Spielberg Should Stick To Making Movies Rather Than Telling Us What And How To Watch
from the Spielberg-knows-best? dept
Steven Spielberg is certainly a great director who has made a bunch of really wonderful movies over the years. However, it's not clear why that then qualifies him to tell everyone else what they can watch and how they should watch it. In a new interview he first complains about gory content on TV and how it might effect children (noting that he sent his kids out of the room when he didn't like something on TV -- which seems like a perfectly decent solution). The reporter at least has the sense to note that some of Spielberg's own movies, such as Schindler's List and Saving Private Ryan have fairly graphic imagery -- and both have been shown uncut on TV. However, more interesting is his claim about how he doesn't like the idea of people watching his movies on an iPod screen. While many people seem to agree that iPods aren't great for video, it's a bit presumptuous for him to think that he can tell people how to enjoy the movies he makes. This isn't the first time he's tried to do this either. Spielberg was famous for holding out for a very long time on allowing his movies to go onto DVD, after he first supported Circuit City's "Divx" self-destructing DVD format instead. Perhaps instead of worrying about how and what people are watching, he should focus on what he's good at: making movies. Update: In the comments people are correctly pointing out that Spielberg's comments are less a demand and more about his decision not to create content for the super-small screen. That's fair, and perhaps I took his comments out of context -- but it still suggests a view where he believes he can draw the line over what are appropriate viewing practices. If we've learned anything over the last few years, it's that you need to go where the customers are, rather than refusing because you don't like it.
Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.
Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.
While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.
–The Techdirt Team
Reader Comments
Subscribe: RSS
View by: Time | Thread
Affect vs. Effect
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I happen to enjoy watching video on my iPod
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Old people?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
reminds me of the quote by Douglas Adams:
"Anything that is in the world when you're born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. Anything that's invented between when you're fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things."
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
Best post I have seen here in a LONG time!
If it's too graphic for children, then PARENTS not the FCC need to tell THEIR CHILDREN to leave or go do something else.
I like scary movies, I like blood and gore in scary movies, Hell I think all scary movies need gore, blood, violence, and of course BOOBS to be great.
Would I let my 3yr old daughter watch that? Absolutely not! That is why my wife and I watch it after she is in bed, or at a friends house, or out with another couple with kids.
People in America have become lazy. They are letting the government dictate to them what we can watch, how we can watch it, and when it is 'appropriate' to be aired.
Funny... I thought thats what a PARENT was supposed to do for their children. I guess the soccer moms are happy letting the government raise their kids so they have more time to get their nails done, shop at Crate & Barrel, and watch their Desperate Housewives while they dream of Pablo the Poolboy.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Hmmm, artistic choice.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
So what?
Oh, and newsflash: there is too much violence on TV. It's a pain to have to constantly monitor what your kids watch before the usual watershed hours of "grown-up" TV, and then send them out the room when something inappropriate comes on.
Honestly, you're just whining now.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: So what?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: So what?
THIS JUST IN...TAKING CARE OF KIDS IS A PAIN IN THE ASS. SIMPLY TURNING THEM OVER TO THE ELECTRONIC BABYSITTER IS NOT ACCEPTABLE!
Sounds like we should call you a Whaambulance!
But seriously, good to hear that someone cares enough about their kids to pay attention to what they're watching. For that I salute you! :)
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: So what?
I agree. It's a leap for Mike to state that Spielberg is telling people how to enjoy the movies he makes when all he's done is state that he doesn't like the idea. He's allowed to do that and Mike should stick to what's said and not read into or put words into it.
Oh, and newsflash: there is too much violence on TV
That's just a jackass thing to say all-around. Being just your opinion you should have a bit more humility rather than being a dick. I personally don't feel there is too much violence on TV. And, if your kids are at the age where you need to constantly monitor them in any way then it just comes with the territory of having them. Sounds more like you're whining about having to be a responsible parent than anything. Deal with it; it was your choice to go there.
Honestly, you're just whining now.
You're dumb. You've whined more in your own post. Get a freakin' grip. Be a responsible parent and don't complain about how hard it is to the world (nobody has sympathy for you there). You made one good point and then stuck your head up your ass.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Fuck you Dan
So take a flying fuck on a rolling doughnut asshole!
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
TOTALLY
(Hey Mike, at least his opinion was solicited via interview. I doubt anyone asked yours.)
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: TOTALLY
Wow. You must be some kind of boy-genius. What are you... 12?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Re: TOTALLY
Isnt it great to see the cycle?
I feel sorry for people that have nothing to stand for,
not even the wrong thing. Have you anything to add to your edifing post? :] Anonymous?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
FCC Priorities
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: FCC Priorities
What-the-fuck-ever. Don't let your kids watch things you find objectionable if you don't like it.
FOR THE LAST TIME SMALL-MINDED SHEEPLE!
It's... not... TV's... fault...
Is that clear enough for you or are you still interested in shoving your personal responsibility to parent your kids on something other than yourselves?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
So What Some More
As to too much violence on TV; heck, there's too much crap, period, on TV. Not just violence, but Dr. Phil, anorexic twins, Cheaters, Judge Judy, etc. But, we have the advantage of DVD's, books, PBS, etc. to counteract the general low quality of television.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: So What Some More
As far as violence on TV, eh...tired of the discussion. It is here to stay. I am convinced that with a little bit of parenting, kids can see violence on TV and not turn into serial killers.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Quick question.
That being said-- why is violence and sex inapproprate for children? I mean, the violence and sex that they can see on TV. (I'm not suggesting sitting Junior down in front of a family viewing of Indiana Jones and the Temple of Poon.)
I hear often about people futher censoring their children in an effort to 'protect' them from 'inappropriate' shows, movies, video games, etc... but I am still unsure what makes it inappropriate at a certain age-- or how you deternime at what age it becomes 'appropriate'. I think that as soon as a child can learn, they SHOULD learn. Why wait until the child is closer to becoming independant before showing them this part of society? Why not educate them from the start?
Just wondering, I don't mean to come across as some guy trying to tell people how to raise their kids.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
RE: TOTALLY
Actually, doucheball, there is an implicit request for Mike's opinion when you go to a BLOG where Mike is a writer and click on his article. In case "implicit" is too big of a word for you, I will try to explain it another way. You are an idiot.
@Mike: "Steven Spielberg is certainly a great director who has made a bunch of really wonderful movies over the years."
I think what you meant was probably "Stephen Spielberg is certainly a greatly over-hyped director who has made a bunch of over-hyped movies over the years."
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Deep Thoughts by Beefcake
We have choices what content we spend time with. For example, I've made the choice not to watch the vandalized version of E.T. The Extra Terrestrial (which, by the way, is a redundant title). It was Spielberg's choice to change it, and it's my choice to not watch it. I'm also personally offended by the musical "Annie". A kid in a wig shouting crappy songs for two hours sends me running out of the room.
And over it all is this almighty "Power" button. Truly a technological wonder.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
He's not telling you what to do
"Spielberg said iPod video may be all the rage but count his films out from tailoring his films to fit the small screen.
"That's one medium where I have to draw the line," he said. "We'll shoot for television and the movies and let there be a wide gap" between that and the small 3-inch screen."
He's not saying "don't watch SPR on the iPod," just he's not shooting his movies to be best viewed on a 3-inch screen. There's a huge difference on how you shoot something depending on where it's going. A TV show is staged and shot differently than an animorphic widescreen epic. He's just going for the epic.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
And What Mike Should Do...
His hold-out on the DVD format would actually mean something if it were still the case today; that fact that it's not serves as evidence that even his own personal opinions hold no sway over the demands of us consumers.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
TV and children -- just say no; it works
She also did well in school, which I believe to be highly correlated with not watching TV.
I have a TV nowadays (more than one, in fact), which gets watched about 5 or 6 hours a *month*. About once a month, I look through the listings to see if there is anything new worth watching on that vast electronic wasteland. Usually, there isn't.
--
chl-tx.com
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
RE: DOUCHEBALL
cjmemay, why don’t you just take your opinions and shove them. Get back to work and make sure you are “sticking to” your job. Do only that. You should know by now that you forfeited your rights to expressing opinions upon accepting a job offer (ESPECIALLY if those opinions are related to your profession, for shame!).
Oh, and in response to your post (which appears to be an excuse for using the new word you learned and swore you would use in a sentence today)…
...following a link from my Google homepage to this post is not in any way asking anyone to then give their opinion. Yes, by downloading the page i am asking to *see* any written content (opinion, fact, advertisement, over sensationalized article title, etc.) but i (nor anyone else, i suspect) ever explicitly asked for an opinion to be generated.
The relevant point here is that Steven Spielberg was asked to discuss some topics. He did. That's it... nothing more. And as AnonymousCoward pointed out, he is only "telling" someone what to do if that individual is in turn listening to him. Take Mike, for example. Mr. Spielberg clearly has him by the balls, because Mike is listening so intently to Spielberg’s opinion that he actually accepts it as a demand, and then goes on to write an article about how he is being told what to watch and how to watch it. Most other people probably read that interview and see an opinion.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
RE: DOUCHEBALL
cjmemay, why don’t you just take your opinions and shove them. Get back to work and make sure you are “sticking to” your job. Do only that. You should know by now that you forfeited your rights to expressing opinions upon accepting a job offer (ESPECIALLY if those opinions are related to your profession, for shame!).
Oh, and in response to your post (which appears to be an excuse for using the new word you learned and swore you would use in a sentence today)…
...following a link from my Google homepage to this post is not in any way asking anyone to then give their opinion. Yes, by downloading the page i am asking to *see* any written content (opinion, fact, advertisement, over sensationalized article title, etc.) but i (nor anyone else, i suspect) ever explicitly asked for an opinion to be generated.
The relevant point here is that Steven Spielberg was asked to discuss some topics. He did. That's it... nothing more. And as AnonymousCoward pointed out, he is only "telling" someone what to do if that individual is in turn listening to him. Take Mike, for example. Mr. Spielberg clearly has him by the balls, because Mike is listening so intently to Spielberg’s opinion that he actually accepts it as a demand, and then goes on to write an article about how he is being told what to watch and how to watch it. Most other people probably read that interview and see an opinion.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
As for violence on television, I have to say that I can respect Spielberg's opinion on this a bit, simply because of the examples he used. He cited CSI, a show I don't even watch unless I happen into a room where it's on, and I've still managed to see false surgery, reenacted brutal murders, and even a rape scene. That's effin disgusting, and of course it's our option to change the channel, but you have to realize that these sorts of things CAN affect children.
If they're on before 10, they REALLY should tone some of it down a bit. I don't care if they show Ichi the Killer on TV at 2am, but I don't want my kids seeing the cheerleader from Heroes with her entire ribcage showing as she lays on a morgue table. That's disgusting, and it's going overboard for a prime-time show. Put it on the DVD, put it on later at night, or put it on an adult-oriented channel. Of course I pay attention to my children's viewing habits, but when something says "TV14" for violence, I don't expect them to show something that would be considered gruesome or gory even in a rated R film. It IS overboard, and I commend Spielberg for using his clout and his media-granted soapbox to say something about it.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Whoops, I forgot to mention that the show Heroes airs from 9-10pm, and though right at the margin, many youngsters are still up (though I personally found the imagery of someone waking up and looking at their own open chest cavity pretty disturbing myself). This is also one of the shows that Spielberg mentioned (though for a different scene).
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
Good news E, that's not what they're seeing. They're seeing either a rubber model or an actor with kick-ass makeup on a set with lights and directors and technicians. If they don't yet know the difference between that and reality, what a great opportunity to start teaching them that very important distinction. Who knows-- the idea may fascinate them and we'll get the next Michael Westmore out of the deal.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Are you a morron?
When somebody gives a opinion, does not mean that
just because his a genius you MUST follow, but you must respect at least. Grow up.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
RE: Re: TOTALLY
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
iPod
Hey if your on a train going across country and you own a giant GB filled ipod then you can convert your Indiana Jones DVD set with
ipod-converter
I found websites that converts dvds to a ipod in google
and as for your next lens crafters bill for watching freaking almost 3 hour movies on your ipod send glasses bill it to apple.
As for tv I bet your kids get online and see all kinds of gross crap. You ever read comic books when you was little?
In Jr high this kid had this wild comic book and I went to the store and bought one for myself and read it.
It was an eye-opener very realistic even for a teenager I thought it was gross. I would hate for a kid to read some of these post on techdirty also. Some of the music these kids could get a hold of like Manson and they run around all DARK is just another example. lol
Besides don't we have the v chips in our tv sets and I know my DSS system has a channel lock.
Also from what I understand little kids go to bed at 8pm unless I guess if you live in a trailer park.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
What Spielberg likes or doesn't like...
I'm out of here.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]