French Radio And Television Newscasters Say 'Au Revoir' To Facebook And Twitter
from the paging-george-carlin dept
Say what you will about France (go ahead! -- that's why we have comment threads!), but it's never been afraid to look reality right in the eye and attempt to legislate around it. The French government seems to profoundly misunderstand the internet, an ignorance which has resulted in some of the worst legislation ever passed and some of the most wrongheaded judicial decisions ever handed down.Here's a brief recap of France's legislative/judicial prowess:
- Introduced HADOPI, the anti-piracy initiative better known as "three strikes," which was recently condemned by the U.N. as "a violation of civil rights" due to its ability to kick certain users off the internet if it doesn't approve of their activity. (See also: Libya, Syria, Egypt, Iran.)
- A French court declared that including the word "torrent" in your URL equals an admission of copyright infringement. (If one word = pleading guilty, god help the people at the Mole Station Nursery -- update: removed the link, because the nursery folks appear to have moved on to a new link, and "someone else" has taken over the old one.)
- Passed a data retention law that required an incredible amount of user data (including passwords and verification questions) be gathered by ISPs, who are also required to log every action by every user of their services. (See also: above "See also" list.)
Here's the latest in a long line of intellectually stunted decrees, via Business Insider:
This week we learned that France’s broadcasting regulator had just issued another decree: henceforth, hosts of television and radio programmes must refrain from uttering the words “Facebook” and “Twitter” on the air.[We'll pause briefly here for a collective rest-of-the-civilized-world interpretive dance known familiarly as the "Whiskey Tango Foxtrot." Additional exclamation points, question marks and incredulous expletives may be added as needed.]
Thus, a French news anchor is not allowed to say to viewers: “For more information on this breaking story, follow us on Twitter.” Nor is any television or radio presenter allowed to mention a programme or network Facebook page. If Facebook or Twitter make the news, they can be mentioned on a strictly “information” basis. But no urging the audience to connect via Facebook or Twitter to learn more, ask questions, give their opinions, and so on.
No, wait! There's a reason for this! Ecoute:
The CSA maintained that any on-air mention of a programme’s Facebook page or Twitter feed constitutes ”clandestine advertising” for these social networks because they are commercial operations. In a word, French television and radio programmes cannot be seen to be promoting Facebook and Twitter as commercial brands.Really? Twitter and Facebook have competitors? I know there are alternatives out there, but nothing I would consider a "competitor" (which would presume some sort of actual "competition"). Myspace? Seriously? Maybe a half-decade ago (or longer). As for Twitter, who else is out there? Tumblr (Blogging for people who don't like writing.™)? whatihadforbreakfast.com?
“Why give preference to Facebook, which is worth billions of dollars, when there are many other social networks that are struggling for recognition,” CSA spokesperson Christine Kelly said. “This would be a distortion of competition. If we allow Facebook and Twitter to be cited on air, it’s opening a Pandora’s Box — other social networks will complain to us saying, ‘why not us?’”
So, if it isn't a protectionist policy propping up development of Le Facebeauque, what is it? Business Insider's Matthew Fraser has a theory:
The obvious answer is that regulators like to impose rules, if only to make themselves feel important. That reflex is particularly in evidence in a heavily regulated society like France with an omnipresent state...Without a better theory in my back pocket, I'm inclined to agree. And like any policy that ignores two of the biggest rules of the internet (and sometimes, real life itself), the Law of Unintended Consequences and the Streisand Effect, it will be interesting to see what sort of backlash develops among the French themselves. The rest of the world hardly needs any more ammunition.
But there is another, more plausible, explanation. Facebook and Twitter are, of course, American social networks. In France, they are regarded — at least implicitly — as symbols of Anglo-Saxon global dominance — along with Apple, MTV, McDonald’s, Hollywood, Disneyland, and other cultural juggernauts. That there is a deeply-rooted animosity in the French psyche towards Anglo-Saxon cultural domination cannot be disputed; indeed, it has been documented and analysed for decades. Sometimes this cultural resentment finds expression in French regulations and laws, frequently described, and often denounced, by foreigners as protectionism.
Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.
Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.
While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.
–The Techdirt Team
Filed Under: censorship, france
Companies: facebook, twitter
Reader Comments
Subscribe: RSS
View by: Time | Thread
Challenge Accepted
Ok, France: The only sovereign nation to lose its own revolution in a manner deemed unconscionably hilarious.
This sentiment is unfortunately paralleled in the manner by which their current ruling body is constantly kicking themselves in their teeth.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
While every country is allowed to define it's own rules and laws, these kinds of rules just make them appear to be a bunch of retarded barbarians...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
Actually I think it is the opposite... it makes them appear to be a bunch of stereotypical "snooty Frenchmen" who think far too highly of themselves as the arbiters of culture.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Re:
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Re:
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
France
F*** the F***ing French
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Maybe the French should give innovation a try
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Victory!?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Victory!?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Re: Victory!?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I think it's stupid to forbid them to use the word twitter and facebook though since it's not really advertising.
But yeah, you cannot expect much from a government put in place by Paul Desmarais himself.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Obviously...
Obviously Pandora has paid the obligatory fee to stay on the air.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Obviously...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Not just Twitter/Facebook
Basically, impartial news programs shouldn't be using brand names (whether Twitter, Facebook, or Hoover, Sellotape -that used to be a big issue in the UK a while back) when discussing stories not related to them.
Obviously, in this case, the issue is the lack of competition - but that doesn't mean the law should be ignored... just makes it a bit silly.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Not just Twitter/Facebook
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
So if you ...
I may agree with much of what you said but you really shot a big hole in your argument with that paragraph and certainly reduced your pundit-creditability in my eyes.
By the way, I use identi.ca in addition to Twitter ... so there! (stamps foot for emphasis)
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
We're the idiots
It is free advertising for wealthy private companies. They should buy ads. I don't see newscasters mention TechDirt in every damn story. I do see them mention Facebook all day and night. For free. Because everyone's doing it.
A while back, every NPR story mentioned that they were talking to someone at a Starbucks. It was probably because lazy reporters kept going to the coffee shop for "real person" reactions. It came off sounding like every story was an ad for Starbucks.
Kudos to the French for drawing a line between content and advertising. A journalistic mention of a brand is fine if it is newsworthy. Otherwise, just say "check out our website for more information."
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: We're the idiots
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Much as I agree with the sentiment of the story....
Lets not tar all the French with the same brush. They are one of the leading developers of Humanoid commercial robots (www.aldebaran-robotics.com/en) and have many leading edge scientific programmes.
Their governement, however, does make some..... erm, interesting legislation but hey I am British and would say that.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Works for me....
I will be so glad when those 2 sites are burnished off the internet for good. Waste of bandwidth all the way around.
Dumb reason(s)... GREAT IDEA! All other businesses should take a lesson here..
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
They have a history of this
As you noted France is often upset by the encroachment of Anglo-Saxon cultures and language and they do their level best to try and stem the tide. Examples include creating the word "l'ordinateur" because they didn't want people using 'le computer' and frequent campaigns against the usage of "le weekend".
They get so upset about their language that the Adademie Francaise is tasked with protecting it and are very stringent and careful to keep it pure and untainted by foreign influence. What amuses me is that this contributes to the language's decline.
English is so successful precisely because it is a mongrel language. We shamelessly steal words from everywhere and are always adapting and messing around with the meaning of the ones we already have. This makes it accessible and versatile and therefore more attractive as a language. Its one of the important selling points for it and that sale seems to be going rather well.
That they are extending this wrong headed approach online should surprise no one.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Please?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Please?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Please?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Re: Please?
You're right. I failed to mention these options:
Academia.edu
Advogato
aNobii
aSmallWorld
AsianAvenue
Athlinks
Audimated.com
Avata rs United
Badoo
Bebo
Bigadda
Biip.no
BlackPlanet
Blauk
Blogster
Bolt.com
Buzznet
CafeMom
Cak e Financial
Care2
CaringBridge
Cellufun
Classmates.com
Cloob
CouchSurfing
CozyCot
Cross.tv
Cr unchyroll
Cyworld
DailyBooth
DailyStrength
Decayenne
delicious
deviantART
Disaboom
Dol2day
DontStayIn
Draugiem.lv
douban
Elftown
Epernicus
Eons.com
Experience Project
Exploroo
Faceparty
Faces.com
Fetlife
FilmAffinity
FledgeWing
Flixster
Flickr
Focus. com
Folkdirect
Fotki
Fotolog
Foursquare
Friends Reunited
Friendster
Frühstückstreff
Fubar
Gaia Online
GamerDNA
Gather.com
Gays.com
Geni.com
Gogoyoko
Goodreads
Goodwizz
Google Buzz
GovLoop
Grono.net
Habbo
hi5
Hospitality Club
Hotlist
HR.com
Hub Culture
Hyves
Ibibo
Identi.ca
Indaba Music
IRC-Galleria
italki.com
InterNations
Itsmy
iWiW
Jaiku
kaioo
Kaixin001
Kiwibox
Lafang o
LaiBhaari
Last.fm
LibraryThing
Lifeknot
LinkedIn
LinkExpats
Listography
LiveJournal
Livem ocha
LunarStorm
MEETin
Meetup.com
Meettheboss
Mixi
mobikade
MocoSpace
MOG
MouthShut.com
Mu bi (website)
Multiply
Muxlim
MyAnimeList
MyHeritage
MyLife
My Opera
Myspace
myYearbook
Nasza-klasa.pl
Netlog
Nettby
Nexopia
NGO Post
Ning
Odnoklassniki
OneClimate
OneWorldTV
Open Diary
Orkut
OUTeverywhere
Passportstamp
Partyflock
Pingsta
Plaxo
Playahead
Playlist.com
Plu rk
Present.ly
Qapacity
Quechup
Qzone
Raptr
Ravelry
Renren
ResearchGate
ReverbNation.com
Ry ze
ScienceStage
Scispace.net
ShareTheMusic
Shelfari
Skyrock
Social_Life_(website)
SocialVibe
Sonico.com
Stickam
StudiVZ
StumbleUpon
Tagged
TalentTrove
Talkbiznow
Taltopia
Taringa!
Tea chStreet
TermWiki
TravBuddy.com
Travellerspoint
tribe.net
Trombi.com
Tuenti
Tumblr
Vkontakte
Vampirefreaks.com
Viadeo
Virb
Vox
Wakoopa
Wattpad
Wasabi
WAYN
WebBiographies
WeeWorld
We OurFamily
Wer-kennt-wen
weRead
Windows Live Spaces
WiserEarth
WriteAPrisoner.com
Xanga
XING
Xt3
Yammer
Yelp, Inc.
Youmeo
Zoo.gr
Zooppa
The largest of these is Qzone with 480 million members, almost all of them Chinese. Now, with all that research behind me, it's now clear that this word dump completely invalidates the premise of this post.
I'll be sure to add a retraction that points out your helpful advice and possibly run a full correction, noting that this latest in French legislation is fully justified. With these FB and Twitter-shilling newscasters properly muzzled, it's only a matter of time before these two preferred networks fall into disuse and eventual "where-are-they-now" status.
I hope that this also enlightens our other readers who I may have mislead with my snarky bashing of Myspace and Twitter. You have my humblest apologies for my ill-informed attempt to bash France without any pertinent information to back up the claims I facetiously made.
I also applaud William for taking the lead in regards to Google's new +1 feature. I'm am also certain that the heady days of pressing FB's omnipresent "Like" button are well behind us.
[Note: to the commenter above this fray ("The way time writes makes me now want to skip whatever item he is writing about") -- you may want to skip reading this because I'm writing it. My apologies for placing my afterthought at the end of this extra-long comment, rather than before it, but as I stated, it was an afterthought.]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Please?
Hey moron, your browser allows YOU to make that choice for YOURSELF!! The effing story is essentially about idiots exactly like you and the French gov't, who somehow seem to want to make decisions for other people regardless of how those other people feel about the subject!
If you don't like Tim's articles or writing, then quit reading them and commenting on them - DUH!
The amount of stupidity of both the French gov't and the comment you made has just sent me over my recommended daily allowance of "stupid drivel to listen to". Great, now I have to turn off the internet until tomorrow and it's not even noon here on the left coast - thanks a lot, jackwagon!
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Please?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Please?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
larousse
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
About the porn link...
Mole Station Nursery is actually located at http://www.molerivernursery.com/ but still uses Mole Station in it's description. :-)
There are of course many other site names that might appear different when you remove the space. :-) For example:
Experts Exchange, Therapist Finder, PowerGen Italia, Pen Island, Who Represents... Those could also be read as: Expert Sex Change, The Rapist Finder, Power Genitalia, Penis Land, Whore Presents...
Yeah, dumb domain names. :-) Maybe that's why the French prefer their own language instead.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Dammit!
ROFLMAO
/spittake
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Blogging for people who don't like writing.™
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
The French Viewpoint
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
It's a catch-22
Should private sites like Facebook and Twitter get this kind of free advertising and traffic? No, but it's like telling people to visit your shop in the mall. You're trying to send people to your shop, but you're giving the mall free advertising.
But I agree with the last conclusion that this is a way for the French to stop intrusion by Americans. I'm sure the government would allow companies to promote the French version of Facebook.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Or a military related one...
In Canada (a country with two official languages, English and French) the province of Quebec (which is predominantly French) makes it ILLEGAL to list English without French, English before French, or English that is any bigger than half the size of the French on any signage in a place of business, failure too comply can result in a loss of your business license. It should be noted this applies even in private areas like offices or storage rooms and on things like garbage cans for staff use. From this we learn something we already know, French are very arrogant.
They may be arrogant but they do make good food, which is why we keep them around. They should give up (something they are also good at doing) on government, run away (another skill) from France and make food worldwide. Good money to be made there.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]