Verizon's Oath Will Still Scan Your E-mail For Advertising Purposes Because Hey, It's Verizon

from the Verizon-gonna-Verizon dept

While all major webmail companies have veered away from the idea of automatically scanning private e-mails in a bid to monetize the content for behavioral advertising due to public backlash, that's simply not how Verizon rolls. According to a deep dive over at the Wall Street Journal (watch out for the paywall, here's a Verizon-owned Techcrunch alternative), Verizon and its Oath subsidiary now offer the country's only major webmail service that still thinks this practice is a good idea:

"Yahoo’s owner, the Oath unit of Verizon Communications, has been pitching a service to advertisers that analyzes more than 200 million Yahoo Mail inboxes and the rich user data they contain, searching for clues about what products those users might buy, said people who have attended Oath’s presentations as well as current and former employees of the company."

After backlash, Google ended its own practice of auto-monetizing e-mail content for behavioral ads last year, acknowledging that the practice doesn't exactly instill trust in your customers (e-mails are still automatically scanned as part of the company's "Smart Compose" feature, but content is no longer monetized). Apple has never scanned subscriber e-mails for this purpose, and Microsoft told Techcrunch this week that the company does “not use email content for ad targeting in any way, anywhere in Microsoft." The shift has been part of an effort to compete on privacy, which is an idea that should be encouraged.

Coming from the telecom sector, Verizon's not quite as familiar with this whole competition thing. In comments to the Journal, Oath's vice president of data, measurements and insights provided a very Verizon-esque response, suggesting the scanning was a public benefit to users eager to see more relevant ads:

"Mr. Sharp said that being served ads is part of the trade-off users make in exchange for free online services, and that Yahoo’s research shows they prefer ads that are relevant to them.

"Email is an expensive system,” Mr. Sharp said. "I think it’s reasonable and ethical to expect the value exchange, if you’ve got this mail service and there is advertising going on."

Yes, so ethical.

On the plus side, Verizon's e-mail scanning doesn't include health and medical information, though in the wild west of consumer privacy oversight that is the United States, you'd have a hard time confirming that this or other information (like financial data) isn't being exploited. After all, Verizon doesn't exactly have a great track record about being candid about this sort of thing. That said, it looks like even before Verizon came on board Yahoo's e-mail scanning and monetization system went notably further than Google's ever did:

"Initially, Yahoo mined users’ emails in part to discover products they bought through receipts from e-commerce companies such as Amazon.com Inc., people familiar with the practice said. Yahoo salespeople told potential advertisers that about one-third of Yahoo Mail users were active Amazon customers, one of the people said. In 2015, Amazon stopped including full itemized receipts in the emails it sends customers, partly because the company didn’t want Yahoo and others gathering that data for their own use, someone familiar with the matter said."

The problem is that while Verizon has hungrily eyed Silicon Valley giants' ad revenues for years, its effort to pivot into the ad sector isn't going so well. The company's Go90 video platform, purported to be the cornerstone of Verizon's Millennial-focused video ad ambitions, recently imploded after a fairly severe lack of public interest. And while Oath may ultimately prove to be a powerhouse in advertising, refusing to bend to competitive trends and consumer concerns by scanning the e-mails of millions of subscribers for an extra buck isn't a great way to build a trustworthy brand.

Of course, anybody surprised that Verizon would take the low road shouldn't be. After all, this is the same company that was caught a few years ago covertly modifying user wireless packets so it could track users around the internet without telling them. It took two years for security researchers to even notice it, and months more before Verizon could be bothered to offer a working opt out tool. And while the company was ultimately fined by the FCC for the practice, a bigger variant of that technology has long-since been implemented across Verizon's entire Oath (the combination of Yahoo and AOL) ad network.

Of course we haven't even gotten to Verizon's ultra-cozy relationship with the nation's intelligence apparatus yet, or the fact that giant ISPs routinely engage in pretty sleazy behavior to undermine pretty much any effort to shore up the nation's privacy standards, regardless of the quality of the effort. All while hoovering up and monetizing private user browsing and location data on a scale that pretty routinely makes the Facebook, Cambridge scandal look like child's play.

Granted if Verizon wants to undermine its own efforts to pivot into the online ad space that's its prerogative, but it might make sense for the traditionally myopic telecom giant to try and evolve on the consumer trust front as well. As an aside, if you're a Yahoo e-mail customer, you should be able to opt out here.

Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.

Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.

While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.

–The Techdirt Team

Filed Under: email, privacy, scanning, yahoo, yahoo mail
Companies: oath, verizon, yahoo