Chosen Reject's Favorite Techdirt Stories Of The Week
from the don't-reject-these dept
Welcome to my little soiree, hosted graciously by The Mazburglar, who I'm sure copied the keys to this place using some illegal number his friends at Big Search found for him. Unfortunately, the hors d'oevres are harder to copy, so you'll have to be content with cake and other such lies.
I'll start off with introductions. I'm The Chosen Reject. If you google my nom de plume, you'll find that I am not alone in being a Nirvana fan. To pay for my own bread and circuses, I develop software. Since introductions are done, let's skip ahead to the entertainment in this repastless fete.
I'm a believer in the free market, and using government regulation only where necessary to obtain that free market (such as laws against fraud, false advertising, antitrust, etc). An important aspect of keeping markets free are low barriers to entry. Which is exactly what the government doesn't do when it grants monopolies, whether those are for electrical service, internet service, or the so called intellectual property laws.
But I don't see the free market as the end unto itself, but mostly a means to better the public good. That is why I'll allow encroachments onto the free market if those encroachments actually do the public any good, which is what I believe the free market does. But if those encroachments don't do the public any good, then they need to be eliminated and shunned. Now you might know why I feel the way I do about IP. I'll allow for it, if it helps the public good, but it ought to be done away with if it doesn't help.
With that being said, let's look at all the reasons from just this week why copyright laws ought to be abandoned for sake of the public good:
- Universal Uses Copyright To Censor Bad Lip Reading Parody; Why Not Embrace It?: In which a government granted monopolist ignores the parody exception in the very same laws that granted it the monopoly it has.
- The Many Killers Of The Film Industry: Volumes One through Keep 'em Coming: In which we learn, yet again, the many ways that the government granted monopolists freak out when others help them.
- EU Politician Wants Internet Surveillance Built Into Every Operating System: In which we learn that an idiot somehow got elected. More seriously, we learn that some people would like to ignore reality, and would really like everyone to be tracked at all times just in case someone might do something that a government granted monopolist might freak about. Keep in mind that we already learned that they'll freak out about anything, even if it helps them.
- House Trying To Rush Through Its Version Of PROTECT IP; Tech Industry Asks Why?: In which we learn, yet again, that politicians don't put much weight into what they actually say.
- UK Court Upholds Its First Web Censorship Order: BT Has 14 Days To Block Access To Newzbin2 & Gets To Pay For The Privilege: In which we learn, yet again, that some judges choose censorship of the public at all costs because the government granted a monopoly at the cost to the public. Lots of costs, none of them actually being paid by the government granted monopolists.
- Comcast, Verizon Ordered To ID Subscribers In Copyright Trolling Suit: In which we learn that some judges see extortion as preferable to violating the government granted monopolies, whether or not the monopolist suffered any harm through said violation.
- Hollywood's Kinder, Gentler DRM: UltraViolet, Getting Slammed In Reviews: In which we learn, yet again, that monopolists tend not to care about their customers, much less the general public, and will screw you even when you pay them money. Wait, isn't that the definition of an illegal act?
- High Prices, Lack Of Availability Driving Lots Of Infringement: In which we learn that the general public actually likes to support artists and even their chosen middlemen, so long as the stuff they want is available and affordable. These are things the free market tends to be good at. Monopolies? Not so much.
- PROTECT IP Renamed E-PARASITE Act; Would Create The Great Firewall Of America: In which we learn that all bad names will be outdone, and that you need to make the check out to Lamar Smith.
- Leading French Presidential Candidate Would Repeal HADOPI But Keep Net Surveillance: In which we learn that some politicians have listened to the public, but have decided that the surveillance put in place for copyright sure is nice to have. It's like copyright law is a gateway drug.
- Warner Bros. Hates Libraries, Wants To Embargo DVD Sales To Libraries For A Month: In which we learn that Warner Bros really does not want any one to see their stuff for 28 days. It's OK, I'm happy to oblige them.
- Just As Valve Shows That You Can Compete With Piracy In Russia, Russia Starts Cracking Down On Piracy: In which we learn, yet again, that providing what the customers want at the price they find reasonable actually means the customer will give you money in a mutually pleasing transaction.
- Hardware Store That Doesn't Play Any Music Has To Fight Off Collection Society Demanding A License Fee: In which we learn, yet again, that when given the power and legal justification to extort money from anyone, many people will take it.
- How Copyright Infringement Turned Vampires Into Big Business: In which we learn, yet again, that copyright harms society, but ignoring copyright helps to create new and interesting works, like Nosferatu, Count Chocula, and Twilight. Wait...maybe I should reconsider.
- Rep. Blackburn, Co-Sponsor Of E-PARASITE, Explains Why Regulating The Internet Is Terrible: In which we learn, yet again, that politicians don't put much weight into what they actually say. That sounds really familiar.
Patents also took some time this week to show that they also can be abused. So let's take a moment to see why patents ought to be abandoned for sake of the public good:
- US Trying To Force Governments To Pay Much Higher Prices For Needed Drugs Through Secretive TPP: Here we have a situation where publicly funded research is locked up by the government so that monopolists can charge higher prices to the public that funded them. This wasn't enough, so the monopolists are getting the government to jack up prices to the citizens of other countries that didn't fund that research.
- Failed Company, Now Patent Troll, Sues Apple Over Transferrable Playlists For A Third Time: An interesting case where Apple finally listened to CmdTaco's 10 year old request and added wireless syncing, but gets sued for it.
- Jay Walker Continues Quest To Sue The Internet Into Oblivion With Patents: Jay Walker (arrest that man) has decided that without his awesome abilities that no one had heard of until recently that no one would have ever figured out how to display ads on the internet.
Not to be outdone, monopolists have even taken the consumer protection laws known as Trademark law, and turned it around, not just to hurt the public, but even to hurt the very customers businesses strive for. Let's take a look.
- Sony Ericsson Shows How Not To Connect With Fans: Forces Shutdown Of Xperia Fan Blog: Because, if you're a true fan, you won't talk about our products using our name.
- ICE Seized 20 Domain Names For The NFL Over The Weekend: Because a true fan of our teams would only buy the properly licensed, higher priced goods, whether or not they could afford them.
Finally, let's not sit around thinking that government granted monopolists are the only idiots in this world looking to make life worse for the public. Heavens no. The biggest, meanest monopolists of all are sure to want to get their share of the fun. And of course, we're talking about governments.
- State Government In Australia Seeks To Issue $12k Fines If You Insult Its Gaming Minister Michael O'Brien: This is justifaction for the US Bill of Rights. Some of the founding fathers feared that a Bill of Rights would mean the government would think that only those rights existed. Thankfully some knew that governments already think the public's rights have to be explicity stated if they want to have a right. Sorry Australia, you can't say anything mean about Michael O'Brien, like that he's a thin-skinned idiot, a weasily malcontent, and a pompous ninny.
- Court Tells Users They Can't Use RECAP: Heaven forbid that you make public domain materials available freely to others.
- California Politician Discovers That You Can't Ban Specific Type Of Music; Admits 'I Didn't Know What Was Going On': I think ravers are weird, but a politician that thinks it's OK to ban certain types of music is even weirder. No, that's not the word. Par for the course is what I meant. One that thinks banning things like binkies and LED gloves will prevent kids from drug overdoses is really odd. Dang it, I meant the norm. A politician that doesn't know what they were doing is right out. And by that I mean, the usual. And one that admits it is quite ordinary. I mean, down right strange. Kudos to admitting it Fiona Ma, but you should have used that as your first clue that continuing on with your legislation wasn't actually going to do anything.
- Justice Department Wants To Be Able To Lie In Response To Freedom Of Information Requests: Why in the world would we expect our government, the Department of Justice no less, to be honest with us? That's just crazy think-of-the-public nonsense.
- Google Reveals 70% Increase In Requests For Content Removal; Including Law Enforcement Wanting To Hide Police Brutality: Of course, no list of abusers of monopoly power would be complete without those who have the monopoly on violence. Thank you for trying to protect my weak sensibilities from having to see you beat, injure, maim and kill others in your quest for more power to abuse.
- The Non-Existent 'Cyber War' Is Nothing More Than A Push For More Government Control: I wonder when they'll quit trying to be quaint, and just tell us we're at war with the public.
So there you have it. My list. But I don't want to be the sole life of our little party, so comment away down below.
Thank you for reading this Techdirt post. With so many things competing for everyone’s attention these days, we really appreciate you giving us your time. We work hard every day to put quality content out there for our community.
Techdirt is one of the few remaining truly independent media outlets. We do not have a giant corporation behind us, and we rely heavily on our community to support us, in an age when advertisers are increasingly uninterested in sponsoring small, independent sites — especially a site like ours that is unwilling to pull punches in its reporting and analysis.
While other websites have resorted to paywalls, registration requirements, and increasingly annoying/intrusive advertising, we have always kept Techdirt open and available to anyone. But in order to continue doing so, we need your support. We offer a variety of ways for our readers to support us, from direct donations to special subscriptions and cool merchandise — and every little bit helps. Thank you.
–The Techdirt Team
Reader Comments
Subscribe: RSS
View by: Time | Thread
tl;dr
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
Or not.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Re:
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Re: Re:
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
The favourite post articles do seem to be ballooning in size these weeks ...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Those aren't reasons... those are just opinion posts on a blog.
Perhaps next time you get asked you can just post "everything on Techdirt" and get it over with.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
Heh. Well, nobody's surprised that you don't associate opinion with reason.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Our Government isn't protecting us, it is protecting itself from us. A truelly open and free society would render them almost un-needed. Wouldn't that be nice.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
As if they know the side effects...
I think we should tap into this pinhead's systems and publish every thing that he/she does to the net and post it on the NYTimes and other major news sites. I think they will change their tune very quickly...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Great post
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
It is nice to find someone who shares the idea that the current system is broken and harming the people. That we do need some laws but we need to reexamine the way they are being used and how it is harming what they claim it is to protect.
There is nothing wrong with a business making money, so long as it is not at the expense of everyone else.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re:
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Re:
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Free Market
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Free Market
Well maybe in some of the isolated parts of the world where trading beads or a fish will get you cured.
But not around here.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Twenty Six!!?
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: Twenty Six!!?
But then I'm one to talk, my favorites list included a story from another site.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
I love SciFi, I also suspect I may like it to the point to be called hardcore.
So once I tried to find Earth 2, an oldie but goodie one(at least for me), I couldn't find it for sell and I couldn't find it to rent, well guess were I found that one, you guessed, I found it on the pirates side of the fence.
By no means that is the only one, there are many others that I found that way, including some that I have never heard off before.
They say piracy is bad, they say it is immoral, they called me a thief, but I'm not the one expecting to get life + 95 years of a evil granted monopoly, I'm not the one with the power to tell others what they could do with what they bought, I'm not the one putting DRM's in everything that annoys everyone, I'm not the one asking for money but calls everyone who hands you some a thief, is not me who sue children, mothers, teenagers, old people and even the dead, it was not me using those laws to create a extortion scheme that resembles so much Nigerian scams that even the scammers are doing it now, it is not me who closes venues for starting artists, the only thing I'm guilty of is being a dirty pirate that copies and share what he found with others, that is right the only thing I do is copy and share and somehow I'm evil too, well at least I take comfort in the knowledge that my little evil is nothing compared to what I see entertainment executives trying to do to their customers.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
My AT&T DSL line had some kind of weird DNS issue or transmission delay something that I could never resolve. For example, it would take 30 seconds (or more, I never timed it) for a Youtube video to start. Every Youtube video. Every time. And lest you think they had something against Youtube, trying to navigate my credit card account site was a lesson in frustration. And lest you think it was because the site was having problems, a) it happened all year and b) I was able to VNC into my work computer and access the same site, at the same time, quickly and with ease. Funny thing is, once it started it was fine. Once the page started loading it loaded quickly. Just took three forevers to go from a mouse click to actually doing something.
I never did figure out WTF the problem was.
So after my year's contract was up I carefully studied the list of alternatives:
- Comcast
I've got Comcast now, and let me tell you, 12mb is blazing. It's a damned shame the latency is over 800ms and the packet loss is about 80%. Oh, not all the time. Just when I'm trying to play Team Fortress online. Sometimes. At random. Good luck trying to get tech support on "random, usually at night and worst at night on weekends".
Of course I've tried an new modem and had a technician out and reset my modem and router about a dozen times and rewired my network and bypassed the router. I'm still in the process of trying to definitively determine if it's the router. It's an expensive router, but an old one. One of the problems is, of course, if I switch from one internal connection to another, I have to power-cycle the modem, because it WILL NOT SERVE UP AN IP ADDRESS twice in a row. Any other DHCP server in the world will do that, but not Comcast's. So there's no way to, say, swap my laptop in for my router and see if the problem persists, without power-cycling the modem.
Two monopolies in the area, nothing else, and you know their customer service is amazing because, well, they've forgotten what customer service is. When you call the only thing they know how to do is reset the modem and, oh, by the way, power-cycle EVERYTHING IN YOUR HOUSE. Including the refrigerator. Release/renew isn't good enough. Oh right, their DHCP server sucks balls, I forgot about that.
Well, I suppose I could just move. Yeah, just like that, it's easy, right? And it's not like I'm in the capitol city of the most populous, and one of the highest tech, states in the US. No, I'm stuck here in the sticks, here in Sacramento, CA. Heck, we even have trees here! Somewhere. I'll have to drive around a while to find it, but I know there's one around somewhere.
I don't know if having real competition would actually cause Comcast and AT&T to actually pay attention to their customers and provide a good, high-quality experience. What I do know is that not having competition has not enabled them to give their customers a good, high quality experience, and it means that here in the benighted and remote hamlet of Sacramento, California I do not have any options (aside from moving... where? Rhode Island?) other than putting up with the incompetence and indifference of two monopoly giants, because the two of them are the Only Game In Town and no consumer advocacy or regulatory organizations actually gives a rat's ass whether they apply Vaseline before they screw me or not.
P.S. They don't actually appear to understand the difference between latency and bandwidth, because every time I talk latency, they go on and on about my bandwidth. Oh, and their tech support people lie. Blatantly and unapologetically.
P.P.S. I just tried to find a US state-by-state bandwidth report I saw last night, but I can't find it now. But here's another. You'd think high-tech California would be near the top, right? Nope. Guess who is? No, go on, you'll never guess. Yep, the aforementioned Rhode Island. Hey, you know, when I think "high tech Internet" I think "Rhode Island". OK, I'm making fun, I'm not suggesting RI is 3rd world or something. But it wouldn't have been my first guess. You know where CA is? 35. Wow, 30th percentile, go us! Our motto: "We don't suck as bad as some other states."
I dunno, maybe it's time to reconnect with my New England roots? Oh hey, our new CA state motto: "We just got our asses kicked by the smallest state in the US."
P.P.P.S. I'm thinking about replacing the router (a Sonicwall TZ 190) in spite of the fact that I don't actually think it's the router. I was looking at this nice Asus as a possible replacement.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
too many bureaucrats...
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Re: too many bureaucrats...
ICE is currently making sure they deport at least 400K people a year so they can keep their current level of funding. They could prepare a nice report on all of the other things they do, but nothing screams louder to the people with the purse strings than handing them the ability to say we go rid of all the dangerous brown people who stole your job.
Congress exists to keep themselves in office, and the money they get from the "donations" of corporations speaks louder than anything else. They have made themselves immune from the laws they seek to impose on everyone else and live in a fantasyland.
I saw Warren Buffett's idea for fixing Congress, I just wish we could get more people to think of the greater good rather than their own pet concerns and make it happen.
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/10/25/1029793/-28th-Amendment:-Warren-Buffetts-How-to- fix-Congress
[ link to this | view in chronology ]
Thou MUST love your gub'ment
This is just one of many examples. Obozo wants the same thing for healthcare. Gub'ment run healthcare with death panels will destroy that industry too.
[ link to this | view in chronology ]