Coldplay Denies Copying Satriani In Federal Court Filing

from the legal-guitarmageddon dept

Thu, Apr 16th 2009 9:14am — Blaise Alleyne

Last December, guitarist Joe Satriani sued Coldplay for copyright infringement over a similar sounding melody. The story generated a lot of discussion here, as people dug up countless examples of other songs with similar melodies (some predating Satriani's tune) to support the argument that it might just be a natural melody to sing over the chords. The lawsuit resurfaced in the news around the Grammys, with Coldplay calling it "ridiculous" and Satriani making an emotional case ("I felt like a dagger went right through my heart. It hurt so much..."). Techdirt reader GK points to the news that, last week, Coldplay's lawyers submitted a federal court filing arguing that any similarities between the two songs were not significant enough to warrant damages. It looks like this may actually go to trial since Satriani is demanding "any and all profits" and Coldplay is standing its ground, but GK suspects that they'll likely reach a settlement in the end, "offering Satriani a sense of vindication and Coldplay a quieter option for laying the thing to rest." That seems to be what Satriani wants.

If this really is a case of independent creation, it's troubling how difficult that would be to prove. In the comments of our original piece, several people noted the case of Bright Tunes v. Harrisongs in which a judge ruled that George Harrison had infringed another song through "unconscious copying" -- not intentionally, but by accidentally using a melody he'd heard elsewhere and had stored in his unconscious memory. The problem with "unconscious copying" and unintentional copyright infringement of a melody is that it undermines the independent creation defense and creates a pretty broad scope for what could be construed as copyright infringement in songwriting. Basically, any melody that sounds significantly similar to another might be considered "copied," even though that happens all the time in music. Plus, it's not like a similar sounding melody in a completely different song is harmful to the "original;" it's not like people are listening to Coldplay's song instead of Satriani's, or that one tune is impacting the commercial potential of the other. There is no functional equivalency in art.

The Harrison case is well-entrenched, but if Coldplay is intent on clearing its name, the case may offer the courts a chance to rethink the decision (or to re-affirm it...). Though, so far Coldplay's lawyers seem to be using a de minimis copying defense, arguing that any similarities are insignificant, rather than focusing on independent creation. At any rate, this could be a precedent-setting case... but don't hold your breath. In the end, it may well just be easier for Coldplay to pay up, settle and make it go away.

Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.

Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.

While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.

–The Techdirt Team

Filed Under: coldplay, copyright, joe satriani, music

35 Comments

If you liked this post, you may also be interested in...

Reader Comments

Subscribe: RSS

View by: Time | Thread

Anonymous Coward, 16 Apr 2009 @ 9:22am

Unlike hip-hop where they just rip off the accompaniment to a good song and stick a bunch of third-rate rhymes in front of it and package it as "music."
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Your Gawd and Master, 16 Apr 2009 @ 12:02pm
  
  unlike everything else..
  ....where they just rip off the music to a good song and stick a bunch of third-rate lyrics in front of it and package it as music...
  
  You forget ALL music has the 5/95 dope-to-doodoo ratio. You just happen to be a fucking bigot.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
sir_flexalot (profile), 16 Apr 2009 @ 9:40am

8-bar sample vs. melody copy
There is an 8-bar "gimme" rule in music where if you want to sample (i.e. exact audio copy) a song, you can usually get away with it, with a wink and a nod to the originator. Unfortunately, if the melody and lead are the same in a "new" song, giving the impression that it is not meant as a sample, and that becomes a platinum hit... for future reference, you better make sure the original author is dead before you try that.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Mark, 16 Apr 2009 @ 9:48am

Classical music
It's amazing how in the 1600 & 1700s it was considered OK to use the technique of theme and variation using snipets from other classical works to create your new music. I wonder how Mozart would feel about modern day sampling and copyright.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
LOL, 16 Apr 2009 @ 9:56am

Guess this means the end of "Top 40"...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
ChimpBush McHitlerBurton, 16 Apr 2009 @ 9:58am

Here's How To Slap Suckriani...
All Coldplay needs to do right now is instruct their lawyers to seek out all the artists who created songs with similar sounding chord progressions *before* Suckriani. Get just *one* of them on board, and file a counter suit against Suckriani for doing the same thing he's suing Coldplay for.

What do you bet Suckriani folds?

By the way, Suckriani is such a fucking has-been, he makes Neil Young look like a winner.

CBMHB
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Anonymous Coward, 16 Apr 2009 @ 10:05am
  
  Re: Here's How To Slap Suckriani...
  OH, Hahaha!
  
  I see what you did there, you replaced Satriani with Suckriani. How clever as well as subtle.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
  - ChimpBush McHitlerBurton, 16 Apr 2009 @ 10:11am
    
    Mission Accomplished...
    I was on a mission to root out the one Suckriani fan out there.
    
    Bonus Bux for me tonight!
    
    CBMHB
    [ link to this | view in chronology ]
    - Anonymous Coward, 16 Apr 2009 @ 10:23am
      
      Re: Mission Accomplished...
      Fuck you. I have more than one fan...
      
      oops.
      [ link to this | view in chronology ]
  - DS, 16 Apr 2009 @ 10:29am
    
    Re: Re: Here's How To Slap Suckriani...
    Come on, look at his user name, he's at the top of his game, a comedic giant. I can't wait to see his riff of Microsoft. I wonder if he'll put a $ in place of the 's'?????
    [ link to this | view in chronology ]
    - ChimpBush McHitlerBurton, 16 Apr 2009 @ 12:24pm
      
      Re: Re: Re: Here's How To Slap Suckriani...
      Ooooooh, "D$ is an a$$hole"
      
      Happy now? Ick.
      
      Aaaaaanyway, this is a perfect example of my point:
      
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6XnhFR73wOs
      
      Let's get this guy on board, and sue the suck out of Suckriani!
      
      GUNTHER RULES!
      
      CBMHB
      (aka "the comedic giant")
      [ link to this | view in chronology ]
      - DS, 16 Apr 2009 @ 1:03pm
        
        Re: Re: Re: Re: Here's How To Slap Suckriani...
        AWESOME! CBMHB SAID MY NAME WITH A $!!!
        
        Although I'm not sure how it fits in....
        
        Either way, regardless of that, take a listen to this..
        
        http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mceAlfjqGBU&feature=related
        
        They are all ripoffs.
        [ link to this | view in chronology ]
  - Anonymous Coward, 16 Apr 2009 @ 11:48am
    
    Re: Re: Here's How To Slap Suckriani...
    I don't even know who he is.
    [ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Andy, 16 Apr 2009 @ 12:30pm
  
  Re: Here's How To Slap Suckriani...
  Suckriani? Yea right. Nice to see maturity from you.
  
  I'm a huge Satriani fan, and I personally don't believe Coldplay stole that melody. To me, it sounds like a coincidence that the music fit so well together. I think it'll be very tough to prove.
  
  Grow up dude. Just because you don't like an artist doesn't mean you have to come up with stupid ass nicknames. Makes you seem like you're 10.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
  - ChimpBush McHitlerBurton, 16 Apr 2009 @ 12:44pm
    
    Re: Re: Here's How To Slap Suckriani...
    Hah.
    
    I made you say "Suckriani"
    
    CBMHB
    10/06/2000
    (My mom was partying like it was 1999 when she got pregnant)
    [ link to this | view in chronology ]
    - kirillian (profile), 16 Apr 2009 @ 2:28pm
      
      Re: Re: Re: Here's How To Slap Suckriani...
      So...ur like 10?
      [ link to this | view in chronology ]
      - kirillian (profile), 16 Apr 2009 @ 2:29pm
        
        Re: Re: Re: Re: Here's How To Slap Suckriani...
        aw heck...now the Feds are gonna come after me for being a ped because I TALKED to a child under 18.
        [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Stuart, 16 Apr 2009 @ 10:06am

Satriani
Wow. I used to listen to his music. It was good, not good enough to keep listening after this craptasticly idiotic move by him. Hope he is cool with saying he USED to have fans.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Andy, 16 Apr 2009 @ 12:32pm
  
  Re: Satriani
  So you weren't really a fan then eh. I think his music is great, and if he feels that another artist stole a piece of his music, he has the right to protect that. I don't agree that Coldplay did, but if you felt someone stole something from you, wouldn't you try and protect yourself?
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
  - Killer_Tofu (profile), 16 Apr 2009 @ 1:18pm
    
    Re: Re: Satriani
    Andy, nothing was stolen. If something was indeed stolen, sure, go and get it back. Except we are talking about copyright junk here. Nothing was stolen. It is not like now that Coldplay has used the tune Satriani can never use it again (and listening to originals of each song instead of the altered ones played on top of each other, they aren't complete similar anyways). This is just how music is. It can never be stolen.
    Sooo, if he feels that another artist stole a piece of his music, then he simply doesn't understand that its just all imaginary property. Its infinitely available. They can both use it and be none the worse off.
    If somebody copied the entire song, note for note, altering not a darn thing, including any lyrics, and then claimed it was their song, I might be able to see an argument.
    
    In the case of parodies, they give credit to the original author so I can't see any harm there either.
    In short, I think Satriani is just being a whiney bitch.
    [ link to this | view in chronology ]
DS, 16 Apr 2009 @ 10:09am

Wasn't this the same melody that was very similar to the Legend of Zelda theme song, which came out before both songs listed above?

Please correct me if I'm wrong, as I may very well be in this case.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- DS, 16 Apr 2009 @ 10:40am
  
  Re:
  Nope, I was right...
  
  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mceAlfjqGBU&feature=related
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
LOL, 16 Apr 2009 @ 10:58am

Lots of Coldplays sycophants out tonight.

Fags.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Brock Jockley, 16 Apr 2009 @ 12:27pm
  
  Re: Fags
  Yeah, that's what we called Satriani fans back in High School, just before we pantsed them and made them suck each other's cocks.
  
  Then we beat the shit out of them.
  
  Fags.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
  - DS, 17 Apr 2009 @ 1:34pm
    
    Re: Re: Fags
    Made them?
    
    Hell, it was hard to ever make them stop!
    [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Killer_Tofu (profile), 16 Apr 2009 @ 11:09am

Standing Ground
While I do not so much care for either. Well, I don't like about any Coldplay, and haven't really heard Satriani.
I do hope that Coldplay stands its ground until the end though. And that they win. By as wide a margin as is possible. Copyright needs to go down. The more restrictions we get on it, the better. That is until it is completely rewritten to make more sense and reflect today's technologies.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
fuzzix, 16 Apr 2009 @ 12:02pm

Satriani has a heart?
Never heard it in his music - it's pretty sterile, even as shredding goes.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- Azrael, 17 Apr 2009 @ 2:24am
  
  Re: Satriani has a heart?
  So Satriani is a shredder ? Never knew that. After listening to his sounds i thought he was recording his unnatural acts with goats.
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Dave, 16 Apr 2009 @ 12:54pm

DON'T SETTLE!
Come on, Coldplay has shitloads of cash and Satriani is being a pretentious haughty bitch.

Fight the case to the end and make that has-been hack eat his lawyer fees.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Dave, 16 Apr 2009 @ 2:55pm

Grammy's?
So when COLDPLAY has to pay up for the rip-off here will the Grammy's stand on all this? They will have to take away the awards otherewise THEY (the Grammys) are endorsing copyright infringement.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Jason, 16 Apr 2009 @ 4:20pm

Killing the Blues
It seems like this case could make every single blues song illegal...since they all sound exactly the same.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
GK, 17 Apr 2009 @ 7:55am

"Perish those who said our good things before we did."

- Donatus
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Gene Cavanaugh, 17 Apr 2009 @ 5:43pm

Coldplay and Satriani
"In the end, it may well just be easier for Coldplay to pay up, settle and make it go away."
Hummm! If they are that dumb, I think I will copyright middle C, and sue them for every song they produce.
After all, it might be easier just to pay up, right?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
- GK, 17 Apr 2009 @ 6:50pm
  
  Re: Coldplay and Satriani
  Please tell me you understand the difference between a note and a melody..................
  [ link to this | view in chronology ]
Digital Citizen, 20 Apr 2009 @ 4:52pm

get an iPhone to settle it
I bet the iPhone is smart enough to know Coldplay ripped off Satriani. And for those calling him Suckiani or whatever, that's worse punning than you give his music credit for... and what does it say about a band who rips off someone who supposedly sucks that bad? If Satriani is a has been, Coldplay is a never was for copying him. In denial about copying, in denial about why "their" music really sells.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]