P2P Doesn't Account For Most Net Traffic, Thanks To YouTube

Will The UK Ban Stephen King Books Next?

from the oh,-the-horror dept

Tue, Jun 19th 2007 3:23pm — Mike Masnick

Lots of folks have been submitting the story of British censors deciding to ~~give the new video game Manhunt 2 tons of free publicity~~ ban the new video game Manhunt 2. The censors are claiming that it's being banned for "unremitting bleakness and callousness of tone." Of course, that pretty much describes every horror movie or horror book ever created -- but we don't hear calls for those to be banned. Yet, the censors claim that the game "involves a range of unjustifiable harm risks to both adults and minors." It's not quite clear what those risks are. In the meantime, that second link points out that there's a campaign underway stateside against the game as well, from a group demanding that the game be given the strictest rating possible from the ESRB. Of course, the group pushing for this also admits that it's not yet seen the game. Apparently everyone there just knows that the game must be horrible. In the meantime, thanks to all this negative publicity, you can pretty much bet that the demand for Manhunt 2 just show way up.

Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.

Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.

While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.

–The Techdirt Team

35 Comments

If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

Paco, 19 Jun 2007 @ 3:44pm

Shoot...I don't even own a game console, but I might have to go out and buy one just so I can play this game when it comes out.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
wolf0579, 19 Jun 2007 @ 3:46pm

I suspect a religious group stateside for the ban before viewing approach. That's the fundamentalist way over here.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Seriously, 19 Jun 2007 @ 3:49pm

Of course it's going to be horrible...
The first game was not only gorey and sick, it was also a bad game. And the argument as to why video games are to be dealt with differently than movies and books is that they're interactive. There's incentive in videogames (especially Manhunt) to perform the most brutal kills. I can appreciate some violence in a game, but since when is that it's defining feature? I'd much rather play a game with good gameplay than simply play something because it's shocking. Shocking is not hard to do.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Koala MeatPie, 19 Jun 2007 @ 3:54pm

The UK (And easpecially Ireland)has always been trigger happy when it comes to banning things, be it Pink floyd Songs (Arnold Lane) To their very own Monty Python.

Bascially banning over there is like Sueing And the RIAA in the U.S.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Koala MeatPie, 19 Jun 2007 @ 3:57pm

That was used as an emphesis, not a matter of fact*
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Anonymous Coward, 19 Jun 2007 @ 4:13pm

I'm a teacher at a "fundamentalist" college and I played Manhunter. It wasn't that big of a deal. Why even bring this issue up.

The only groups that prejudice is allowed against is fundamentalist Christians.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
GIR, 19 Jun 2007 @ 4:17pm

Censorship
God, censorship, censorship, OH MY GOD Censorship!!! I hate it! I hate it, so f**king much (oh no, they've already got me self censoring my self?!). I side with Techdirt, what next? Elton John will be censored because his gay? Paris Hilton will be censored because she's blond? It's ridiculous. If censorship continues at this rate, our world will be like the world in the novel Nineteen Eighty-Five!!!
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Anonymous Coward, 19 Jun 2007 @ 4:25pm

Com on Anon Coward... That last statement is a load of crap. No one cares what Fundamentalists do until they decide to tell everyone else what to do. Your statement is twisted and only true if you believe it is your right to dictate other people's lives.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
matt, 19 Jun 2007 @ 4:30pm

fundies
fundies are indeed a part of the problem, they need to stay out of our lives and they don't....don't get me started. No other group seems to have 90% extremists who feel they have a right to tell other people how to live.

Anyway, mike typo on the last sentence? show way up?

also, this represents the stupid crap epople are, there's no other way to describe attempting to censor a single game as if it makes some kind of difference.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
PhysicsGuy, 19 Jun 2007 @ 4:30pm

@Anonymous Coward on Jun 19th, 2007 @ 4:13pm
"The only groups that prejudice is allowed against is fundamentalist Christians."

interesting that you turn a blind eye against the allowed prejudice towards atheists. of course, we're immoral, godless sinners who are going to burn in hell; i don't see why you'd even notice.

@Seriously
"And the argument as to why video games are to be dealt with differently than movies and books is that they're interactive."

interesting argument, it's too bad there's no supporting evidence what-so-ever for the interactivity of video games causing them to be any worse than any other type of violent media.

-

ever since i was young i recall being told by politicians and annoying mothers, who would rather be rabble-rousing than, get this, mothering, that by ripping my friends head and spine off, in the still-kick-ass-video-game mortal kombat, that i'd turn into some crazed, violent youth hell bent on imitating the things i did in those video games. what amazes me the most is that all these years later, when there's observable evidence that video games DON'T cause violent behavior, that this is still a soapbox issue with politicians and another generation of mothers who are inept at mothering. hint: if there was a CAUSAL relationship between playing violent games and violent behavior manifesting then myself and the hordes of others who competed trying to mutilate the other would be in quite different situations than we now find ourselves in.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
nipsey russell, 19 Jun 2007 @ 4:48pm

"There's incentive in videogames...to perform the most brutal kills. "

actually no, theres incentives to... push buttons. oh, horror!
[ link to this | view in thread ]
nipsey russell, 19 Jun 2007 @ 4:51pm

"The group said the Wii version was particularly troublesome because players would be able to act out the violence with the console's controller."

crap, i was wrong...the incentive is to, what shake a stick?
we're dooooomed!
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Anonymous Coward, 19 Jun 2007 @ 5:04pm

"The UK (And easpecially Ireland)has always been trigger happy when it comes to banning things, be it Pink floyd Songs (Arnold Lane) To their very own Monty Python.

Bascially banning over there is like Sueing And the RIAA in the U.S."

The U.K isn't actually that bad when it comes to games. It's not really that bad in general. Monty Python, for example, wasn't widely banned. "Life Of Brian" was banned in many parishes (a lot of which didn't even have a cinema in their borders) simply because no one actually bothered to make sure it's not a parody of Jesus. Which it isn't.

Manhunt 2 is probably up for banning because of some murder case we had a while back which blamed Manhunt (it later turned out that it was the kid who was killed who actually owned the game, not the other way around). They probably just can't be bothered going through all the negative press of various groups claiming they suck because they allowed it to be released.

Plus, seriously, Manhunt isn't even that good a game. I doubt Manhunt 2 will be any better.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Bob Jones, 19 Jun 2007 @ 5:15pm

Will the US stop exporting murderous, vile crap?

For the record I don't mean The War on Terror.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Anonymous Poster (profile), 19 Jun 2007 @ 5:21pm

http://kotaku.com/gaming/breaking/manhunt-2-rated-adults-only-270337.php

Manhunt 2 just got a preliminary AO rating here in the States. Looks like the UK's not the only place worried about the game.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
N0RR1N RADD, 19 Jun 2007 @ 5:34pm

The system works, people are broke...
My 9 year old son and I are avid gamers and we play multiplayer games together. Not only do I check the ratings before I give a game my blessing, I play the game myself. The ratings are just guidelines; it is a parent's job to decide if a particular game is suitable for their child.
We wouldn't even need the ratings if people still believed in personal responsibilty and took a more active role in their children's upbringing.
If the UK really wants to shield children from violent media, they should start by censoring the television news, which I don't let my kid watch, by the way.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
N0RR1N RADD, 19 Jun 2007 @ 5:45pm

Re: fundies
The best thing about "fundies" is you , as an American citizen, don't have to listen to them. In some countries, not listening to the "fundies" is punishable by death.

Typo? epople?
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Anonymous Coward, 19 Jun 2007 @ 5:48pm

"Of course, that pretty much describes every horror movie or horror book ever created -- but we don't hear calls for those to be banned."

Clearly you weren't around in the UK during the 80s - calls to ban movies ("Video Nasties") resulted in the Video Recordings Act - the very law used to ban Manhunt 2.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Charles Griswold, 19 Jun 2007 @ 6:04pm

Re:
crap, i was wrong...the incentive is to, what shake a stick?
Yes, exactly. You're killing things by exercising your masturbation muscles (think about the motions you make with the Wiimote). They're worried that one day you might snap, climb a water tower, drop your trousers, and "snipe" at people. :-P
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Koala MeatPie, 19 Jun 2007 @ 6:52pm

I'd Sugest applying the "Lego Rule"

Weapons and killing is okay as long as they are not modern looking. (Swords, Muskets) (Freak Video Camera looking Ray Gun)

For example, Halo, you're shooting Aliens that look nothing like Humans, and even if they did, the weapons are funky.

Every kid plays Cowboys and Idians, Cops and Robers Scince a hell of a long time. (Thank you Wired)
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Kyros, 19 Jun 2007 @ 6:53pm

I agree with N0RR1N RADD, He has a valid point in that parents need to be in charge of deciding whats appropriate for they're children. I don't want someone telling me what appropriate for my child. I don't want a government telling me what appropriate for me either. Besides, attacking something, especially this upfront only makes it more popular as mike said.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Anonymous Coward, 19 Jun 2007 @ 6:54pm

As Applyied to kids* under a Certain Maturity / understanding, not everybody - D'uh.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Paul, 19 Jun 2007 @ 7:14pm

Duh
"Clearly you weren't around in the UK during the 80s - calls to ban movies ("Video Nasties") resulted in the Video Recordings Act - the very law used to ban Manhunt 2."

Clearly he didn't bother to do any research before pulling a sensationalist title out of his ass either.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Newob, 19 Jun 2007 @ 7:32pm

Fallout 3
Can't wait for the "protect the children" banning of Fallout 3. Even if it sucks this will no doubt happen. But this is probably more of a publicity stunt, to get the game more attention so more people buy it anyway
[ link to this | view in thread ]
动画片, 19 Jun 2007 @ 7:41pm

I agree with N0RR1N RADD, He has a valid point in that parents need to be in charge of deciding whats appropriate for they're children.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Anonymous Coward, 19 Jun 2007 @ 7:43pm

Where do I buy it?
[ link to this | view in thread ]
T.J., 19 Jun 2007 @ 7:47pm

Re: Re: fundies
"The best thing about "fundies" is you , as an American citizen, don't have to listen to them. In some countries, not listening to the "fundies" is punishable by death."

Umm yeah as an American we don't got to listen to em. But when they go out of their way to get involved in MY life, I have reason to have severe disrespect for such people.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Gaming Dad, 19 Jun 2007 @ 8:00pm

Re: Will the US stop exporting murderous, vile cra
pffft! America is not the root of all evil. People are. Besides even though I love my country and I'm a vet. I have to admit national border's and differences are fading, and probably a thing of the past or soon will be.

Anyway on the topic at hand,

A game is a game, don't like it, don't play it. Don't want your kids to play it then try something new...parenting.

As a father of two I decide what my kids don't do and do.
I also teach them the difference between what's on the screen and real life to handle those moments (like at a friend's house) when I am not present. My kids make straight As (or near to it most report cards) We listen to music like Korn, Mariln Manson, KMFDM. Watch zombie movies and play every video game that we can get our hands on. Violence in children (and adults) comes from being the victims of violence. Either at the hands of adults or their peers. Not from the game/music/books/TV.

Nothing, no ban, no rating beats good parenting. I personally wish people would stop cesoring and just start parenting. Either that or stop breeding.

Make what ever game/movie/book you want people. If it sucks then no one will buy it.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
mike allen, 19 Jun 2007 @ 11:51pm

As I live in the UK banning is in effectual there will be copies around you just cant walk into a shop and buy it.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Edinburgh IT dude, 20 Jun 2007 @ 4:33am

Totally. I didn't care a jot about this; now I'm getting a chipped Wii and a US version to see what all the fuss is about.

(Incidentally, I work 3 offices down from the Rockstar buildings where the game is developed, and saw them in the pub as happy as Larry - they obviously know that a ban on the game is pretty much the best thing that could happen to promote their game.)
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Ferin, 20 Jun 2007 @ 5:34am

Reminds me of that idiot thompson suing to have Bully pulled from the shelves before it was even out yet. No doubt the manhunt games are freakishly brutal, but they could at least wait till it's been submitted to the ESRB or something.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Anon, 20 Jun 2007 @ 12:02pm

Re: Censorship
No, Paris Hilton will be censored because she's Paris Hilton. That's Hot
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Sean, 20 Jun 2007 @ 12:23pm

Re:
The way I understand it, the ESRB has given it an AO rating here. TakeTwo/Rockstar can make changes and re-submit if they want, but there's a good deal of discussion already about if Take-Two can financially afford the time and money it would cost them to have Rockstar do the needed work.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
Overcast, 29 Jun 2007 @ 6:50am

If you are willing to ban one item - others certainly won't be far behind.

You'd think the lessons of the past would teach people where 'banning' can lead.

I think 'power' not only corrupts the soul, but the mind too. How many politicians would the world consider 'smart'?

Plus - it'll just generate a re-sales market on e-bay for it.
[ link to this | view in thread ]
toptop90, 7 Aug 2007 @ 1:35pm

i thought shaun hutson novels were more graphic that kings novels.in other words 90% gore and hardcore sex
[ link to this | view in thread ]