Once the US tries it, all the other governments will want the same level of access to devices used in their territory. The UK government is already proposing a similar scheme.
However, Angela Merkel is unlikely to be happy using a device that has US or UK government decryption keys built in. So will the manufacturers have to install different decryption keys depending on where a device is being used ? US keys on US devices, German keys on German devices, Brazilian keys on Brazilian devices.
International travel suddenly becomes very complicated.
If Michael Daniel visits France, will he be happy to comply with their laws and install the French government decryption keys on his Kindle ? What happens when he returns home. Will he want to be able to remove the French decryption keys once he is safely back in the USA ?
If Dilma Rousseff visits the USA, will she be required to install the US government decryption keys on her iPad ? Can she remove them again once she has left ? Will she ever be able to trust the device again, or do we all just throw everything away and buy new devices every time we cross a border ?
If the keys can be added and removed, who is authorised to modify the keys and how ? Who checks that a device has all the right decryption keys installed on it ?
By fax or by email ?
Is that code for "yes, it kind of might have been sent by fax" ?/div>
Re: How *Many* Governments and Agencies?
However, Angela Merkel is unlikely to be happy using a device that has US or UK government decryption keys built in. So will the manufacturers have to install different decryption keys depending on where a device is being used ? US keys on US devices, German keys on German devices, Brazilian keys on Brazilian devices.
International travel suddenly becomes very complicated.
If Michael Daniel visits France, will he be happy to comply with their laws and install the French government decryption keys on his Kindle ? What happens when he returns home. Will he want to be able to remove the French decryption keys once he is safely back in the USA ?
If Dilma Rousseff visits the USA, will she be required to install the US government decryption keys on her iPad ? Can she remove them again once she has left ? Will she ever be able to trust the device again, or do we all just throw everything away and buy new devices every time we cross a border ?
If the keys can be added and removed, who is authorised to modify the keys and how ? Who checks that a device has all the right decryption keys installed on it ?
Perhaps this a job for United Nations Cyber Law Enforcement ?/div>
Techdirt has not posted any stories submitted by Zarquan.
Submit a story now.