Treating computers as authors for copyright purposes is a non-solution to a non-problem. It is a non-solution because unless and until computer programs can qualify as persons in life and law, it does no practical good to call them "authors" when someone else will end up owning the copyright anyway. And it responds to a non-problem because there is nothing actually distinctive about computer-generated works.
There are five plausible ways in which computer-generated works might be considered meaningfully different from human-generated works: (1) they are embedded in digital copies, (2) people create them using computers rather than by hand, (3) programs can generate them algorithmically, (4) programmers as well as users contribute to them, and (5) programs can generate them randomly. But all of these distinctions are spurious. Old-fashioned pen-and-paper works raise all of the same issues. A close look at the creative process shows how little really changes when authors use digital tools. The problems posed for copyright by computer-generated works are not easy, but they are also not new.
Nonetheless, there are library records privacy laws in place in NJ that should apply.
EFF is misleading; I don't think the California Reader Privacy Act applies to this case, though the CA library records privacy law Cal Gov Code ยง 6267 should make this illegal./div>
I posted an update on my piece, linked in the story- The developer of flp.mobi is voluntarily taking the repo down, out of fear that Caltech/Perseus will take down the free website./div>
Aaron, have you seen the recently launched Unglue.it? It aims to crowd-fund creative commons licensed ebooks.
Why do you make it hard to get the CC0 books and ask people to buy them on Amazon? Or maybe the better question is why should readers patronize an author AND buy their books?/div>
Techdirt has not posted any stories submitted by gluejar.
Grimmelmann has an articla about this.
Treating computers as authors for copyright purposes is a non-solution to a non-problem. It is a non-solution because unless and until computer programs can qualify as persons in life and law, it does no practical good to call them "authors" when someone else will end up owning the copyright anyway. And it responds to a non-problem because there is nothing actually distinctive about computer-generated works.
There are five plausible ways in which computer-generated works might be considered meaningfully different from human-generated works: (1) they are embedded in digital copies, (2) people create them using computers rather than by hand, (3) programs can generate them algorithmically, (4) programmers as well as users contribute to them, and (5) programs can generate them randomly. But all of these distinctions are spurious. Old-fashioned pen-and-paper works raise all of the same issues. A close look at the creative process shows how little really changes when authors use digital tools. The problems posed for copyright by computer-generated works are not easy, but they are also not new.
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2699862/div>
NJ Privacy laws
http://go-to-hellman.blogspot.com/2014/09/online-bookstores-to-face-stringent.html
http://go-to-hellm an.blogspot.com/2014/09/emergency-governor-christie-could-turn.html
Nonetheless, there are library records privacy laws in place in NJ that should apply.
EFF is misleading; I don't think the California Reader Privacy Act applies to this case, though the CA library records privacy law Cal Gov Code ยง 6267 should make this illegal./div>
flp.mobi is coming down
More on EMP domain registration
EMP registering domain names
Re: Thanks for the Mention
Why do you make it hard to get the CC0 books and ask people to buy them on Amazon? Or maybe the better question is why should readers patronize an author AND buy their books?/div>
Techdirt has not posted any stories submitted by gluejar.
Submit a story now.
Tools & Services
TwitterFacebook
RSS
Podcast
Research & Reports
Company
About UsAdvertising Policies
Privacy
Contact
Help & FeedbackMedia Kit
Sponsor/Advertise
Submit a Story
More
Copia InstituteInsider Shop
Support Techdirt