Chosen Reject’s Techdirt Profile

About Chosen Reject

Posted on Techdirt - 29 October 2011 @ 12:00pm

Chosen Reject's Favorite Techdirt Stories Of The Week

from the don't-reject-these dept

Welcome to my little soiree, hosted graciously by The Mazburglar, who I'm sure copied the keys to this place using some illegal number his friends at Big Search found for him. Unfortunately, the hors d'oevres are harder to copy, so you'll have to be content with cake and other such lies.

I'll start off with introductions. I'm The Chosen Reject. If you google my nom de plume, you'll find that I am not alone in being a Nirvana fan. To pay for my own bread and circuses, I develop software. Since introductions are done, let's skip ahead to the entertainment in this repastless fete.

I'm a believer in the free market, and using government regulation only where necessary to obtain that free market (such as laws against fraud, false advertising, antitrust, etc). An important aspect of keeping markets free are low barriers to entry. Which is exactly what the government doesn't do when it grants monopolies, whether those are for electrical service, internet service, or the so called intellectual property laws.

But I don't see the free market as the end unto itself, but mostly a means to better the public good. That is why I'll allow encroachments onto the free market if those encroachments actually do the public any good, which is what I believe the free market does. But if those encroachments don't do the public any good, then they need to be eliminated and shunned. Now you might know why I feel the way I do about IP. I'll allow for it, if it helps the public good, but it ought to be done away with if it doesn't help.

With that being said, let's look at all the reasons from just this week why copyright laws ought to be abandoned for sake of the public good:

Universal Uses Copyright To Censor Bad Lip Reading Parody; Why Not Embrace It?: In which a government granted monopolist ignores the parody exception in the very same laws that granted it the monopoly it has.
The Many Killers Of The Film Industry: Volumes One through Keep 'em Coming: In which we learn, yet again, the many ways that the government granted monopolists freak out when others help them.
EU Politician Wants Internet Surveillance Built Into Every Operating System: In which we learn that an idiot somehow got elected. More seriously, we learn that some people would like to ignore reality, and would really like everyone to be tracked at all times just in case someone might do something that a government granted monopolist might freak about. Keep in mind that we already learned that they'll freak out about anything, even if it helps them.
House Trying To Rush Through Its Version Of PROTECT IP; Tech Industry Asks Why?: In which we learn, yet again, that politicians don't put much weight into what they actually say.
UK Court Upholds Its First Web Censorship Order: BT Has 14 Days To Block Access To Newzbin2 & Gets To Pay For The Privilege: In which we learn, yet again, that some judges choose censorship of the public at all costs because the government granted a monopoly at the cost to the public. Lots of costs, none of them actually being paid by the government granted monopolists.
Comcast, Verizon Ordered To ID Subscribers In Copyright Trolling Suit: In which we learn that some judges see extortion as preferable to violating the government granted monopolies, whether or not the monopolist suffered any harm through said violation.
Hollywood's Kinder, Gentler DRM: UltraViolet, Getting Slammed In Reviews: In which we learn, yet again, that monopolists tend not to care about their customers, much less the general public, and will screw you even when you pay them money. Wait, isn't that the definition of an illegal act?
High Prices, Lack Of Availability Driving Lots Of Infringement: In which we learn that the general public actually likes to support artists and even their chosen middlemen, so long as the stuff they want is available and affordable. These are things the free market tends to be good at. Monopolies? Not so much.
PROTECT IP Renamed E-PARASITE Act; Would Create The Great Firewall Of America: In which we learn that all bad names will be outdone, and that you need to make the check out to Lamar Smith.
Leading French Presidential Candidate Would Repeal HADOPI But Keep Net Surveillance: In which we learn that some politicians have listened to the public, but have decided that the surveillance put in place for copyright sure is nice to have. It's like copyright law is a gateway drug.
Warner Bros. Hates Libraries, Wants To Embargo DVD Sales To Libraries For A Month: In which we learn that Warner Bros really does not want any one to see their stuff for 28 days. It's OK, I'm happy to oblige them.
Just As Valve Shows That You Can Compete With Piracy In Russia, Russia Starts Cracking Down On Piracy: In which we learn, yet again, that providing what the customers want at the price they find reasonable actually means the customer will give you money in a mutually pleasing transaction.
Hardware Store That Doesn't Play Any Music Has To Fight Off Collection Society Demanding A License Fee: In which we learn, yet again, that when given the power and legal justification to extort money from anyone, many people will take it.
How Copyright Infringement Turned Vampires Into Big Business: In which we learn, yet again, that copyright harms society, but ignoring copyright helps to create new and interesting works, like Nosferatu, Count Chocula, and Twilight. Wait...maybe I should reconsider.
Rep. Blackburn, Co-Sponsor Of E-PARASITE, Explains Why Regulating The Internet Is Terrible: In which we learn, yet again, that politicians don't put much weight into what they actually say. That sounds really familiar.

Patents also took some time this week to show that they also can be abused. So let's take a moment to see why patents ought to be abandoned for sake of the public good:

US Trying To Force Governments To Pay Much Higher Prices For Needed Drugs Through Secretive TPP: Here we have a situation where publicly funded research is locked up by the government so that monopolists can charge higher prices to the public that funded them. This wasn't enough, so the monopolists are getting the government to jack up prices to the citizens of other countries that didn't fund that research.
Failed Company, Now Patent Troll, Sues Apple Over Transferrable Playlists For A Third Time: An interesting case where Apple finally listened to CmdTaco's 10 year old request and added wireless syncing, but gets sued for it.
Jay Walker Continues Quest To Sue The Internet Into Oblivion With Patents: Jay Walker (arrest that man) has decided that without his awesome abilities that no one had heard of until recently that no one would have ever figured out how to display ads on the internet.

Not to be outdone, monopolists have even taken the consumer protection laws known as Trademark law, and turned it around, not just to hurt the public, but even to hurt the very customers businesses strive for. Let's take a look.

Sony Ericsson Shows How Not To Connect With Fans: Forces Shutdown Of Xperia Fan Blog: Because, if you're a true fan, you won't talk about our products using our name.
ICE Seized 20 Domain Names For The NFL Over The Weekend: Because a true fan of our teams would only buy the properly licensed, higher priced goods, whether or not they could afford them.

Finally, let's not sit around thinking that government granted monopolists are the only idiots in this world looking to make life worse for the public. Heavens no. The biggest, meanest monopolists of all are sure to want to get their share of the fun. And of course, we're talking about governments.

State Government In Australia Seeks To Issue $12k Fines If You Insult Its Gaming Minister Michael O'Brien: This is justifaction for the US Bill of Rights. Some of the founding fathers feared that a Bill of Rights would mean the government would think that only those rights existed. Thankfully some knew that governments already think the public's rights have to be explicity stated if they want to have a right. Sorry Australia, you can't say anything mean about Michael O'Brien, like that he's a thin-skinned idiot, a weasily malcontent, and a pompous ninny.
Court Tells Users They Can't Use RECAP: Heaven forbid that you make public domain materials available freely to others.
California Politician Discovers That You Can't Ban Specific Type Of Music; Admits 'I Didn't Know What Was Going On': I think ravers are weird, but a politician that thinks it's OK to ban certain types of music is even weirder. No, that's not the word. Par for the course is what I meant. One that thinks banning things like binkies and LED gloves will prevent kids from drug overdoses is really odd. Dang it, I meant the norm. A politician that doesn't know what they were doing is right out. And by that I mean, the usual. And one that admits it is quite ordinary. I mean, down right strange. Kudos to admitting it Fiona Ma, but you should have used that as your first clue that continuing on with your legislation wasn't actually going to do anything.
Justice Department Wants To Be Able To Lie In Response To Freedom Of Information Requests: Why in the world would we expect our government, the Department of Justice no less, to be honest with us? That's just crazy think-of-the-public nonsense.
Google Reveals 70% Increase In Requests For Content Removal; Including Law Enforcement Wanting To Hide Police Brutality: Of course, no list of abusers of monopoly power would be complete without those who have the monopoly on violence. Thank you for trying to protect my weak sensibilities from having to see you beat, injure, maim and kill others in your quest for more power to abuse.
The Non-Existent 'Cyber War' Is Nothing More Than A Push For More Government Control: I wonder when they'll quit trying to be quaint, and just tell us we're at war with the public.

So there you have it. My list. But I don't want to be the sole life of our little party, so comment away down below.

25 Comments

Chosen Reject’s Comments

Jan 29th, 2015 @ 10:45am

Re: Re: Better than the alternative..

on You Don't Own What You Bought: Drone Maker Updates Firmware On All Drones To Stop Any Flights In DC

You don't need to jailbreak it. There are all sorts of flight controllers (even open source ones) that are available. You simply replace it.

My understanding is that this is not the first time DJI has added a no-fly zone in its flight controller. You also can't fly over the forbidden city with the Naza flight controller (by DJI). In fact, they have a whole list of no fly-zones preprogrammed into their FCs:

http://www.dji.com/fly-safe/category-mc
Dec 11th, 2014 @ 12:05pm

Re: wat

on Dick Cheney Says CIA Torture Report Is 'Full Of Crap' -- Then Admits He Hasn't Read It

A sad thing is that the people that did kill thousands of Americans suffered less than the people the CIA tortured. Heck, even if the hijackers had survived (say they did it by installing remote control autopilot or something), and had been caught, they would have had a trial, been convicted, and been sentenced to either life in prison (solitary confinement being likely) or sentenced to death. Sure, dead is dead, but torture is pain. Every one of the victims of the CIA's torture probably wished for death at some point. Some tried to get there by starving themselves.
Dec 10th, 2014 @ 2:06pm

Good ol' Guvnah Tarkin

on GCHQ Follows NSA Into Paranoia -- Just As Julian Assange Predicted

I'd say Leia (or Lucas) had it called much earlier
The more you tighten your grip, Tarkin, the more star systems will slip through your fingers.
Aug 5th, 2014 @ 8:45am

Re:

on Randy Queen Keeps Digging: Issues DMCA Takedown On Blog Post About Him Issuing DMCA Takedowns

Said the kettle to the pot:

There are people and animals suffering and dying in the world, and real human rights issues in certain countries, and this is what you take issue with? Someone showing and commenting on pictures that are nearly two decades old? I think there are greater causes to champion with the limited time and energy we are given on this Earth.
Jul 2nd, 2014 @ 1:15pm

Users and Rights holders

on SoundCloud Has Given Universal Music Group The Ability To Directly Remove Content

What I like most about SoundCloud's statement is that they automatically consider users and rights holders separate and distinct entities. Up until now, I thought the assumption was supposed to be that their uploading users were the rights holders. This shows how SoundCloud feels about its users.

SoundCloud better hope UMG doesn't use that statement to show in some court that SoundCloud has always intended uploaders to not upload their own content.
Jan 14th, 2014 @ 4:13pm

(untitled comment)

on Court Rules That Woman Wrongfully Placed On No Fly List Should Be Taken Off The List... We Think

without prejudice to future adjustments based on new information
Unfortunately for her, new information has just been obtained. It has recently come to light that she prevailed in a case against the DHS. If we allow that to continue to happen, the DHS will become weaker, allowing terrorists to bomb us fortnightly. Therefore, she is a threat to our national security and is hereby placed on the no-fly list.

It's truth. It's not retributional at all. We even signed a promise to that, but we can't let you see it for security reasons.
Dec 19th, 2013 @ 9:36am

Re: I knew it

on Oklahoma Cops Think Falling Glitter Might Be A Biochemical Attack, Book Protesters On 'Terrorist Hoax' Charges When It Isn't

As the father of two single-digit-aged girls, I would gladly vote for any politician who ran on a platform of banning glitter. It does not matter how often you clean up, that stuff shows up in weird places years later.
Dec 9th, 2013 @ 12:11pm

Re: Re:

on AT&T Tells Shareholders To Mind Their Own Business Concerning Its Relationship With The NSA

The telcos don't whine to the government to get money. They just promise to do things they have no intention of ever doing, and the government pays them. Lather, rinse, repeat.

The telcos are happy to hand over data to the NSA for lots of reasons, one of which is they get paid to do it. I'm sure they also do it either to keep getting the boondoggles I mentioned previously, or to keep those boondoggles from being spoken about too much in Congress.

I'd wager that a sizable portion of the telcos revenue doesn't come from actual customers, but from defrauding the government and the government spying on its citizens.
Nov 21st, 2013 @ 10:45am

(untitled comment)

on Massive Man-in-the-Middle Attacks Have Been Hijacking Huge Amounts Of Internet Traffic And Almost No One Noticed

I agree that Alexander's two positions are opposed to each other. He seems to have preferred the NSA one over the cyber security one. Would he suggest city walls are bad since they make it more difficult to see all angles of where the enemy might be coming from?
Oct 1st, 2013 @ 12:45pm

(untitled comment)

on Furloughed Federal Workers Can't Check Their Email... But Don't Worry, The NSA Can Still Check Yours

Of course it won't affect the NSA's surveillance programs. They don't have surveillance programs.
Jun 19th, 2013 @ 2:55pm

Re: Re: Re: Re:

on The Next Time Someone Says Twitter Is Killing Deep Thinking With Short Quick Messages, Show Them This

Wow, you didn't get my comment at all. Perhaps you should spend some more time reading and thinking.

The key word is independently. If some Amazonian tribal guy with no education to speak of wrote a book about how he independently discovered some new mathematical model that is really just calculus as we understand it, nobody would care, even though he would need the same mental genius as Newton. In fact, this happened. See Leibniz. We don't judge people for how smart they are. We judge them by how novel they are. Newton did it first, therefore he is a genius. Some guy does it second, but independently, and we don't care.

Mental geniuses from centuries ago had a level of genius to make a leap to understand things we take for granted now. Nobody needs to make these leaps anymore, but that doesn't mean nobody could. Many people are making further leaps, but their leaps are in such specialized fields that we, as a society, can't even begin to appreciate it because understanding those leaps is beyond us.

Or you know, everyone is dumb nowadays. Except you of course.
Jun 19th, 2013 @ 2:32pm

Re: Re:

on The Next Time Someone Says Twitter Is Killing Deep Thinking With Short Quick Messages, Show Them This

And all those mental giants got the low hanging fruit. If someone today independently came up with Newton's laws, we would ignore them completely rather than praising them for their understanding. We have mental giants today who are getting the next lowest level of fruit, but they are harder to recognize because their fields are necessarily more specialized.
Jun 14th, 2013 @ 10:47am

Re:

on Leaked: NSA's Talking Points Defending NSA Surveillance

I'm honestly really surprised that none of the leaked talking points had anything to do with milk. It looks like you've gone rogue.
Jun 13th, 2013 @ 2:23pm

(untitled comment)

on Lawsuit Filed To Prove Happy Birthday Is In The Public Domain; Demands Warner Pay Back Millions Of License Fees

I've been thinking about doing the same thing with Steamboat Willie. Unfortunately, I don't have the money. I wonder where the GMTY people are getting their funds. Wherever they're getting it, I hope it doesn't run out. That will probably be Warner/Chappell's biggest tactic.
Jun 13th, 2013 @ 12:27pm

Re: Emulating Obama's leadership style

on DoD: If You See A Leaked NSA Document, Press SHIFT And DELETE To Get Rid Of It

This is used to weed out the bad guys. Those who report it are obviously not getting all of their news directly from DoD-approved filtered news services and are thus put on a watch list.
Jun 13th, 2013 @ 10:44am

Re:

on Feds May Have To Reveal FISA Phone Records In Murder Case

You have it backwards. If he can show his phone being somewhere else, then the DoJ now has to show that he didn't have his phone. The guy's not been convicted yet. The government has to show that beyond a reasonable doubt he was there committing a crime. If he shows that his phone wasn't there, and that it was involved in making phone calls, that makes the government's job harder.

The guy could be guilty. He could also be telling the truth that he wasn't there. Let's let due process do it's thing. If he's guilty and walks, that sucks. But that's better, IMO, than him being innocent while not being able to show some exculpatory evidence because the NSA would prefer to keep their secret surveillance secret for longer.

Presumed innocent until proven guilty. Let due process work. Make the prosecution do it's job of proving guilt. Let the defendant show his evidence.
Jun 10th, 2013 @ 12:35pm

Re: Re:

on Anonymous Participant Who Drew Attention To Steubenville Rape May Face More Years In Jail Than Rapists

I'm not a fan of lynch mobs of any sort, because they tend to react emotionally and are prone to go much farther than a reasoned protest.
I too am against what the lynch mob did here. If only there was a way to reign in the FBI so they won't overreact next time.
Jun 10th, 2013 @ 12:19pm

Re:

on How Can NSA Surveillance Leaks Both Be No Big Deal And Put Us All In Danger?

It's true...if you figure that most folks involved in terrorist activity include all the FBI-created "terrorists".
Jun 5th, 2013 @ 4:52pm

Re: Has anyone been sued or prosecuted for this?

on Help Explain Why Phone Unlocking Is Important To You And Why It Should Be Legal

There are all sorts of things that affect only a small portion of the population, and most people just don't care. That doesn't make it right.

A law that bans all Welsh immigrants to the US from ever being granted a small business license would be "important only to a small number of [Welsh entrepeneur]-weenies, while nearly everyone else doesn't worry about it". That hypothetical law would still be wrong.

You're also wrong that they are looking for evidence. The position is solid without anecdotes. What they are looking for is human stories that make it more understandable for congresspersons. That's completely different. Taking the example above, I don't need to know a single Welsh entrepeneur to know that a law barring them from starting businesses is wrong. But if I had an actual example of it harming someone that would make it easier to overturn that hypothetical law.
Jun 5th, 2013 @ 1:56pm

(untitled comment)

on Irony Alert: John Steele Denies Uploading Anything Ever Despite Growing IP Evidence

The great part about this is that every step he takes to prove it wasn't him actually helps the defendants and anyone else accused of downloading.

More comments from Chosen Reject >>

Chosen Reject’s Techdirt Profile

About Chosen Reject

Chosen Reject's Favorite Techdirt Stories Of The Week

from the don't-reject-these dept

Chosen Reject’s Comments

Re: Re: Better than the alternative..

Re: wat

Good ol' Guvnah Tarkin

Re:

Users and Rights holders

(untitled comment)

Re: I knew it

Re: Re:

(untitled comment)

(untitled comment)

Re: Re: Re: Re:

Re: Re:

Re:

(untitled comment)

Re: Emulating Obama's leadership style

Re:

Re: Re:

Re:

Re: Has anyone been sued or prosecuted for this?

(untitled comment)

Tools & Services

Company

Contact

More