTURES on IP Enforcement Learned from years as a Music Industry Leader and Co-owner in Several Music Publishing houses!
Tuesday 14 May 2013, 10:21 | By CMU @ TGE
Artist brands and the challenges of communicating copyright tackled at Great Escape IP-themed sessions
CMU Business Editor Chris Cooke will lead a debate on the challenges of ‘communicating copyright’, with Sentric Music’s Chris Meehan, Henley Business School’s Helen Gammons, First Column Management’s Phil Nelson and the Music Managers’ Forum’s John Webster.
http://www.thecmuwebsite.com/article/artist-brands-and-the-challenges-of-communicating-c opyright-tackled-at-tge-ip-themed-sessions/
• A Technorati Article on her Music Lectures http://technorati.com/entertainment/article/henley-business-schools-new-mba-for/
Helen Gammons, Owner of Rotolight, "Sync in the City" Music Licensing Site (Conveniently Down for Maintenance at the Moment! )
Heres the Wayback Machine Home Page!
http://web.archive.org/web/20120305131309/http://www.syncinthecity.com/about-us
Web Link
http://www.syncinthecity.com/about-us
I Screen Capped and Posted Rotolight's Owners tweet from Last Year About how Copyright Laws are NOT used to Censor here;
https://twitter.com/JeepersMedia/status/363506126328832000
(Incase she Removes Original ) Here;
https://twitter.com/Helen_Gammons/status/160896372667719681
Helen Gammons Linked In
Helen Gammons's Overview
Current
Programme Director at Henley Business School http://www.henley.com/mbamusic
CEO at Sync In The City
Owner / Director at Rotolight.com
Owner at Planet Video Systems Ltd
see less
Past
Creative Director. at Avex Inc
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I have a feeling they're going to play the game a little longer. Oh well at least it provides some good entertainment lol.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Ouch
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
How do you feel about censorship here on TD
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: How do you feel about censorship here on TD
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: How do you feel about censorship here on TD
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: How do you feel about censorship here on TD
You come from a den of pirates, darryl. You've no business criticising anyone.
Go fuck a solar panel.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]