Oh come on ... you totally set yourself up for that one. How could you expect someone, anyone, to NOT call you out on it? Just laugh, say "good one" and move on.
but back to feeding the troll ...
What lie? Are you saying that the labels don't rip off musicians and keep the profits for themselves? Are you saying that SOPA won't result in a flagrant abuse of the internet (much like bogus DMCA takedown requests do today)?
What I think that many pirate apologists seem to miss is that nobody in the music industry is against new ways to distribute content, new ways to contact fans, new ways to make connections.
Unless those new ways have any sort of measurable negative impact on their existing (read:ancient) business model's bottom line ... then it's all lawyers and lobbyists from there.
The inventive aspect of what they did was combining three seperate and unrelated devices into one device.
Palm and ... Windows Mobile ... have been able to do what the iPhone does for far longer than the iPhone has been out. I'd hardly call apple inventive in this regard. What they did, and did well I will readily admit, was simplify the whole interface to the point that a MASSIVE number of users could pick one up and figure out how to use it. An evolution of an existing species to better adapt to the current climate.
If you don't then your musical taste will not be catered for in future.
You're not implying that musicians only make music to make money are you? That if a musician doesn't make any money off of the music he creates then he will just stop making music (or at least that style of music)? I'd wager that the vast majority of musicians make music solely for the love of it. I want as many people as possible to listen to, and hopefully enjoy, what I create because I love what I do. I don't sit in my practice space with my bandmates pouring over the latest demographic information for our target audience so that we can carefully craft the next hit. I make the music I do because it's what comes naturally.
I know this is somewhat off topic but I felt the need to address that particular comment. There is a virtually limitless wealth of music out there. Certain genres or styles may become more difficult to find because the music industry doesn't deem it popular anymore so they don't push it into your face 24/7 but it's there.
Techdirt has not posted any stories submitted by setaside.
Re: Re: Watched a lot yesterday.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
but back to feeding the troll ...
What lie? Are you saying that the labels don't rip off musicians and keep the profits for themselves? Are you saying that SOPA won't result in a flagrant abuse of the internet (much like bogus DMCA takedown requests do today)?
Can you support those assertions with any facts?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:
You're talking about the record labels and SOPA, right?
Re: (as Adam)
Unless those new ways have any sort of measurable negative impact on their existing (read:ancient) business model's bottom line ... then it's all lawyers and lobbyists from there.
Re: Re: Re:
The inventive aspect of what they did was combining three seperate and unrelated devices into one device.
Palm and ... Windows Mobile ... have been able to do what the iPhone does for far longer than the iPhone has been out. I'd hardly call apple inventive in this regard. What they did, and did well I will readily admit, was simplify the whole interface to the point that a MASSIVE number of users could pick one up and figure out how to use it. An evolution of an existing species to better adapt to the current climate.
Re: Re: Re:
Reason to buy ...
If you don't then your musical taste will not be catered for in future.
You're not implying that musicians only make music to make money are you? That if a musician doesn't make any money off of the music he creates then he will just stop making music (or at least that style of music)? I'd wager that the vast majority of musicians make music solely for the love of it. I want as many people as possible to listen to, and hopefully enjoy, what I create because I love what I do. I don't sit in my practice space with my bandmates pouring over the latest demographic information for our target audience so that we can carefully craft the next hit. I make the music I do because it's what comes naturally.
I know this is somewhat off topic but I felt the need to address that particular comment. There is a virtually limitless wealth of music out there. Certain genres or styles may become more difficult to find because the music industry doesn't deem it popular anymore so they don't push it into your face 24/7 but it's there.
Techdirt has not posted any stories submitted by setaside.
Submit a story now.
Tools & Services
TwitterFacebook
RSS
Podcast
Research & Reports
Company
About UsAdvertising Policies
Privacy
Contact
Help & FeedbackMedia Kit
Sponsor/Advertise
Submit a Story
More
Copia InstituteInsider Shop
Support Techdirt